Assessing evidence in final report by seniormentorcohort7

It is parcially achieved.

candyolivares — 2024-11-07 22:22:05 UTC

Yellow

2024-11-07 22:22:53 UTC

With the first description, there is no clarity about what AFL strategy they were developing. The Action points were not mention. They just talked about the progress done between recordings, but didn't mention what other activities they carried out.

Yellow

2024-11-07 22:25:01 UTC

The description is not rich enough to compare. It is not very clear. The narrative is not technical, for example the goal is related to AFL, but didn't mention any about decree 67, for example.

Light blue

cquezada9 — 2024-11-07 22:26:04 UTC

The description of the goal is clear in showing progress but lacks depth. It mentions improvements but doesn’t fully explain why these specific steps, like linking AfL strategies to Hattie’s questions, are important for reaching the goal. A bit more detail on how these steps fit the program’s bigger aims would make the description stronger.

Light blue

cquezada9 — 2024-11-07 22:26:55 UTC

The description gives a basic comparison of the mentee’s progress but lacks richness. It highlights some improvements, like the addition of key lesson planning elements, yet it doesn’t fully explore areas for improvement, such as the importance of connecting AfL strategies to Hattie’s questions. A more detailed comparison of the mentee’s initial and current performance, with insights into specific growth areas and remaining challenges, would make the description more comprehensive and balanced.

Yellow

2024-11-07 22:27:08 UTC

The elements that are missing are feedforward, because it doesn't say the actions planned in the future.

Light blue

cquezada9 — 2024-11-07 22:27:47 UTC

The description outlines some achievement of each Action Point, noting progress and partial gaps. However, it could better detail how each Action Point supports the overall goal. More specific examples of strengths and areas for improvement would clarify effectiveness.

Yellow

carlacisternas — 2024-11-07 22:28:03 UTC

We believe that there's an idea of having an analysis but it's still too broad, ideas are sketched but not detailed.