Lucky Broken Girl by Pachion Carlson https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/15UNXraA66fiCKoP-5IsbaOFdfT_NHSlc22H1t9JHY34/edit#slide=id.g73065b07e_0_75 en-us 2018-02-24 14:12:37 UTC 2025-10-19 23:04:15 UTC hello@padlet.com https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1470324089l/31247023.jpg pcarlson20_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/234985396 2018-02-24 14:15:06 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/234985396 Question 1 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308022342
The book starts with Ruthie saying, “When we lived in Cuba I was smart. But when we got to Queens, in New York City, in the United States of America, I became dumb, just because I couldn’t speak English.” What do we know about Ruthie, based on this opening line? What else can we infer? What kinds of things do you expect from a book after reading this first line?
Answer 
We know that she is frustrated because she’s not in the smart class
even though she was smart in Cuba. She had to prove to her teacher that she was smart enough to be in the smart class by spelling the word commiserate. When she got the word right she was so happy because then her teacher said that she could transfer to the smart class on Monday. I feel bad for Ruti because if I was considered dumb just because I spoke a different language I Wouk be mad to. That’s also being very judge mental to Ruti just because she speaks a different language. We know about Ruti based on the opening line that she dose not take it when people say she is dumb because she was very mad when she got put in the dumb class just because she speaks a different language. I also think she is not stopped by any thing because Ruti and her friend both wanted to be in the smart class they wanted to ask the teacher if they could transfer to the smart class but Ramu didn’t want to ask instead Ruti asked with no problem as if nothing was going to stand in her way to be in that smart class. After reading the first line I expect the book to be like,big and outgoing with a lot of changes that Ruti and her family face but also some really great memories and moments. For example,when Ruti’s dad got her white gogo boots that she really wanted,when Ruti’s dad bought Izzie some toy cars and when Ruti’s dad bought himself a car. But some bad times are when the family gets into a car accident and Ruti broke her leg and now has to wear a body cast so she doesn’t grow and cause one of her legs to grow more than the other. I believe that Ruti will face a lot of hard and good times and I hope she will get through them all. In conclusion I think people should not be judged on their language that they speak. I wonder if in the book will their be any more unexpected/bad news like the body cast didn’t work or that Ruti isn’t allowed in the smart class ever. I think that this book will be great and full of surprises which makes me want to finish reading it even more also I could already recommend this book to people but also by reading just one part of it I would rate this book a 10/10 book because I love it so much and I never want to put it down.
   
]]> 2018-11-26 20:51:10 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308022342 Question 6: Ruthie’s mother always cries because she misses Cuba, but Ruthie’s Baba says, “We can’t keep looking back.” What can you infer about the family’s relationship to Cuba? What about their new relationship to the United States? Compare and contrast Mami’s experiences in Queens and in Cuba. I think there relationship with Cuba is strong especially Mami’s. But in some places it is weaker. In Mami’s perspective all she wants to do is go back to Cuba because she feels that if they did not come to America they would not have gotten in a car accident and Ruthie wouldn’t have had to be in a body cast. nreed000 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308024374 CQuestion 12
Ruthie talks about her big and her small wishes—her small wish is “to look out the window and just see the world” (56). In what ways is this wish bigger than Ruthie realizes?
This wish is bigger than ruthie realizes because other people in the accident are probably wishing that to and most likely she will have her wish granted and they won’t. That s why she is a lucky broken girl. Also being able to be outside is a privilege than some people do not have. 
Question 18
When Ruthie puts on Danielle’s old go-go boots, she learns to trust her leg again. Why do you think this is the case? What do the go-go boots represent for Ruthie now?
I think she learns to trust her leg with danielle’s Go go boots on because the go go boots reminded her brain that her leg is way stronger than it was at the accident and that she can trust it like she did before the accident. ]]> 2018-11-26 20:55:17 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308024374 Question 4 kkraner000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308505252 Ruthie really wants a pair of go-go boots like Danielle’s. She’s always walking around singing the popular 60s song “These Boots Are Made for Walkin’.” She can’t believe it when her Papi gets her a pair. What do go-go boots represent (symbolize) for Ruthie?

