https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca 1-Does the filmed version of “The Monkey’s Paw” depart or stay faithful to the text version? Explain why. (Put response under appropriate column). 2-Pick which version you liked most and tell why. (Under the appropriate column) *Put your name in Title's spot. en-us 2018-11-02 11:42:26 UTC 2018-11-04 20:20:50 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299793526 It stays faithful to the text because it has the same details as in the text and same format.]]> 2018-11-02 14:09:46 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299793526 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299794799 Film departed from the text version because in the text, the "mother" says to wish for "200" pounds, but the film shows, the "son" says to wish for "300" pounds. This shows that the film showed isn't that much different, but it still departed from the story in the book. they also have the difference in the setting when the man came over to give Mr. White and his wife their money. In the text, they are inside having breakfast, but in the film, they are out in their yard talking. ]]> 2018-11-02 14:12:00 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299794799 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299794834 The filmed version does stay faithful. It has the same meaning.     A Lot of the parts were exactly the same in the book, For example when they wished for their son back he came back in his dead form, and knocked on the front door. Just like in the text version  ]]> 2018-11-02 14:12:03 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299794834 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299794853 I think the film version stayed faithful to the text version because they had some of the same narration and dialogue from the text. Although, I did see a key difference in the movie. In the book it quotes," I wish for two hundred pounds," said the old man distinctly. on the other hand, in the movie it says. " I wish for three hundred pounds. This is showing that the story and the movie/show were not exactly the same, but everything in the story was closely related or exactly the same in each.]]> 2018-11-02 14:12:05 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299794853 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795090 It stays faithful to the text because it has the same details and events as the book. For example, Herbert died getting stuck in the machinery, leading up to the family receiving a lot of money. This was shown in both the text and film.]]> 2018-11-02 14:12:33 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795090 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795293 The film version stayed faithful to the text, because the events happened like it was stated in the text. ]]> 2018-11-02 14:12:56 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795293 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795320 I think the film was basically the same as the text because it shared many of the same details as the text. The film may have got into a little more detail, but overall it shared many of the same details.  ]]> 2018-11-02 14:12:59 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795320 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795517

The film version departed from the text version in numerous ways. One way was the money wish. Mr. White wished for 200 pounds, but in the film he wished for 300 pounds. Also, the film version differed by adding many more scenes. Like the church scene where Sergeant-major Morris was praying. The film had the same lines of dialogue for the most part, there were still some things that differed from each other throughout the film and the text. In my opinion, the film version was better because it gave off a more suspenseful effect. The characters showed much more emotion and had a lot more fear. Though the text version was not my favorite, it still had a range of great parts. So, in conclusion, the film version differed from the text version.

]]> 2018-11-02 14:13:18 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795517 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795865 The film version stayed faithful to the text version because the film portrays the same message/theme as the text. Similar settings, description, and dialogue were also found in the film version of "The Monkey's Paw".]]> 2018-11-02 14:13:50 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795865 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795974 The filmed version of the Monkey's paw stays faithful to the text because It does what the characters do in the story and say's the words that the characters used the the text.]]> 2018-11-02 14:14:01 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299795974 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796267 the film was different then the story because in the story when Mr.white wished his first wish there was a piano sound but not in the movie.]]> 2018-11-02 14:14:31 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796267 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796709 The film and the text was almost the same but the film had more details.]]> 2018-11-02 14:15:20 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796709 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796934 i prefer the filmed version because its is more descriptive.]]> 2018-11-02 14:15:44 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796934 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796960 I think the film was the same as the book because some examples are when the son and father are playing chess both the book and film said the same things. Throughout the film and book say almost the same things and both had a sort of creepy vibe to it. They also keep the same story line throughout the whole thing. There were some differences though like when it said in the book "200 pounds" and the film said "300 pounds". Other than that there both pretty alike.  ]]> 2018-11-02 14:15:46 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299796960 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797098 I think the film stayed faithful to the story because a lot of the same lines were used in the film that were in the book. I also liked the film better because it has more details of the story and it obviously gives you a better visual of what is going on.]]> 2018-11-02 14:16:00 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797098 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797241 The Filmed version departed from the Text version because there were many differences in the movies that differed from the text. Some examples of the differences are that in the film the dad's name was Andrew, while in the story it didn't tell us his name. The same is for the mom because in the movie her name was Elizabeth and the story didn't tell us her name. In the story the Whites don't have dogs, but in the film it's mentioned that they have dogs. The person who had the first wish was an old man in the story, but in the Film the first wisher is a young man in the army that Sergeant-Major Morris knew well. In the film, Andrew stops Morris from burning the paw, yet in the story Elizabeth stops him. Andrew wishes for 200lbs in the story, but in the film his wish was for 300lbs. In the film after the parents were informed about there son's death, Mrs. White ]]> 2018-11-02 14:16:16 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797241 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797308 The film stayed faithful because the dialogue was about the same and the actions described in the text and video were the same. 

