INSTRUCTION:

Instructions for Group Discussion on Pinocchio

Setup (5-10 minutes)

• Form a group of 5 students

• Discuss the questions together.

Discussion Guidelines (20-25 minutes)

1. Each person should share their initial thoughts on the question (1-2 minutes per person)

2. Look for connections between different ideas in your group

3. Try to include examples from the story of Pinocchio to support your points

4. The note-taker should write down the main ideas from your discussion

5. Make sure everyone in the group gets a chance to speak

Presentation Preparation (5 minutes)

• Organize your main ideas into 3-4 key points

• Choose 1-2 examples from the story that best support your answer

• Prepare a brief 2-3 minute presentation to share with the class

Tips for Good Answers

• Use specific examples from the story

• Consider different character viewpoints

• Connect the story to your own experiences when possible

• There are no "wrong" answers as long as you can explain your reasoning

• Keep your language simple and clear

Presentation (2-3 minutes per group)

• The presenter will share your group's ideas with the class

• Be prepared to answer 1-2 questions from other students or the teacher

Remember to listen respectfully to other groups' presentations and be ready to learn from their different perspectives!

Discussion Questions on the Fractured Story of Pinocchio

1. How does the story of Pinocchio change when told by different characters like Geppetto, Jiminy Cricket, or the Blue Fairy?

2. Could Pinocchio's lies actually help him grow as a character instead of just being bad choices?

3. How does the whale Monstro both cause problems for Pinocchio and help him change by the end of the story?

4. If the children on Pleasure Island told the story, would we think differently about why they made bad choices?

5. What might Pinocchio's growing nose and donkey ears tell us about how he feels inside?

6. How is this new version of Pinocchio similar to other fairy tales that have been retold in modern movies or books?

7. If Geppetto was the main character instead of Pinocchio, how would the story change?

8. When we look at Pinocchio's story in new ways, what can we learn about being honest and being yourself?

9. If the Blue Fairy told the story, what might we learn about helping others and forgiveness?

10. What can Pinocchio's wish to become "a real boy" teach us about accepting who we are today?

-Amanda Widya Setia Putri / 5

-Ananda Talitha Fani Aristha / 7

-Desty Callista Sulistyo / 14

-Devina Olga Yogi Agustin / 15

-Qaishar Ilmu Emilia Sabrina / 30

1. from Gepetto's point of view, because Gepetto wants to have a child, whatever bad nature of Pinocchio he will still accept it well and continue to look after it.

2. Pinocchio's lying nature can be a lesson to continue to be better and be careful in doing something.

3. the whale's monstro causes a major problem for Pinocchio by swallowing Geppetto, separating them and putting Geppetto's life in danger. This creates a moment of crisis and deep emotional struggle for Pinocchio. However, facing this danger helps Pinocchio grow. He shows bravery, determination, and love by risking his life to rescue Geppetto. Even though he cannot save him in the end, this journey marks a turning poinnocchio transforms from a naive boy into someone capable of deep care, selflessness, and maturimatur.

4. yes, hearing the story from the children's point of view could change how we see their actions. We might learn that they were confused, lonely, or seeking freedom from strict or uncaring adults. They may not have fully understood the consequences of their choices. Their version could help us see them not just as “bad” kids, but as children who made mistakes because of fear, pressure, or the need to feel accepted. This perspective might create more empathy and help explain their behavior in a more human way.

5. Pinocchio’s nose grew whenever he lied, and each time he felt embarrassed, scared, and anxious. over time, those unpleasant feelings taught him that honesty brings far more comfort than deception.

6. those 2 retold Pinocchio stories have almost the similar plot, meaning and ending. its about Pinocchio and his owner / step dad Gepetto. it both looks interesting because each story of Pinocchio teaches us a good moral.

7. if Geppetto was the main character, the story would focus more on his loneliness and struggles. It would tell us about his journey to find Pinocchio, how much he cared for his son, and the sacrifices he made. The story would be about a father's love and how he never gave up on his son.