Answer

In my opinion, the boots give her confidence to be in the smart class and make her very happy. Ruth wants to we’re them every we’re she we’re them to school, bed, in the car, mostly every we’re. But not to play so she won’t get them dirty. According to the text on pg.28,” Guess what?” I announce proudly. “My father just got me go-go boots too!” “So why aren’t you wearing them?” Danielle replies “ I don’t want to get them dirty I say. She loves her go-go boots that much she won’t get a crumb on them. What go-go boots do for her is they make her think we’re she is now then we’re she was then. In the chapter crying about Cuba, all Mami and Ruth thought about was Cuba they cried a lot but not in the next chapter. In the next chapter Ruth gets her very own go-go boots at that point she totally forgets about Cuba. It tells her we’re safe here we will be fine here. Which her go-go boots she is the happiest girls on the planet. According to the text on pg.39 it states, “I feel so happy and grown-up wearing my go-go boots.”after answering this question i now know how much the go-go boots mean to her.]]> 2018-11-27 19:54:58 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308505252 Question 3 mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308507959 My question is “ List some positive expiences of being immagrant what does ruthie see as the benefit of being imagrant 
I think some positive experiences are that instead of suffering through not knowing what people are saying by having a translator.  ]]> 2018-11-27 19:59:51 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308507959 One part I liked mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308516472 One part I liked in the book was on page 17 because this happens” What is he carrying ? It is a shopping bag, for you Ruti A gift, A gift for me! Yes white gogo boots they fit just right”! The reason I like this part because you know ruthies mother says papi works really hard every day and somtimes has stressful days and he got a gift for ruthie and that just made her so thankful and happy.]]> 2018-11-27 20:16:15 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308516472 Question 2 agolke000 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308522720
Ramu is Ruthie’s first friend at school, maybe because they are both new immigrants who feel like they shouldn’t be in the “dumb” class. What else makes them get along so well?
Answer
Ruti and ramu May get along so easily, not just because their both in the “Dumb” class,although that is a pretty good reason,or that their both immigrants , but there’s many more reason why they could be friends. For example,relating to the dumb class, they both knew they were both smart but were in the class because they were both immigrants. At first it was only ruti that would be going to the “smart” class by spelling commiserate while Ramu didn’t. But since Ruti is a good friend,she almost begged for ramu to have a second chance. You need a friend that helps you like Ruti did to Ramu.On the plus side,they both got in the smart class in the end.In conclusion,I think Ruti and Ramu are good friends for different reasons and that’s a good thing.They both have differences and simaliar things about them as well. That’s why they are both great friends. Different and alike makes a great friendship.]]> 2018-11-27 20:29:33 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308522720 Question 7 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308527379 Ruthie has to translate for her mother at the grocery store. What other tasks is Ruthie given because of her unique immigrant experience? How does this add to our knowledge of the immigrant experience?
Answer
Ruti has to translate to her mom how to take care of her when she gets home from the hospital because she is in a body cast so she can’t move at all.]]> 2018-11-27 20:39:59 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308527379 Question 13 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308528936 Why does Ruthie want to become a storyteller? What can we infer about her desire to keep people’s stories?
Answer

