https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions en-us 2020-01-28 18:36:41 UTC 2025-09-27 23:43:17 UTC hello@padlet.com mattayahankey https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425149595 No, it was not justified. Shannon has the full right to grieve but instead she goes out of her way to try and pressure Sayid into killing another survivor. once Sayid disagrees she, herself, tries to kill Locke. Shannon had one source of Boone's death so everything she did was on impulse and emotion. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:38:16 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425149595 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425150260 I feel both of their arguments are justified. Their trust is broken because in Jack's eyes because Jhon lied about the hatch and the plane. But in Jhon's eyes the reason for delaying about telling them about the hatch was not to scare people and maybe figure out how to open it first.]]> 2022-12-19 19:39:11 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425150260 hailey_thompson1 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425157112 no i don't think what sawyer did was justified because he called her out in front of everyone and she had no way of defending herself and even if sawyer was just trying to get his spot back on the raft he didn't have to do it the way that he did because that changed everyone's perspective on her and how they act around her.]]> 2022-12-19 19:48:54 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425157112 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425157630 I believe that she was going to kill her mom and that she didn't do it and she runs off for she doesn't get caught ]]> 2022-12-19 19:49:39 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425157630 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425158573 he didn't want to leave at first that's why he burned the raft down then after everything that happen he wants to leave to get to safety]]> 2022-12-19 19:51:02 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425158573 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425158990 Personally I feel like Jacks side is justified more. John lied about the plane which respectfully upset Jack. If they are gonna be on the island together they shouldn't lie and keep secrets like what John was doing. John thinks he is in the right for not wanting to tell anyone about his findings and causing them to get scared.]]> 2022-12-19 19:51:40 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425158990 mattayahankey https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159004 originally i assumed the hatch was some sort of miltary bunker. though since that the hatch couldnt be opened from the outside it suggested their was another entrance. or that it was trying to trap something inside.
so everything i figured about the hatch, theory wise, is still intact. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:51:42 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159004 bryceohara https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159111 One of the biggest questions brought up in Sayids story is when he was able to escape the republican army. We also see how much hes motivated to find Nadia, even going so far as infiltrating a terrorist group. This makes me wonder how much changed between the different segments of his past.]]> 2022-12-19 19:51:51 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159111 brentmorishita https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159386 2022-12-19 19:52:20 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159386 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159492 I do not think Shannon's reaction is justified in the slightest bit. It was boone that made the decision to stay in that plane longer even when Jhon was yelling at him to get out and that decision ended his life. It is normal to grieve but to try and get your own revenge is wrong.]]> 2022-12-19 19:52:29 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159492 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159583 i think you i am gonna side with john becase everybody els has secrets so he can two and his secret was to protect everybody elses intrest]]> 2022-12-19 19:52:39 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159583 sarahsommerfeldt https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159899 it was not justified, sawyer didnt need to make a big scene in front of everyone to try and keep his spot on the raft]]> 2022-12-19 19:53:07 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159899 hailey_thompson1 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159984 no i don't think that her reaction was justified because even tho her brother died and it was tragic she had no reason to send say id to try and kill another survivor. even if he did kill boone shannon would have to live with killing another man for the rest of her life and because she only knew one person that was with him she was acting completely on impulse.