]]> 2018-11-02 14:16:23 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797308 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797378 I think that the film version stayed faithful to the text version because although it added a few minor details and scenes, it kept all the major details and even some direct dialogue pulled directly from the text.]]> 2018-11-02 14:16:32 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797378 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797767 The film version of " The Monkey's Paw" is different then the text version in a couple different ways. One way is, that the mom told Mr. White too wish for 200 pounds in the text version. Then, in the film The son told Mr. White to wish for 300 pounds.]]> 2018-11-02 14:17:13 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797767 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797770 the film stayed faithful to the story it had the same climax and same words.]]> 2018-11-02 14:17:14 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797770 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797902 I preferred the film because it helped me visualize what was going on after I read the text. ]]> 2018-11-02 14:17:25 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797902 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797941 I prefer the film over the story because the film shows a lot more emotion during their struggles. The film actually shows how the fakirs actually put the spell on the paw, and how the paw actually looks.]]> 2018-11-02 14:17:29 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299797941 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798110 I preferred the film over the story version because it has more details and you can picture what was going on through out the events.]]> 2018-11-02 14:17:46 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798110 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798182 The film version of "The Monkey's Paw" was different from the text in many ways. In the text version of the story when Mr. White made his first wish the piano made a noise. In the video the piano was not even mentioned nor did it make a sound. Another example is, in the text Mr. White payed Sergeant-Major Morris for the Monkey's Paw, but in the video he never did. I prefer the film version of  ''The Monkey's Paw'' because it gave me a better understanding of what happened in the story and you could actually see the true personalities of each character. ]]> 2018-11-02 14:17:53 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798182 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798453 I prefer the text version because in my opinion the text was more descriptive and detailed. To me description and detail is what makes a good story. Also with the text version I understood it more. I could make better connection with the characters and how they really felt. It also let me understand the more deeper meaning of the story. ]]> 2018-11-02 14:18:17 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798453 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798810 I preferred the film version because I was able to pick up on certain details and emotions that I didn't notice in the text version of the short story.]]> 2018-11-02 14:18:53 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798810 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798835 I preferred the film version because it is very easy to comprehend when you are watching it. It kept all the major details of the story and added a few minor ones. I thought it was more entertaining to see it this way as well.]]> 2018-11-02 14:18:56 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798835 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798927 I preferred the film version because it shows the events and actions through out the video. You get a good understanding of what is actually happening then trying to think about it in your head.]]> 2018-11-02 14:19:05 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299798927 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799209 In the film there was no seen with the fire. The scene was where Herbert was gazing at the fire and saw faces. In that scene it was foreshadowing his fate and should have been included.]]> 2018-11-02 14:19:35 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799209 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799275 I preferred the film version because it expressed the story in many ways and you can see what is going on. And I could catch on to what was going to happen next.]]> 2018-11-02 14:19:44 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799275 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799446 The filmed version of the story "The Monkey's Paw" was different from the text version because it had changed or did not add some important details to the film. For example, the mother in the film looked way younger than she was described in the story. She was said to be a white-haired old lady and in the story she looked very young and did not have white hair. Another example is that the lady ]]> 2018-11-02 14:20:01 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799446 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799838  I preferred the film version because I understand the plot more easily ]]> 2018-11-02 14:20:41 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299799838 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299800442 I preferred the film version way more because it helped me visualized what was going on and I understood the story more when I watched the film version. ]]> 2018-11-02 14:21:53 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299800442 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299800717 In the film Mr. white wish for 300 pounds, but in the book he wish for 200 pounds. Also, in the beginning they showed the background of Sgt. Major Morris and what he saw in India]]> 2018-11-02 14:22:27 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299800717 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299801183 I would rather watch the film than read the book because when I was reading the book its a little confusing to me. While I was watching the movie I understood more of what was happening and more into the story. Even tough its better to read and I did enjoy the book I had an easier time feeling the scary vibes and really knowing every detail that was there. So I would rather watch the film than read the book.  ]]> 2018-11-02 14:23:19 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299801183 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299802140 While the text was very descriptive, some scenes in the book led me curious and wanting to get a peek of what the Sergeant majors wish was. In the movie it did just that. In story I also did not fully understand what was going on in the scene and the book showed the scenes I could not visualize clearly.]]> 2018-11-02 14:25:02 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299802140 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299802783 I preferred the film more cause i can visually see whats going on in the story and understand it more.]]> 2018-11-02 14:26:09 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299802783 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299803145 The film departed from the text because the video showed the first man who wished on the monkey's paw as well as at the end the video showed the mother's grave with the father lying in front of it dead. They also changed little details like in the first wish Mr. White wished for 300 pounds instead of 200 and the family didn't talk about using the money to pay off the debt on the house. The short story also said the parents were very old, but they didn't look that old to me.]]> 2018-11-02 14:26:48 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299803145 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299804138 The film version departed from the text version because in the story in the text Mr.White wished for 200 pounds, but in the film it showed him saying he wishes for 300 pounds. Also in the film it shows what Sergeant-major Morris saw in India when he acquired the Monkey Paw, but it doesn't show that in the text version.]]> 2018-11-02 14:28:16 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299804138 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299807641 I prefer the film version because in certain scenes you better understand what is happening if you see the emotion the characters are shows within their facial expressions. In the film version you can clearly see the emotion given off by the characters, but in the text you have to inference what their faces look like.]]> 2018-11-02 14:34:02 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299807641 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299808766 2018-11-02 14:36:00 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/299808766 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/300193354 The filmed version of the story "The Monkey's Paw" was different from the text version because it had changed or did not add some important details to the film. For example, the mother in the film looked way younger than she was described in the story. She was said to be a white-haired old lady and in the film she looked very young and did not have white hair. Another example is that in the story Mr. White's first wish was for  two hundred pounds and even though in the movie he also asked for money it was three hundred pounds instead of two hundred.]]> 2018-11-04 15:32:22 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/300193354 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/300196958 I preferred the film version of "The Monkey's Paw" because it showed more background information especially in Sergeant-Major Morris's past. The film had also helped me visualize and understand the events more clearly. Even though the film was not an exact replica of the original text version, the included details cleared up some of the confusion I had with the story.]]> 2018-11-04 15:50:40 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/300196958 https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/300239620 I preferred the text version over the filmed version because the story was more detailed and because I get to visualize what I want to instead of seeing what is onscreen.]]> 2018-11-04 20:12:28 UTC https://padlet.com/bakaric/wksdpugk2cca/wish/300239620