]]> 2018-11-27 20:43:39 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308528936 Katie week 1 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308942182 How do you think Ruti and her mom get over Cuba? Why do you think they have such a strong relationship with Cuba?
Answer
I think Ruti and her mom get over Cuba by doing stuff to take it off their mind and thinking about the good about New York not the bad. Also I think they have a strong relationship with Cuba because they lived their and now have barely anything to remember it by. Like the doll Ruti had and the handkerchief Ruti’s mom had. In conclusion It is hard to let go of things  especially when you move from a place that you really really loved and made good memories at. So I get Ruti and her mom even though I haven’t experience that kind of a change.]]> 2018-11-28 17:58:50 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308942182 Anna agolke000 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308942202 How do you think ruti feels knowing that she may not be able to go to the smart class because of the crash that recently happened?]]> 2018-11-28 17:58:53 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/308942202 On page 48 mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309540857 I think on page 48 the girl doctor got mad at ruthie for having an accident and she is new to this and she is scared and I do t think the doctor would like it if so one was yelling at her for having an accident and she was scared she probably didn’t even realize it.]]> 2018-11-29 20:23:55 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309540857 Katie https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309577463 Answer to Anna’s question
I think Ruti is feeling very mad,sad but also maybe a little bit happy that she doesn’t have to go to school. I think she is mad because she can’t go out of her bed to do anything not to go to the bathroom because she is in a body cast. I also think she is sad because she can’t be in the smart class with Ramu so he is all alone in class. But another reason why she is happy is because she likes her 
tutor/private teacher. Ruti private teacher is nice to her and also is very concerning to to her but understanding about her situation. In conclusion I think Ruti is having mixed emotions but also having a hard time because of the mixed emotion.
 ]]> 2018-11-29 22:04:01 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309577463 Mackenzie’s awnser to anna’s Question mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309956588 I think ruti will be very sad that she will not be able to go to the smart class because she will not be able to go to school for like at least a few months and she will just have to stay in bed all day just sitting there on the bed while she does nothing and she thinks because she is not learning anything by just sitting there for like a few months that she will have to go back to the dumb class.]]> 2018-11-30 19:46:00 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309956588 Question 5 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309969421
Ruthie used to be “Miss Hopscotch Queen of Queens.” How does she react to this loss after the accident?  I infer that Ruthie is very sad or depressed. Because when she got put in a body cast the last thing that was said in part 1 is “I must have done something horribale to deserve this.” She also said “God  I promise I will commiserate with all broken people all over the whole wide world form now on,and forever.” In this time I think she felt very sad and she really wanted forgiveness ]]> 2018-11-30 20:19:02 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/309969421 Question 9 week 2 mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/311549169 At the beginning of the story, Ruthie is placed in the remedial class. Now Joy is her personal tutor and celebrates Ruthie’s work. Yet when Joy gives Ruthie a gold star, she says, “I think maybe part of the reason I am getting it is because Joy feels sorry for me” (56). What can we infer about Ruthie’s confidence based on this statement?]]> 2018-12-05 19:15:21 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/311549169 Question 10 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312034888  At the beginning of the story, Ruthie is placed in the remedial class. Now Joy is her personal tutor and celebrates Ruthie’s work. Yet when Joy gives Ruthie a gold star, she says, “I think maybe part of the reason I am getting it is because Joy feels sorry for me” (56). What can i infer about Ruthie’s confidence based on this statement? I infer that Ruthies confidence is really down to the ground because I bet you that Ruthie deserved that gold star. ]]> 2018-12-06 20:39:59 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312034888 Question 8 agolke000 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312074323 TRuthie’s mother always cries because she misses Cuba, but Ruthie’s Baba says, “We can’t keep looking back.” What can you infer about the family’s relationship to Cuba? What about their new relationship to the United States? Compare and contrast Mami’s experiences in Queens and in Cuba.

Awnser
Ruthie and her family have lived in Cuba since who knows and you can infer that the entire family wants to try and start a new life but it’s hard.thats why baba is probably saying “We Can’t keep looking back.” Imagine moving away from a place you have known by heart since you were born. Hard to forget but trying to move on? That’s how ruthie must feel.I infer that why Ruthie’s mother is crying so often about Cuba,because it was her first home and you never forget your first home.They have a different connection with the United States then they did with Cuba.for one example, the relationship with The United States is new while Cuba is there older relationship. So far,the United states has made good memories and terrible ones . On of her terrible memories was the car crash. Then I bet she just wanted to go back to cuba,wishing nothing like this ever happened and everyone was happy. But instead,she was in a bodycast  not even being able to use the restroom for herself.And yet,there were happy moments too. For example,when daddy bought her the white Gogo boots that she was so proud of.She was one of the happiest people alive then. There are ups and downs when it comes to relationships in general. But personally,I think she will like it in America when she can walk again.Mami has had ups and downs in America too. A few ups were when she knew everyone was alive from the car accident and safe (mostly). But many downs. Thinking she can’t take care of herself like she did in Cuba,or taking care of the children while father was at work. She worked hard to keep the family running in America so they wouldn’ Be homeless or have to go back to Cuba.One of the only differences I spotted in how mami felt toward Cuba and America were that she was more happy in Cuba.In conclusion, I thinkin the end they will like that America is their happy little home.