i agree with mattaya because she was so sad and overall emotional that she wouldn't stop at anything to kill john even if she had to do it herself ]]> 2022-12-19 19:53:14 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425159984 kaidavidson2 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160265 She was a fugitive who seemed to have some public recognition, so it definitely is fair. Kate was also using a dead woman's passport to fake her identity, and that's kinda screwed up, so even just in that moment she was in the wrong.]]> 2022-12-19 19:53:36 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160265 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160451 findign out thers more people on te island was a big surpised and with the deaths and dark past of some surivivers i think we are going to see more of everyones past and how they figure out how to fix it]]> 2022-12-19 19:53:51 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160451 brentmorishita https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160597 2022-12-19 19:54:06 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160597 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160600 i think it was justafyed she was sad about her brother dying and was trying to get payback on the person who did it]]> 2022-12-19 19:54:06 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425160600 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161084 I would agree that shannon took it too far when she tried to kill john lock. Johns making Boone go into the plane was very stupid of him. Shannon should be mad at john lock but killing him is not reasonable at all. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:54:50 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161084 brookeslaney https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161249 At first I thought that the Hatch was a underground shelter of sorts that lead to like a house underground. But after finding out theres no handle to the hatch and hearing Walt's fear in his voice when he tells John to not open it, I now think it's containg some sort of animal science project from the scientists 16 years ago or just any sort of animal species contained in the hatch. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:55:08 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161249 mattayahankey https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161398 Walt at first didnt want to leave the island, though behind the scenes im sure Walt has got vocies in his head. because i feel like he wouldnt know about the hatch otherwise. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:55:21 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161398 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161491 becase i the begining eposodes she helped rob a bank]]> 2022-12-19 19:55:30 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161491 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161887 cause there are like a bunch of seasons i can't say everyone dies but maybe a couple people will die. I guarantee that someone will die on the raft but they get to another island or something to keep the show going. Why the french lady is on the island hasn't been answered yet. I hope everyone dies one by one by a cool looking T-Rex or by a poisnous toad. that is all.]]> 2022-12-19 19:56:07 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425161887 brentmorishita https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162183 2022-12-19 19:56:33 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162183 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162231 Shannon wasn't in the wrong for greiving for the loss but two wrongs don't make a right. Her trying to get Sayid to kill John is not the slightest bit justified. It was Boones decision to stay in the plane and John was yelling at him to get out. There really wasn't much John could have done to save him because he didn't want to die and have both of them dead. Shannon being upset and John is reasobable but going out of her way to kill him is not.]]> 2022-12-19 19:56:37 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162231 hailey_thompson1 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162248 when they first found the hatch i thought maybe that's where ethan was hiding because it was found around the same time that claire went missing and if it was underground nobody would hear her screaming for help or anything like that but now that ethan is dead i'm thinking that they are trying to keep something trapped something bad taht could harm the island and hurt the people on it if its released.]]> 2022-12-19 19:56:39 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162248 kaycestennes https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162289 walt says to not open the bunker and looks very startild after saying that. walt knows something that the others don't know. The only thing i can take out of the information given is that it is something not very good because walt looks scared when he tells lock to not open the bunker and he wants to get of the island. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:56:43 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162289 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162630 I am on Jacks side. Like john lied and honestly I dont think you are ever justified to lie about something so serious and important. They are all on the island together and i think everyone would have benefited by knowing about this. Jack was very upset for a good reason.]]> 2022-12-19 19:57:15 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162630 sarahsommerfeldt https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162697 i think Jack is more justified becuase he was mad at locke for lying about the plane and for not telling him about the hatch for so long, since theres only a small group of people locke shouldnt be keeping secrets that could mean theres other people on the island. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:57:20 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425162697 emilydemott https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425163265 Awhile ago communication about a bunch of numbers bringing curses upon people who use them was in the air, and still to this resent episode the answer is still in question. 