8. we can learn that honesty is very important. Pinocchio faced problems every time he lied, but things got better when he started telling the truth. This story teaches us that being honest with yourself brings respect, love, and true happiness.

9. if the Blue Fairy were the one telling the story, we would place more emphasis on the value of helping others and giving second chances. We would learn that everyone can change for the better if given love and trust.

10. Pinocchio's desire to become a "real human child" teaches us that we all have a desire to be accepted and loved. However, the journey to self-acceptance begins with being honest, responsible, and showing compassion to others.

1. aliffya

2. kheyzia

3. fira

4. anggi

5. chelsea

jawaban :

1. • Geppetto: Focuses on love and fatherhood; may stress Pinocchio's journey as a reflection of his own hopes.

• Jiminy Cricket: Represents conscience and morality; may highlight the importance of choices and the consequences of actions.

• Blue Fairy: Offers a magical and nurturing perspective, emphasizing potential and the capacity for growth.

2.• Learning Experiences: Pinocchio's lies and mistakes can lead to self-discovery.

• Character Development: Each lie may lead him to confront difficult truths about friendship, honesty, and responsibility

3 • Challenges: Monstro represents the dangers and consequences of Pinocchio's actions, creating high stakes in the story.

• Transformation: The encounter with Monstro can serve as a catalyst for Pinocchio's growth, teaching him bravery and the importance of others.

4 Hearing from the children might reveal peer pressure or a lack of guidance as reasons for their actions.Their stories could elicit sympathy and help explain choices better than solely viewing them as bad.

5. Growing Nose, Represents dishonesty; each lie has a physical manifestation, showing the weight of deceit.

Donkey Ears, Symbolize feeling out of place or being treated as lesser, reflecting inner turmoil and identity struggles.

6 This new version of Pinocchio mirrors other retold fairy tales by incorporating modern themes, deeper character development, and contemporary moral lessons, making them relatable to today's audience.

7 •It might include Geppetto's journey, his emotions, struggles, and perhaps magical encounters while searching.

•The story's climax could shift to Geppetto's reunion and eventual death after sacrificing everything to be with Pinocchio again.

•If Geppetto were the main character, the story would focus more on his journey of love and sacrifice, exploring his emotions and struggles while trying to connect with Pinocchio.

8. Looking at Pinocchio's story from new perspectives teaches us that honesty can lead to authentic relationships, and being true to oneself is essential for personal growth and acceptance.

9. If the Blue Fairy narrated the story, we might learn about the importance of aiding others selflessly and the value of forgiveness in healing relationships.

10. Pinocchio's desire to become "a real boy" teaches us about embracing our true selves and recognizing that our worth is inherent, regardless of external validation.

AJENG DWI ARIYANTI /03

FANNY PUTRI A /17

NAVARA CLARINE H /28

S.N AISYAH /36

ANSWER :

1. The story changes depending on the narrator. Geppetto might focus on love and loss. Jiminy Cricket might talk about conscience. The Blue Fairy would focus on magic and forgiveness.

2. His lies cause trouble, but they also teach him right from wrong. They help him grow by learning from mistakes.

3. Monstro is a problem, but also a turning point. Pinocchio becomes brave and responsible when saving Geppetto.

4. If they told the story, we might understand peer pressure and how making bad choices isn't always simple.

5. These changes show Pinocchio’s guilt and shame. They reflect his inner feelings and emotional growth.

6. This version is like other modern fairy tales that explore deeper emotions and different character perspectives, like Shrek or Maleficent.

7. The story would focus on a father’s journey, his loss, hope, and love for his son.

8. The story teaches us the value of honesty, self-awareness, and accepting who we are.

9. Her version would teach about compassion, forgiveness, and the importance of second chances.

10. This wish represents everyone's desire to be accepted as their true self, not just who people expect them to be.

-Adzra/01

-Aisyah Dwi/02

-Arche/08

-Azizah/10

-Dwi Esti/16

Answer:

1. The story of Pinocchio can change significantly depending on who tells it. Geppetto might focus on themes of love and sacrifice, portraying his relationship with Pinocchio as a reflection of his own dreams and desires. Jiminy Cricket could emphasize moral lessons, highlighting the importance of conscience and the consequences of Pinocchio's actions. The Blue Fairy might frame the narrative around themes of magic and transformation, illustrating the significance of guidance and kindness.

