On Moral Development Dilemma by Alejandro Iborra https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k en-us 2017-12-20 08:20:52 UTC 2017-12-20 10:29:16 UTC hello@padlet.com Group 4 (Andrea, Beste, Nihan, Denisa) https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432571 Our group thinks that the sister shouldn't tell the mother about Judy going to the concert, because it's not of her business and it could break the trust between sisters. 👭

Secondly, Judy deserved to go the concert, because she worked hard and saved the money, and it was her mother who changed her mind in the last moment unfairly. 💸

In case something bad had happened, we agreed that Judy's sister should tell their mother because it involves responsibility from the sister and Judy. 👩‍👧‍👧

In our opinion the interview is a mixture of our opinion and group 1 opinion. The interviewee mentions revenge and kid's way of acting to dilemmas. 👿👦👧]]> 2017-12-20 08:46:58 UTC https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432571 GROUP 2 (Diego, Patri, Irene, Gema) https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432598 We think the decission taken by the older sister depends on the relatioship she has with Judy.     The fact that the mother promissed she could go to the concert if she earned the money herself and then changed her mind in the last moment is something important to have in mind when taking a decission.

If we were the older sister, first, we would talk with Judy and tell her that she hasn't done the right thing.  Also, the sister advice is to put on her mom's shoes in order to see how she would feel.
Moreover, she should think about it and to talk about it with her mom. 

In case, the mother asks the older sister what happened that day, she would suggest talking with Judy.
--------------------------------------------------------
The main difference with our opinion is that she thinks in what the mother would have felt. ( she can think in different points of view).
On the other hand, our common point of view with the adolescent is that Judy has the right to go to the concert as she has earned her own money. 

We think she is in the stage two of moral development as she considers the fairness of the situation depending on the person.


]]> 2017-12-20 08:47:05 UTC https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432598 GROUP 5: SISTERHOOD https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432657 (Belén, Coral, Patri M., Lidia)

We are thinking about.... What is worst? Betraying the trust your sister gave to you or keeping the secret away from your mother and becoming a part of the lie...?
Here is when the dilemma comes. Taking the perspective of the older sister, we  wouldn't tell our mother because we think that the fact that your sister trusted in you has more importance than telling the truth to her mother because the mother wasn't fair with Judy at first.
In addition, we based our decision on the situation, the fact that the sister had already gone to the concert and nothing happened to her, has a very impact on it. We feel like the dilemma would have been bigger for the older sister if Judy told her BEFORE she went to the concert as if something had happened to her she would be responsible for it 

SECOND TASK
This girl  explained both points of view but she is being influenced by her own experience.
She may be in the first stage as she is appearing to be egocentric and she is confusing the real authority to her own. She wants it all and she thinks that she can get it all.
Close to it, we can find the second stage as she is understanding different points of view.

(The girl hasn't probably any kind of attachment to the members of her family so she hasn't develop any kind of moral base)]]> 2017-12-20 08:47:20 UTC https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432657 GROUP 3 https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432678 (María, Nuria, Adriana and Marta) We won't tell nothing to our mother. 
All of us think that it would be a better idea to not tell their mother because that way Judy and us would keep our confidence alive. 
Otherwise Judy would feel she can't say anything to anybody in her family. 
In this way, she would feel the support of her sister, but at the same time we should advise her about how dangerous is to do this kind of things without telling her parents. 
ON one hand, take care of our sister is important because we think is better that if she does something like that again or if she is in trouble she will tell us and we will look after if it is any problem with our parents. 
On the other hand, if we tell our parents something, Judy won't tell never more anything to anyone in the family. ]]> 2017-12-20 08:47:28 UTC https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432678 `GROUP 1: BROTHERHOOD https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432882 ( Julio, David, Jose, Kique)

We wouldn´t tell to the mother because she is your sister and maybe if you tell your mother what she did it will have consequences in the future, for example if someday you do something that your mother hasn´t aproved your sister could tell her what you have done. 

However if we were the older sister we would talk to our sister to  raise awareness her, in other words we would make sure that she knew that she did something wrong
We find this opinion similar to ours , the girl is in the 4th stage because as we cam see in the interview, see she didn't want to harm the  familiar institution, she attempts to find the best solutions to all the people who are involved in dilemma]]> 2017-12-20 08:48:31 UTC https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217432882 Group 6: REAL sisterhood https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217433175 Pilar, Sonja, Laura and Silvia
If we were the older sister we wouldn't have any dilemma. We wouldn't tell the mother about it because it is the younger sister business. Judy has trust her sister and she has to handle in her own with the issue. There is no need to get the mother angry when at this moment everyone can be happy: the mother doesn't know and Judy has already gone to the concert. Despite this, Judy has to face the consequences of the problem. 
On the other hand, it exist a link between the sister, they she the other as equals and the mother is in other level of hierarchy so they don't tell her the issues they have.
Also, Judy hopes that there is trust back to her from her sister by telling her a secret.

Comparing our justification with the teenage one we have seen some similarities and some differences. On the one hand, we both think about the role that the older sister could adopt. On the other hand, we think that she has taken the role of the good sister because, according to her own ethical principles, it was the correct option (post conventional level). However, the girl justifies that the role that the sister has adopted was for not being punished by her sibling(preconventional level).
Moreover, the girl says that Judy pursued her own interest without caring for others (preconventional level).
]]> 2017-12-20 08:50:04 UTC https://padlet.com/cuentauniversidad2010/yvlb848mok7k/wish/217433175