And we still don't know what the significance about the underground bunker is all about.]]> 2022-12-19 19:58:06 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425163265 bryceohara https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425163735 I think that they both had reasonings for what they did but Jack was more justified in his course of action. John is a very rational man he thought out what he was going to do and he made a calculated lie. he only acts like he had made an impulsive decision because Jack had caught him in his lie. Lockes lie contributed to Boone's death and Jack was right in going for retribution.]]> 2022-12-19 19:58:47 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425163735 brookeslaney https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425164314 I agree with Mattaya that Shannon trying to kill Locke is not justified. I can see why she wants to kill Locke since she thiks he killed Boone but she has no proof Locke killed Boone so she shouldn't have tried to kill him or try to convince Sayid to do it. ]]> 2022-12-19 19:59:41 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425164314 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425164315 I agree with what Hailey said. I also believed it had relevance to Ethan and that he used it and that is why he was so good at getting around the island. Now that Ethan is dead I am not sure what they could use it for and what its relevance is anymore.]]> 2022-12-19 19:59:41 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425164315 frankie_thiessen https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425164530 I predict the group of raft builders,and people going on the raft will not get on the raft in season 1.I wonder if Kate will get her way on the raft.]]> 2022-12-19 20:00:01 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425164530 sarahsommerfeldt https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165487 i think what she did could be half justified because she was in shook from her brother dying and she heard jack call locke a lier about what happened to boone, she cant be justified for trying to get sayid to kill locke and then after sayid said he belives lock she tries to kill hijm herself, she was mad and wanted to blame someone for the death of her brother. ]]> 2022-12-19 20:01:30 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165487 emilydemott https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165599 I believe that if Kate wants to start over in the real world, she has to start doing things right. For example, not using a dead woman's ID. So yes Sawyer was justified in revealing her secrets because he was just trying to take his spot back, and in the action of his doings she may want to start over too.]]> 2022-12-19 20:01:37 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165599 kaidavidson2 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165631 The security guard in the hospital recognized her, so I assume what she did was pretty bad. Probably something like murder or a heist. During the heist later in her backstory, she seemed pretty confident in her abilities, so she had probably done it before.]]> 2022-12-19 20:01:40 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165631 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165871 I think the situation is 50/50, the truth was going to come out at some point about her old lifestyle and the crimes she's committed. She shouldn't have lied to everyone about her past and Sawyer shouldn't have dragged her in front of everyone.]]> 2022-12-19 20:02:02 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165871 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165901 Shannons response was all on emotion and greed. like when are you ever justified to try and kill someone else. Shannon isn't grieving normally and her reaction is not ok. She can be angry at John because what he had done was stupid but her attempt to murder is not justified.]]> 2022-12-19 20:02:05 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425165901 bryceohara https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166197 I think that in the final episode we will meet, or find out more about the other people who live on the island, and see more of the island in general. I still want to know what the black rock we've seen Rousseau talk about is, and what the origin of the numbers is. Or the box that the guy says hurley has opened.]]> 2022-12-19 20:02:33 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166197 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166628 I believe it has something to do with scientific animal experiments. Maybe has something to do with that polar bear that was on the island. Its definitley has a cooralation to the other people on the island.]]> 2022-12-19 20:03:18 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166628 kaycestennes https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166744 i do not think that sawer was right for taking her bag and showing that she was a criminal. But i think that he had to do that because he had all the fingers pointing at him and no one would have believed him if he said that kate was a criminal. ]]> 2022-12-19 20:03:30 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166744 drew_thompson1 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166907 I think both characters Locke and Jack had reasons to be sour at eachother. Locke completely lied to Jacks face when Locke Should of stated what happened to Boone in the tree that was stuck. Do to this it ended killing Boone in the end, but later on Jack caght John lying to bis face and John was eafer to tell him the truth.]]> 2022-12-19 20:03:48 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425166907 bryceohara https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425167480 I think that what you've said is great and makes a lot of sense and I'd also want to add, that she probably feels that locke is responsisble for Boone becoming more isolated from the rest of the islanders, as well as seperateing Boone from Shannon specifically.]]> 2022-12-19 20:04:46 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425167480 emilydemott https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425167866 At first I believed that the bunker held supplies or shelter but because there is no handle to get in and the way Walt talks in fear about the bunker I believe it is pointing towards the people like ethan and if they are to open it they may find for trouble.]]