Cogheart - What does it mean to be human? by Yan Cooper

coopery1 — 2025-02-04 02:50:23 UTC

Do mechanicals have feelings and/or a personality?

coopery1 — 2025-02-04 02:51:26 UTC

Should mechanicals have the same rights as humans?

coopery1 — 2025-02-04 02:51:50 UTC

What does it mean to be human?

2025-02-05 01:39:36 UTC

a mech(mechanical)should have rights but not as powerful as human rights….Noah

2061855 — 2025-02-05 01:40:51 UTC

I think that robot also need to be free because if robot don’t have a liberty, that will be a repeating of racism.

2025-02-05 01:41:40 UTC

I’m not sure but, I think it’s about how the master has made it or how long it has been doing something in an order

Ayaan

2025-02-05 01:41:45 UTC

it depends if you’re as good as John hartmen at mechanics you could get some quirks in the robots/mech

2025-02-05 01:42:08 UTC

John’s mechs have a personality and feelings because Mrs Rust was humming while she was cooking 🧑‍🍳

2025-02-05 01:42:12 UTC

I’m not sure but, I think they do have feelings because Mrs.Rust was exited and serious and also Molly was crying so I think they do

2025-02-05 01:42:15 UTC

What I think is that mechanicals not having same rights as humans is technically racism for in real life people with different skin is counted as different people or it could be females not having the same rights as males anyway this is unfair for mechs so if mechs are made by humans then they should have the same privileges ( what I think )

2025-02-05 01:42:19 UTC

I think that John’s mechs have feelings and can think for themselves and have personality as in the text, Thaddeus says that John’s mechs are different from others and have quirks.

Youngung

2025-02-05 01:42:19 UTC

I think that mechanicals Have feelings because in the book Molly was crying and that is a feeling.Also she is a mechanical.

Ishanvi

2025-02-05 01:42:19 UTC

Sometimes because MRS Rust has feelings but a serving robot doesn’t.

2025-02-05 01:42:27 UTC

To be a human, it means to have a family and have blood and brains.

Sein

20621510 — 2025-02-05 01:42:31 UTC

Aadya

I’m not sure but I think that it depends on the way it was programmed. John’s mechanicals were extremely human-like. On the other hand Thaddeus said that mass produced mechanicals didn’t have personalities or weren’t human-like.

2025-02-05 01:42:33 UTC

Perhaps if the maker is good at making things and also they’re coding

2025-02-05 01:42:42 UTC

I think they should have different personalities and should not be able to do jobs.

2025-02-05 01:42:43 UTC

I think machines do not have feelings because they are deliberately made

2025-02-05 01:42:50 UTC

Yes I think mech(mechanimals) have personality because if you look at Malkin he bite Robert so we can know that mechs have personality.

Lee

2025-02-05 01:43:20 UTC

I’m not sure but i think yes because Mrs rust has feelings and i know that because she love’s Lilly more than any thing

2025-02-05 01:43:24 UTC

The mechanicals John makes have feelings but any other robots if they follow the rules then they don’t really have feelings.

2061855 — 2025-02-05 01:43:32 UTC

To be human they should be:

Can regenerate their own cells
Produce own bloods/energy to live by eating
Can hydrate by its own(they needed to)
Having organs

2025-02-05 01:43:34 UTC

To be human you must have personality traits and emotions and a soul

2025-02-05 01:43:59 UTC

Im not sure But humans need food and water robots do not human can think dor themselves robots cannot humans are born from a human robots are not…Horace

2025-02-05 01:44:07 UTC

I think John’s mechanics is very special and more alive.YAN

20621510 — 2025-02-05 01:44:09 UTC

Aadya

I think that humans and mechanicals should follow the human rights and not the robot laws because robots and mechs also need to be free. Just not all of them. Other wise be prepared for the world to be taken over by robots.

2025-02-05 01:44:15 UTC

I think that mechs should have rights but definitely not more than a human because otherwise they can technically take over the world

Ayaan

2025-02-05 01:44:22 UTC

A human has more power than robots/mechs and dose not need any winding to do stuff.

2025-02-05 01:44:26 UTC

I’m not sure but I think mechanicals have feelings because in the book ,Mrs.Rust felt sorry for Lily because John Hartman went missing/dead

2025-02-05 01:44:29 UTC

They might not have the same right but I know that they do wanna be treated the same way as human

2025-02-05 01:45:10 UTC

I think they have a feeling and a personality because when Lilly ask where are the other robots going Mrs Rust looked sad and in the book it also says Mrs Rust used to sing when she cooked that shows she’s really happy when she cooks and i also think that her personality is kind hearted because she loves Lilly like a lot because she cares for her while Lilly also loves her!

2025-02-05 01:46:04 UTC

I think mechs should be treated well like humans or that would be racist.

2025-02-05 01:46:07 UTC

I think that mechanicals and humans should be treated equally because mechs also might have personality and souls and have thinkings.