]]> 2018-12-06 23:30:16 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312074323 Awnser to question 9 week 2 mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312074650 I think Ruthie is convinced this because Joy knows Ruthie has a broken leg and a full body cast. Ruthie probably thinks Joy wants to make Ruthie happy because she knows how much pain she’s in sitting in bed all day and that seems to make her happy ]]> 2018-12-06 23:32:44 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312074650 Question 15 week 3 mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312392610 After her injury, Ruthie is angry with Danielle for not coming to visit; however, they eventually become very close friends. How does Ruthie’s view of Danielle change over the course of the book?]]> 2018-12-07 19:39:05 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312392610 Anna week 2 agolke000 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312394636 Has the accident change Ruthie? If it has,how?]]> 2018-12-07 19:43:49 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312394636 -Mackenzie a question I want you guys to awnser!! mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312398190 How do you think Ruthie feels about chichio? ]]> 2018-12-07 19:52:21 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/312398190 Question agolke000 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/313611873 Now that Ruthie is healed she has a new obstacle to overcome, but this one isn’t physical. Why is Ruthie afraid to walk?

wnser]]> 2018-12-11 20:18:04 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/313611873 Question 10 kkraner000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/313612514 In the beginning of the story, Ruthie is placed in the remedial class. Now Joy is her personal tutor and celebrates Ruthie’s work. Yet when Joy gives Ruthie a gold star, she says, “I think maybe part of the reason I am getting it is because Joy feels sorry for me” (56). What can we infer about Ruthie’s confidence based on this statement?

Answer 
We can infer that ruthie has lack in confidence because everyone is trying to make her seam as she did awesome  when she did not do to good. Like when ruthie was home schooled joy would always say she did s good job and always give her a gold star,  no matter what.and when her real teacher came to see her she was so sorry, but she only showed that. We could infer she only said that because ruthie was right there. If Ruthie knew that she didn’t really care about her her confidence you be at 0. Even though right now she doesn’t believe in herself later on she probably won’t either.

]]> 2018-12-11 20:19:39 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/313612514 Question 7 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/313615697 Also Ruthies mom is now starting to know English so she can go to the store with out Ruthie and talk to the check out man.]]> 2018-12-11 20:26:18 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/313615697 Question 11 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/314416027 When Ruthie gets sad while she is bedridden in her cast, she often thinks about Cuba (56). How do her memories of Cuba help her to heal? Why do you think she keeps returning to Cuba in her mind?

]]> 2018-12-13 18:57:52 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/314416027 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/314498860 I think when Ruthie returns to Cuba in her mind she feels safer because that’s where she grew up that’s where she has her family. That’s also where she has all of her friends. How I think or infer Ruthie heals from thinking of Cuba is all the amazing things that happend. Also I feel that Ruthie keeps trying to forget Cuba and focus on her new life in cuba]]> 2018-12-13 23:11:57 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/314498860 Week 3 question 16 kkraner000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/314811357 When Ruthie is talking with Papi about how angry she is with the boys who caused the accident, he tells her, “Even good people can do bad things” (72). Do you agree? What would you say to Ruthie about her anger and hate? Why do you think she says that the anger is “a stone in her heart”? 

Answer

I think she should be mad but also feel sad for the person who caused the accident. In my opinion she should be mad at the person because of what he did to the people in the accident. An example is, the person who caused the accident killed the other four people in the accident and he parlize one person. Also the car broke Ruthies leg and she has to not move and stay in bed for more than 8 months. But I also think Ruthie should fell sorry for the person, because referring back to what papa said “even good people can do bad things.” The person in the accident could of been good but that night he wasn’t that conscientious. If Ruthie was me I would feel bad because the night it could of been a bad one and everyone in the car died. I would be so sad if I died in a car accident by someone else but his family is probably never going to be happy again. I feel bad for his family and friends and hope that doesn’t happen again.😔]]> 2018-12-14 19:59:12 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/314811357 Awnser to week 3 mbelland000_1_3 https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/315349033 I think at first ruthie thought Daniel was her best freind.But  during the middle of the book we’re Ruthie broke her foot and she had to be in a body cast for 4 months, she was pretty mad at Daniel for not visiting her at all only once in the total 10 months. But in the end of the book we’re Daniel gave her gogo  boots to ruthie she became her best freind.]]> 2018-12-17 20:41:56 UTC https://padlet.com/pcarlson20_3/vrwr8eg6vy3m/wish/315349033