https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5 Click "+" and add a comment or question for each of your student colleague's presentations. What were strengths/highlights of the presentation/proposed study? What suggestions do you have for improvement? What other questions do you have for this topic? en-us 2022-04-19 13:48:58 UTC 2022-04-26 20:58:07 UTC hello@padlet.com earnestclayton https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149062663 1. Define SES and what areas/zip codes are considered to fall within those parameters]]> 2022-04-19 18:16:42 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149062663 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149070679 What were strengths/highlights of the presentation/proposed study? 
- The priority population is well defined
- Current and accurate obesity prevalence figures
- Good planning group that even includes owners of the HOA
- Target population is affected by SES and she identified the need for assistance 

What suggestions do you have for improvement? 
- How is MVPA defined? 
- Explanation to the specific range of the target population (40-59 years of age)
- Are there minority groups that are part of the SES strata?

What other questions do you have for this topic?
- Is this intervention based on neighborhoods, schools, or other similar areas?
- Can you think of any other evaluation instruments that might be useful for your proposal?]]> 2022-04-19 18:21:19 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149070679 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149081234 Strengths
-great presentation overall
-good background providing eviddence for need
- good idea conducting focus groups within community

REcommendations
-define low SES
-describe approach in forming planning comittee]]> 2022-04-19 18:28:13 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149081234 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149086151 Great job! Your background context and AIMS are very clear.

I think I would have enjoyed to hear more about recruitment strategies and the cultural messaging behind how you would use feedback -- what about the feedback and cultural needs might impact phrases or words in flyers? what would impact the intervention. Maybe examples here!]]> 2022-04-19 18:31:29 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149086151 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149090056 Strengths 
- Overall good presentation
- good justification for priority population

Recommendation
- Consider changing your comparison group for your experiemental design to low SES neighbourhoods as well.
- You have 2 different study designs quasi and group randomized control trial are you conducting two different evaluations or is that a mistake. I'd maybe stick to GRCT. Sounds more appropriate. ]]> 2022-04-19 18:34:12 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149090056 earnestclayton https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149091850 Great topic
1. You mention that it is the most obese area in the country but it would be helpful if you broke it down by age & gender.]]> 2022-04-19 18:35:28 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149091850 earnestclayton https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149096596 You mentioned " Making stakeholders feel appreciated". What techniques/modeling can you incorporate that increases their participation and assist them with feeling that the program is inclusive.]]> 2022-04-19 18:38:52 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149096596 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149107933 Strength
- Love the visuals in the presentation

Recommendations
- Wide age range and may require different recruitment approaches and maybe different interventions. 
- Your aim 1 and 2 are very similar in terms of conducting a needs assessment. Are you conducting 2 different needs assessment?
- Could you explain how you intend to identify stakeholders using logic model]]> 2022-04-19 18:47:10 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149107933 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149108703 Strengths
-Nice Visuals
-Good evidence for rational
-good clarity of measures

Recommendation
-more details on recruitment process ]]> 2022-04-19 18:47:48 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149108703 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149114214 I really like how you focus on the facilitators, unhealthy eating, to obesity, and I'm really thinking hard about the four tacos I've already eaten today :)But jokes aside, I really like how equal participation of stakeholders is emphasized. I'm wondering what ways you will ensure this to happen? But I know we hardly got into that with time constraints.

]]> 2022-04-19 18:51:48 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149114214 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149125580 Strengths
- great overall presentation
- good prevalence data emphasizing the issue

Recommendations
- may want to specify where low SES neighborhoods are located in Harris County. I am not too familiar!]]> 2022-04-19 19:00:11 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149125580 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149129365 Great overall presentation! I also have an interest in obesity prevention within the RGV, so it was great listening to your presentation. I'm wondering how you would differentiate between age ranges. 18 years and 45 year olds may have different interests and probably frequent different locations. Great job!]]> 2022-04-19 19:01:57 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149129365 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149131099 Great visuals, succinct with sufficient information.
Recommendation
you should consider the groups to ensure they are comparable.]]> 2022-04-19 19:03:12 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2149131099 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159069009 Strengths:
- Cultural relevance is well-defined, magnitude of the problem is also well-defined
- Strong epidemiological background
- Specific aims are thorough 

Improvements/Questions:
- More clarity on the study design
- Why the population range only 15-19 y/o?
- Will you have a professional like a biostatistician to run the regression analysis?

]]> 2022-04-26 18:29:48 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159069009 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159071461 Nice presentation, thank you! 
I specifically appreciated your specific aims and objectives section in which your elaboration were clear and concise.]]> 2022-04-26 18:31:22 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159071461 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159082929 Strengths
great highlight of need
strong background
great job highlighting implementers and adapterr ]]> 2022-04-26 18:38:50 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159082929 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159096517 Great presentation and good providing adequate information about the community of interest.]]> 2022-04-26 18:47:57 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159096517 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159097091 Strengths:
- Aims are clear and concise
- Good methods

Improvements/Questions:
- Why just phase 2-4 of MAPP?
- Target population is too narrow (in my opinion

Great work nonetheless and a very important public health issue in the area!]]> 2022-04-26 18:48:18 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159097091 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159103113 Good job with your presentation. It was well detailed and i appreciate your justification for what school districts you would target. 