Youngung

2025-02-05 01:46:26 UTC

Humans do not need winding to be alive

2025-02-05 01:46:28 UTC

I not sure but I think you need to have feelings and intuition,love and compassion(maybe).

2025-02-05 01:46:37 UTC

Based on the design they would BUT if robots didn’t have personalities it would make the world pretty bland and boring cause robots will be everywhere and they would talk in a boring no personality voice :P

2025-02-05 01:46:47 UTC

Human mean that human need to think about of them self and human have friend and also they have family

2025-02-05 01:47:31 UTC

Mechanicals do have personalities,because Mr.roach is a mean/secretive/evil mechanical but on the other hand Mrs.rust has a happy/nice/joyful personality.

Mrs rust main feeling is happy and she is really nice but Mr roach is more like a…mean feeling person because when he went to the clockmakers shop,he smashed the canary’s head on the edge of the table and asked Robert to fix it.

2025-02-05 01:47:35 UTC

Needs love

Can regenerate

Can feel emotions

Can be in /drink water

Don’t need winding/charging

Has organs

Can be trusted

Can learn

Can communicate

Can get sick

Have 5 senses

Given birth from a human

Need food

2025-02-05 01:47:35 UTC

Yes because mechanicals do the same jobs as humans like cooking, working, farming. So they should be treated just like humans are treated.

2061855 — 2025-02-05 01:47:36 UTC

I don’t have any proof to but I guess that robot doesn’t have any emotion because unless they don’t have mechanical brain or gimmick to think by its own they shouldn’t have any emotions scientifically.

20621510 — 2025-02-05 01:47:55 UTC

Aadya

The writer suggests that to be a human it doesn’t matter whether you’re made of cogs or bones and blood. You need a soul or a personality to be human. John’s mechs all have personalities and souls so they are more human-like than mech-like.

2025-02-05 01:48:00 UTC

No because robots were programmed to listen to human orders but us humans don't have to follow orders

Chen suen :)

2025-02-05 01:48:28 UTC

Perhaps 🤔 mechanicals and humans should have the same rights and mechs shouldn’t follow the law of the robots because mechs have a personality

2025-02-05 01:48:48 UTC

To be human you need rights

Sells

5 senses

Organs

Emotion

Can get sick

Needs food

Is born from another human

Can think for itself

Doesn’t need winding or charging

2025-02-05 01:48:51 UTC

I think Mrs Rust is very kind

2025-02-05 01:49:23 UTC

Humans have the right to work I think machanics do not have the right to work

-human get salary

-demand more salary

2025-02-05 01:49:26 UTC

I’m not sure but I think that they should have thee rights as humans but they should also do some of the laws like a robot can’t harm or kill a human and if there is danger you should help.

2025-02-05 01:49:44 UTC

i think that they should because they deserve to but just not that they ARE aloud to hurt humans(because i am not ending up in hospital because of a robot)

2025-02-05 01:51:14 UTC

Im not sure but maybe they should depending of the type of mech like for Mrs Rust i think she should because she’s like a Mum to Lilly (or a better guardian says Lilly herself).Mrs Rust should have same rights as well as other mechs like maybe a gardener so she knows when to water the plant because it could die or maybe a housekeeper mech should have the permission because she has to clean the house and needs to know what to do instead of being controlled by a human that might not be experienced and just saying random stuff but if the housekeeper just listens to the human that is not experienced it could end up bad.

2025-02-05 01:52:07 UTC

I don’t think mechanicals should have the same rights of humans because in like…I don’t know they could just take over the world anytime then there will be no more humans and robots…they will live life starting robot world I.

You never know when they could take over the world anytime.

2025-02-05 01:52:59 UTC

To be human you need to be able to swallow water because it said in the book that mechanicals and swallowing water don't mix.Thats why I think humans need to be able to swallow water or be able to go into water to be human.

2025-02-05 01:54:05 UTC

Mechs have feelings and personality because at the beginning Molly was crying about the sheets.

2025-02-05 01:54:34 UTC

I’m not sure but I’m pretty sure it means if you have cogs or if you are a mechanical or not it doesn’t matter.

2025-02-05 01:54:52 UTC

To be human ,it means that you have blood flowing through your veins and you have your own feelings,drink water, have organs, have 5 senses, is born by human, needs food, can speak,can learn, no windings,can regenerate cells, have certain DNA, gets love, has life, don’t need cogs or machine parts, have heart thumping, and has right to live and take care.

2025-02-05 01:55:01 UTC

They should have same rights as humans because it is not fair and mechs are just a bit different.

2025-02-05 01:55:29 UTC

To be human u need to..

Mix with water

Have rights

Have a free life without being controlled

Have the right and fair treatment like a human being

Have no ticks or keys

Have blood and bones

And more!( ran out of time)

2025-02-05 01:55:35 UTC

I also think mechanicals have a personality because Mrs. Rust has a kind personality.

2025-02-05 01:56:20 UTC

The list of things you need to be human

•Heart

•born from another human

•can get sick

•cry tears (water)

•does not have cogs

•works without charging or ticks

•needs food

•needs water

•has 5 senses