Read the following situation and answer the questions. by kelvin cadena https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq 1. Alan Jones, aged 78, had a second stroke three weeks ago. He has severe brain damage and his condition is getting worse. At the request of his daughter, a nurse stops giving him oxygen until his heart stops. The nurse then starts giving oxygen again. People think that Mr Jones died naturally. Later, Mr jones'daughter tells a friend what happened. The friend is married to a police officer. As a result, the police charge the nurse with murder. Do you feel that the nurse has committed a crime? Do you feel that the daughter has committed a crime? What punishments, if any, should be given? en-us 2023-11-29 14:22:32 UTC 2023-12-11 14:45:56 UTC hello@padlet.com ffranciscosebastian1 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2807474883 Hi Kelvin

]]> 2023-11-29 14:33:08 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2807474883 The nurse hasn't committed a crime, for that reason she doesn't deserve a punishment lazogabriel456 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821102866 2023-12-11 14:38:16 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821102866 No punishment https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821104495 2023-12-11 14:39:29 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821104495 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821109204 I don't think the nurse committed a crime due to it was a request of Alan's daughter, and she give her permission. Also, I don't think the daughter has committed a crime, because maybe she did it for to prevent his father from continuing to suffer

]]> 2023-12-11 14:42:41 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821109204 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821109811

  1. Do you think the nurse committed a crime?

No, she only did what she was asked to do.

  1. Do you think the daughter committed a crime?

Neither because the patient was dying anyway.

  1. What penalties should be imposed?

None

]]> 2023-12-11 14:43:00 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821109811 Doménica García domeprisioner https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821109821 No, the nurse did not commit any crime because it was the request of the patient's daughter to withdraw the oxygen.

The daughter did not commit a crime because she allowed her father to rest in peace.

On the contrary, euthanasia should be legal depending on cases like this.

]]> 2023-12-11 14:43:00 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821109821 gl054959 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110317 I think that anyone have committed a crime.The daughter’s decision was a good way to stop the health problem of Mr. Jones

]]> 2023-12-11 14:43:20 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110317 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110327 Neither committed a crime because the daughter decided what was best and the nurse's main rule is to preserve life.

No punishment

]]> 2023-12-11 14:43:21 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110327 Bryan https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110474 Is a crime because she didn't ask to his family to do it

]]> 2023-12-11 14:43:24 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110474 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110979 Taking someone's life, even in the context of medical decisions, can have legal implications. It would be best to consult with legal professionals to discuss the specifics of this case.

]]> 2023-12-11 14:43:44 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821110979 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821111442 I believe it appears that the nurse followed the daughter's request to stop giving Alan Jones oxygen until his heart stopped, and then resumed giving him oxygen. So, whether the nurse's actions can be considered a crime depends on the legal and ethical aspects.

]]> 2023-12-11 14:44:00 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821111442 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821112397 I believe that the daughter thought it was the best for her father but since it was perhaps not allowed, she did what she did, but it is the daughter's fault.

]]> 2023-12-11 14:44:37 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821112397 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821114536 No, I think not because the man was already sick and I think the best thing was to disconnect him because it was already recorded.

]]> 2023-12-11 14:45:51 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821114536 https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821114669 Do you think the nurse has committed a crime?

No because the nurse did what the daughter asked her to do, in her condition it was the best option.

Do you think the daughter has committed a crime?

No because Alan was not improving and surviving would have been left with a problem.

What penalties, if any, should be imposed?

None because in my opinion it is the best thing to do when a person is suffering more than they should be.

]]> 2023-12-11 14:45:56 UTC https://padlet.com/kelvincadena1015/zrjiiuzzy2xgy0zq/wish/2821114669