Does equity equal to equality? Discuss by CelesteYuen https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7 Please discuss among your group members and upload it in Padlet en-us 2018-09-10 11:48:04 UTC 2018-09-12 07:52:05 UTC hello@padlet.com Ok https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280222971 2018-09-12 07:39:08 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280222971 Elaine Lau Yin Ling, Seraph Luk Hiu Laam, Zachary Chin Chi Ho, Edwin Choy Siu Fung, Alexander Leung Ho Yin, Summer Li Hiu Wang https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223104 While opportunity equality can be achieved by compulsory education, education equity puts learner's individual differences into consideration.

Opportunity equality only provides identical opportunities & resources without considering individual needs. ]]> 2018-09-12 07:39:38 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223104 Elliot 1155076012, claudia 1155077873 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223106 No, 要達至教育公平需要有vertical equity （根據學生情況分配資源）。 

]]> 2018-09-12 07:39:39 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223106 1155077436鄭康怡， 1155079846羅芷琪，1155078020林思穎，1155064327張嘉敏 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223121 教育公平和機會平等並不是均等，教育公平傾向有教無類和按需要給予支援，幫助學生達到一定的成就；而機會平等只提供同等入場機會。雖然香港提供免費教育是能夠做到機會平等，但不等於教育上的平等，以津校和直資為例，學生都有機會進入這些學校，但他們所接受到的教育質素和資源是不同，因此他們的教育結果亦是不同。]]> 2018-09-12 07:39:44 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223121 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223129 Not okay]]> 2018-09-12 07:39:46 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223129 Hi https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223157 2018-09-12 07:39:52 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223157 1111 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223214 2018-09-12 07:40:03 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223214 Brian 1155078559 Henry 1155078563 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223216 不同意。雖然大家都有免費教育(equality)，但並不代表所有學生能夠在免費教育機制下發揮所長(equity)，例如不同組別的學校學校有不同的學習資源。]]> 2018-09-12 07:40:03 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223216 Sin Yau, Chan Shiu Tang, Chung Long Hin, Chan Hong Ting, Ho Tsoi Ni, Hui Nga Sze https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223220 No, because
1. having equal opportunities (horizontal equity) is only the prerequisite
2. Educational equity also means tailored support that cater for Ss’ individual needs (vertical equity)]]> 2018-09-12 07:40:04 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223220 菲力 一一五五零六四八六五 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223225 機會平等=/=教育公平]]> 2018-09-12 07:40:05 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223225 Chan kin Ying (1155062733), Chan suet yi (1155064466), Cheung ka man (1155064125) Chau Hiu kwan (1155063905), tang hei man (1155064645), Lo king Yeung (1155063455), Li Tsz Yuen( 1155063599) https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223276 否
就香港社會而言，機會平等並不等於教育公平。香港提供了15年的免費教育與全港學生，讓所有人都能夠接受教育機會，香港社會提供了很多資源及弱勢的學生，例如給點字書予視障學生，有學習困難的學生，他的考試模式又會有所調整，由此可見香港社會給予了很多額外的資源去幫助弱勢的學生。雖然政府提供了很多客觀的條件去讓他們再入學習的環境，但不等於他們就能夠有正面的學習成果。而且，教師在教學時也會有很多主觀的想法及教學信念，他們未必能做到公平地對待每一個學生。

]]> 2018-09-12 07:40:19 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223276 1155064526 Yam Tsz Lung https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223283 No, since everyone is unique, the students who have special needs need more caring. ]]> 2018-09-12 07:40:22 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223283 Yip Shin Chun 1155049504 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223304 No. It is interrelated and equity is value judgement. Not everyone need the same opportunity. ]]> 2018-09-12 07:40:26 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223304 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223409 1155079207Ho Tze Yau
機會平等是基本，教育公平必須先做到機會平等]]> 2018-09-12 07:40:51 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223409 1155079367 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223489 Not equal
公平同平等係兩個唔同既概念]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:07 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223489 1155063417 (Toni)，1155064865 (菲力) https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223505  
“機會平等”不等於“教育公平” 
學生有平等機會接受教育，但並不等於在教育裡面受到的待遇是公平的。政府有明文規定學生享受15年免費教育，無論是什麼種族的香港人都能享有這個權利。然而，當學生進入學校接受教育時，並不能夠保證每位學生在學校入面受到一模一樣的公平教育。
]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:10 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223505 1155077773 gaga, 1155077743 moses https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223515 no
because there are peraonal factors that hinder pupils to access education (eg.ethnic background, ses), even that opportunity is given]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:11 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223515 1155064534 Li Kwun Yin https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223566 不一樣，皆因人的特質本身不一樣，在接受同樣的資源時，帶來的結果和意義的差距很大。考慮教育公平時，應從教育目的和意義出發，而並非取決於機會和資源的平等。]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:22 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223566 To hiu yin 1155079642 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223623 No]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:34 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223623 no https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223634 2018-09-12 07:41:37 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223634 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223639 Not equal. ]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:37 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223639 1155064909,1155063937,1155078699,1155078815,1155077448 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223662 不是。教育給人提供公平競爭，向上流動的機會，幫助弱勢者擺脫他出身的那個群體的局限。]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:44 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223662 1155064178 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223673 No no no not ok

]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:47 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223673 1155078275 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223700 not equal

]]> 2018-09-12 07:41:53 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223700 1155079367 https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223879 Not equal]]> 2018-09-12 07:42:35 UTC https://padlet.com/CelesteYuen/vjyfinj1goa7/wish/280223879