Improvement/questions:
You mentioned your intervention will focus on the enviroment but it was unclear how so?]]> 2022-04-26 18:52:45 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159103113 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159106380 Strengths
-great background
-design is clear]]> 2022-04-26 18:54:56 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159106380 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159109396 Strong description of issue/need.
Bringing this intervention to the community level is a very unique approach. Great understanding of specific aims and how they will guide the implementation. Great presentation!]]> 2022-04-26 18:56:59 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159109396 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159117089 Strengths:
- Good cultural appropriateness
- Good target population
- Plenty of aims that are concise

Improvements/Questions:
- Why 40%?
- Target population unclear (at least unclear to me)]]> 2022-04-26 19:01:35 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159117089 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159123584 Strengths 
- Good knowledge of the health problem 
- A comprehensive range of change methods choosen for the intervention 

Improvement/Questions:
Consider moving the design of an experiment design from Aim 1 to after the intervention has been developed so it doesn't look like you're conducting 2 different experimental designs. ]]> 2022-04-26 19:06:16 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159123584 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159125353 Strengths 
- great justification of methods
-great description of need
- clear aims
Recommendations 
-describe justification for project outcomes ]]> 2022-04-26 19:07:31 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159125353 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159147316 Strengths:
- RCT is a concise method of research design that can be used to better gauge attitudes, norms, and behavioral control for condom usage 
- Good combination of RCT and CBPR for innovation

Improvements/Questions:
- Why is the target population adolescents ages 15 through 19? 


Great work!]]> 2022-04-26 19:23:23 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159147316 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159154192 Strengths
Love the visuals in your presentation 
Appropriate population of interest

Improvement/Questions:
What intervention would you be implementing for adolescents?
Would you be targeting the environmental level and how? 

]]> 2022-04-26 19:27:56 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159154192 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159156742 Strengths
-great visuals 
-good summary of method- it is hard to fit it all in
-good evidence for background



]]> 2022-04-26 19:29:43 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159156742 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159160044 Great presentation sharing your interest and experience in this field. 
Good supportive evidence and visuals.]]> 2022-04-26 19:32:20 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159160044 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159162998 Great description of need, and I enjoyed hearing about the innovation of this proposal. Good defining health issue]]> 2022-04-26 19:34:42 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159162998 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159173658 Strengths:
- Good background and descriptive epidemiology
- Good combination of CBPR and IM principles for innovation

Improvements/Questions:
- Why a one-group quasi-experimental design?
- Why is the target population only adolescent girls ages 9 through 14?]]> 2022-04-26 19:43:21 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159173658 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159177476 Great presentation, it seemed as though your proposal fills an important gap. I liked how you discussed the methods and practical applications related to your behavioral theories, such as elaboration likelihood model, etc.]]> 2022-04-26 19:46:18 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159177476 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159184978 Strengths
-great background
-good description of need
-good descrption of practical applications]]> 2022-04-26 19:52:24 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159184978 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159186385 Great presentation. HPV vaccinate is very important and i like that this reasearch will be filling in an obvious gap in our helath care system. Good Job!]]> 2022-04-26 19:53:24 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159186385 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159195530 Strengths:
- Great use of diabetes self-management education (DSME) with IM and pre/post-tests
- Great use of theoretical change methods
- Innovation is great (DSME and gender focus)
- Cultural competency is strong

Improvements/Questions:
- How can CHWs improve self-efficacy and outcome expectations for the target population?
- Potential biases with convenience sampling?]]> 2022-04-26 20:00:49 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159195530 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159204292 Awesome topic Angela. I love the rationale for including family members. Your specific aims and objective were very clear. Overall great work ]]> 2022-04-26 20:08:11 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159204292 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159214843 Strengths:
- Great presentation background and transitions
- Great incorporation of program planning organizations and the proposed project
- Great incorporation of CBPR principles for the aims
- Great target population

Improvements/Questions:
- What are some examples of the social media platforms you mentioned?
- Is this just for faith groups and for African American individuals?]]> 2022-04-26 20:17:27 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159214843 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159215859 Strengths:
- Love the visual and the use of prezi for your presentation
- Great cultural focus 
- That's a nice picture of you in your presentation. 

Improvement/Questions:
The target population age group seems broad 17-50 years old would there be a different intervention for the different age groups that make up your population?]]> 2022-04-26 20:18:01 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159215859 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159221473 Thank you for your presentation.
A good strategy utilizing an existing organization with built in CHWs to integrate into your intervention.

]]> 2022-04-26 20:22:53 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159221473 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159228281 I loved the visuals in your presentation. Good description of aims and background.]]> 2022-04-26 20:29:18 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159228281 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159235334 Strengths:
- Very interesting topic and important within the realm of public health
- Great descriptive information on dating violence 
- Great incorporation on how parents play a key role in addressing dating violence

Improvements/Questions:
- What other PLA tools can you use for your proposal?
- Details of the IM methodologies (why only Step 4 of IM)? ]]> 2022-04-26 20:36:01 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159235334 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159250631 Thank you for explaining the difference between passive and active referrals.]]> 2022-04-26 20:50:42 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159250631 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159253702 Strengths:
- Great background and descriptive information 
- Great inclusion of many partners from planning groups
- Active referrals a great component of the innovation approach

Improvements/Questions:
- Why CBPR 3,4,7, and 8?
- Why not Step 5 for IM?

]]> 2022-04-26 20:53:32 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159253702 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159257227 I really like the focus of the referral system and the methods/tools you used!

I think this is such an interesting topic and we don't hear much of this research in our classes!]]> 2022-04-26 20:57:08 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159257227 https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159258195 Love the visuals in your presentation and the focus on referral/ linkage system. ]]> 2022-04-26 20:58:07 UTC https://padlet.com/andrewespringer/xdfd7lqtnijp77q5/wish/2159258195