https://padlet.com/n160806_g/w1dmeutej58rk4yi en-us 2023-04-12 19:43:54 UTC 2025-11-11 21:05:57 UTC hello@padlet.com n160806_g https://padlet.com/n160806_g/w1dmeutej58rk4yi/wish/2552085861 Nina Glick Schiller has argued that this opening up of citizenship has led scholars to distinguish between political citizenship and social citizenship. 70 Claims of social citizenship occur through social practice rather than law, “when people make claims to belong to a state through collectively organizing to protect themselves against discrimination, or receive rights and benefits from a state, or make contributions to the development of a state and the life of people within it.” 71 Citizenship as social practice is different from a more cultural or identity-based approach to citizenship.


Leo Chavez borrows Nina Glick argument to help him support his claim. We know this is borrowing because he doesn't extend on this topic at all to go into the direction he wants to. ]]> 2023-04-12 19:47:44 UTC https://padlet.com/n160806_g/w1dmeutej58rk4yi/wish/2552085861 n160806_g https://padlet.com/n160806_g/w1dmeutej58rk4yi/wish/2552095174 However, Rosaldo and Flores’s definition of cultural citizenship, as claiming the right to be different, may not be enough. 80 Feelings of belonging and desire for inclusion in the social body exist in a dialectical relationship with the larger society and the state, which may or may not find such claims for cultural citizenship convincing. In this sense, cultural citizenship as subject-making is not a unilateral act, as Ong argues when she refers to it “as a dual process of selfmaking and being made within webs of power linked to the nation-state and civil society.” She adds, “Becoming a citizen depends on how one is constituted as a subject who exercises or submits to power relations.”

Chavez is borrowing Rosaldo and Flores's Definition of cultural citizenship. He doesn't add to what his own definition of cultural citizenship is so that is how we know it is borrowing. ]]> 2023-04-12 20:00:08 UTC https://padlet.com/n160806_g/w1dmeutej58rk4yi/wish/2552095174