> 2022-12-19 20:05:23 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425167866 drew_thompson1 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425168743 Questioning if everybody will make safe to the next stage where the raft takes tgem and what its called, also wondering if Kate will sneak onto the raft and why the french lady has been on the island for so long and why she hasnt found a way home or wherever she came from.]]> 2022-12-19 20:06:48 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425168743 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425168911 I think Walk knows something about the hatch that the others don't. I don't know how Walt would know about the hatch tho but there was voices talking to Sayid and Sawyer so it may have been those talking to Walt]]> 2022-12-19 20:07:06 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425168911 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425169131 I would say sawyers in the right for the most part, Kate is a bad person who probably should be caught but Sawyer didnt need to bring her out infront of everyone. ]]> 2022-12-19 20:07:26 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425169131 drew_thompson1 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425170215 Not really sure with Walt seems very bipolar. meaning this because he burnt down the raft and didnt wanna leave at the start, then helped build the raft and immediatly wants to go home. Not super sure what his plan is but very interesting decisons he has made.]]> 2022-12-19 20:09:12 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425170215 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425170571 Kate literally is trying to take a dead woman's passport to try and live normally. If you need to go to that extant to try and live a normal life, people deserve to know what you have done. However Sawyer was a little over the top he could have treated Kate with a little more respect than he did.]]> 2022-12-19 20:09:48 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425170571 frankie_thiessen https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425170703 I don't know what he's thinking.He's probably scared to communicate with John anymore and wants to leave the island now because he might think John actually killed Boone.]]> 2022-12-19 20:10:02 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425170703 mattayahankey https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425171589 i also agree that what sawyer did wasnt Justified. there were many ways to get the spot back on the raft but the way he went about it was very absurd ]]> 2022-12-19 20:11:24 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425171589 frankie_thiessen https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425172284 I think the hatch has people in it because when John was going crazy after trying to open the hatch and yelling at the island for answers.The a light turned on inside the hatch.]]> 2022-12-19 20:12:29 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425172284 kaidavidson2 https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425172677 Shannon's reaction was a little much, but at first she just wanted to find out if John had killed Boone. I'd say that was justified, but trying to kill him with no evidence was a bit irrational.]]> 2022-12-19 20:13:07 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425172677 kaycestennes https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425175193 i think that there is something very dangerous in the hatch like a lab experiment that was so dangerous that it had to be sealed shut and not made to open.]]> 2022-12-19 20:17:05 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425175193 sarahsommerfeldt https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425176388 i think he knows something about the hatch because he seemed very concerned when he told john to not open it. ]]> 2022-12-19 20:19:09 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425176388 sarahsommerfeldt https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425177478 i think the hatch was built by ethan or the fench lady, when sayid was with the french lady she was in an underground hatch similair and the hatch they found is part of her underground bunker.]]> 2022-12-19 20:21:00 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425177478 kaycestennes https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425178049 i think that cole is right saying that it is a experiment because why would there be a hatch on a strand island sounds like a good place for a experiment. ]]> 2022-12-19 20:21:57 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425178049 brookeslaney https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425178918   I think that Walt is trying to navigate his new life with his Dad. The island life is all he knows with his dad. Walt seems to have grown closer to his dad. And as far as Walt telling John not to open that hatch Walt dosen't know about, I think that Walt has physic abilities and sometimes touching people such as John gives him visions. ]]> 2022-12-19 20:23:26 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425178918 joshua_plumer https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425181510 I think that she had had a very extreme reaction and that her anger was takenout on John just because he was close with her brother. But I don't think it was justified what she did because she had no evidence that John did anything.

]]> 2022-12-19 20:27:57 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425181510 joshua_plumer https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425185160 My theory for the bunker is that they are being observed by somthing and they are all there for a spacifc reason that I haven't figured out yet and they are being observed by some people and the bunker there has somthing to do with it.]]> 2022-12-19 20:34:13 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425185160 joshua_plumer https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425188785 A few episodes back Walt set the raft on fire so him and his father wouldn't have to leave. And now John is the only other person to know of this. ]]> 2022-12-19 20:40:28 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425188785 emilytorkelson https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425925325 i think sayyids storyline in the first episode was very important because it shows that he is very  determined to do what he needs do to find nadia it also helps to make you understand that he's very compassionate. we see this because of how he stayed to have his friend buried instead of cremated and how he risked his life to find nadia. ]]> 2022-12-20 15:56:14 UTC https://padlet.com/Duchessschool/lostquestions/wish/2425925325