2. Pinocchio's lies can be interpreted as opportunities for growth rather than merely bad choices. Each lie leads to consequences that teach him valuable lessons about honesty, responsibility, and the impact of his actions on others. This perspective suggests that mistakes can serve as important stepping stones in his journey toward becoming a "real boy."

3. Monstro, the whale, acts as both a source of conflict and a catalyst for change in Pinocchio's life. The challenges posed by Monstro force Pinocchio to confront his fears and take responsibility for his actions, ultimately leading to his bravery and selflessness. This duality illustrates how obstacles can foster personal growth and transformation.

4. If the children on Pleasure Island told the story, it might reveal their motivations and the pressures they face. Their choices could be seen as responses to neglect, societal expectations, or a desire for freedom, prompting a more empathetic understanding of their actions rather than simply labeling them as bad.

5. Pinocchio's growing nose and donkey ears symbolize his internal struggles with honesty and identity. These physical changes reflect his guilt, shame, and the conflict between his desires and his true self, suggesting that our outward appearances can often mirror our inner emotional states.

6. This new version of Pinocchio shares similarities with other modern retellings of fairy tales, such as themes of self-discovery, moral complexity, and personal growth. Like many contemporary adaptations, it may explore deeper psychological and social issues, making the story more relatable to today's audience.

7. If Geppetto were the protagonist, the story might focus more on themes of parental love, sacrifice, and the challenges of raising a child. It could explore Geppetto's feelings of loneliness, his dreams for Pinocchio, and his own journey of growth as he learns to let go and trust his creation.

8. The story of Pinocchio from various perspectives shows the importance of honesty and authenticity. It highlights that being true to yourself is essential to building trust.

9. This view highlights the importance of caring for others and how kindness can change a person's life. The support we provide can bring positive changes to others.

10. Pinocchio's desire to become "a real boy" can teach us about the journey of self-acceptance,and that embracing our true selves, flaws and all, is essential for personal growth and happiness.

Group member:

1. M. Abdullah F. (9-10)

2. M. Rizky Rafiansyah (7)

3. M. Fikri Al Gifari (1-4)

4. Faris iqbal P. (6 & 8)

5. Galih Evan As. (5)

6. Vino (7)

7. Rivano Ghaly Kaluku (1-4)

Answer:

1. From Geppeto's pov pinocchio is a kind and obidient alive wooden puppet.

2. Its not a bad choice cause this gives pinocchio a honest character.

3. The whale caused problem to Pinocchio and Geppetto by swallowing both of them,after Geppetto and Pinocchio out from the whale belly by sneezed out by the whale they find a good fairy and the fairy turn pinochio into real living boy.

4. Yes, its going to be a bad choice because the children is not smart enough.

5. Together, these changes show that Pinocchio's outward appearance reflects his inner feelings-his guilt, shame, and regret when he lies or makes poor choices. They remind us that our actions can have visible consequences and that trying to hide our mistakes often makes us feel worse inside.

6. Not similar, because the old story did not show the father's name, whereas the new story does, and in the old story the father is still alive, whereas in the new story the father has died.

7. If Geppetto were the main character, the story would shift its focus from Pinocchio's adventures to Geppetto's journey as a craftsman and a father. The narrative would explore Geppetto's motivations for creating Pinocchio, his hopes and fears for his wooden son, and his experiences in raising a child, even a puppet one.

8. I'm afraid that if I lie my nose will grow long, and I will change to be better so that I won't be like Pinocchio who has a long nose.

9. We must help each other and forgive each other because we are social creatures.

10. Pinocchio's story teaches that true growth and transformation come from within, not just external changes. While he initially yearned to become a real boy, the Blue Fairy emphasized that this required him to be truthful, brave, and selfless. This suggests that accepting who you are today involves acknowledging your current self, including your flaws, and focusing on developing positive qualities like honesty and kindness.

1. Asy syaira Y.M.M (09)

2. Deffrina A.S (13)

3. Habibah P.D (21)

4. Nabilah D.P.A (27)

5. Rigitha P.A (33)

-Answers :

1) In the Gepetto point ow view, he was lonely and dreamed about having a son. One day he making a puppet, which he would call Pinnochio, at night fairy came and turned the puppet alive. Gepetto was so happy, Geppeto loved Pinnochio dearly as his son.

2) Because when Pinnochio lies, his nose would be grow longer and longer. Because of that, he would be the person who cannot be trusted.

3) Mastro caused problems by swallowed up by a huge whale when he was looking for Pinnochio, and the whale swallowed him as well, but it help him to meet Gepetto. Pinnochio and Gepetto were so happy to see each others, they made a plan to get out and began tickling the whale stomach to make the whale sneezing and after they out they looking for fairy, after met fairy the fairy turned Pinnochio to real living boy.

4) Yes, if the children told the story, we might see that they were just looking for fun and didn't know the consequences, like how Pinnochio skipped school to watch a circus and made bad choices without thingking.

5) As soon as he lied, his wooden nose would grow longer and longer, but Pinocchio was quite naughty and rarely spoke the truth.

6) the difference between old stories and modern stories is found in the ending.

in the old version of Pinocchio had a happy ending, he was turned into a human by a blue fairy. while in the modern version, the end of Pinocchio's story must lose Gepetto and he remains alive as a wooden doll with a sorcerer.

7) The focus of the story will likely shift to Gappetto's desire to have a son and what actions he will take to create Pinocchio. And it may show a lot of sacrifices made to achieve this.

8) in the story we learn about: looking at the story of Pinocchio in a new way can teach us some valuable lessons about honesty and being ourselves and that we should not repeat past mistakes if they have been forgiven.

9) If you have been forgiven, don't repeat the same mistakes. Because if you repeat the same mistakes, it will be difficult to be forgiven again. And if you help others, one day you'll be helped too.

10) We will be more grateful for what we have, and we will not be liars. and we have to be ourselves.

• Amel Agnistya Dufa Mentari

• Putri Alifia

• Safiina Karunia Kinanti

• Maudy Dwi Airin

• Chika Priska

1. Gepetto loved Pinocchio deadly, but Pinocchio was quite naughty and rarely spoke the truth.

2. No, Pinocchio's nose got longer and longer because he lied

3. Pinocchio only felt the negative impact, namely getting karma in the form of a long nose.

4. That would be a bad story, because the story of "Stupid Little Boys" is about naughty children who are taken to their heaven, where alcohol, cigarettes and other things are freely done there. If Pinocchio was in this story, he would probably be an even more naughty person, and he would never realize his mistake.

5. Pinocchio's nose became long, because he lied too much. That was the reason his nose always kept getting longer from time to time. Actually he was very sad, he really wanted to change his nature that liked to lie. However, unfortunately the change never happened to Pinocchio.

6. The original version of the Pinocchio story begins with a man named Gepetto who was cutting wood in a forest. Gepetto suddenly thought of making a doll from the wood which was then named "Pinocchio". A miracle happened, the doll came to life and could behave like a human. However, his nature was very naughty and liked to lie. However, unfortunately, one day his father, Gepetto, was lost and eaten by a whale. Pinocchio, who felt panicked, began to look for his father in the whale's mouth. But fate said otherwise, Pinocchio was also eaten in the whale's stomach and both of them could not be saved.

7. The plot might follow Geppetto's struggle to create life for Pinocchio, facing physical, emotional, and spiritual challenges along the way. This could include themes of perseverance, sacrifice, and hope.

8. Even if honest, Pinocchio would still be a unique character as a living wooden puppet. The story might explore how Pinocchio interacts with the world around him and faces challenges as a different kind of being.

9. Pinocchio learns that helping others can bring happiness and fulfillment. Pinocchio also learns about the importance of forgiving oneself and others. When he realizes his mistakes and apologizes, he shows maturity and self-awareness."

10. respecting yourself means loving yourself