Mad science by

Acknowledge and Confront Ethical Legacies

2025-05-27 07:01:32 UTC

Publicly recognize when discoveries were made through unethical means, such as exploitation, lack of consent, racism, or abuse.
Include the full context of the discovery in scientific publications, educational materials, and public communications.

Promote Ethical Retrospective Justice

safeerajasmeen2 — 2025-05-27 07:14:42 UTC

Create pathways for redress, such as scholarships, memorials, or public apologies for communities harmed by unethical research.
Update scientific institutions’ codes of conduct and historical records to reflect these truths.

Correcting Historical Inaccuracies

safeerajasmeen2 — 2025-05-27 07:15:06 UTC

Update educational materials to reflect more accurate credit.
Use dual naming (referring to "Cardano's rule (sometimes attributed to Tartaglia)" to highlight disputes or corrections.
Acknowledge overlooked contributors, particularly women, people of color, and colonized individuals whose work was often suppressed or stolen.

How historical inaccuracies are corrected

2025-05-27 07:15:57 UTC

1) New evidence

archaelogical finds, documents or firsthand accounts can shift understanding

-Niccolo Tartaglia was the one who discovered the solution to certain cubic equations before Cardano; revealed by reviewing Tartaglia’s notebooks and letters.

-Cardano’s work used rhetorical algebra (writing equations in words instead of symbols) which was an evolution of European and Arabic mathematicians rather than him being a solo genius

2) Reinterpretation

historians reanalyse events using new theories or perspectives (e.g feminist, postcolonial or technological lens)

-Cardano’s work was part of a larger tradition whereby it was already formalised by Islamic mathematicians

-This gives the perspective that he’s more of a compiler and synthesiser of the equation

3) Digital archives and technology

advanced tools like AI, satellite imagery, carbon dating can make it easier to verify or challenge past claims

-AI

summarise and contextualise texts across languages and time periods
identify philosophical patterns (e.g. stoicisim and determinism) across Cardano’s scattered works
Compare Cardano’s ideas with earlier thinkers like Aristotle, Galen and Descartes

-Digital bases (Europeana and JSTOR)

visualise intellectual networks of the Renaissance to see how ideas flowed
reveals that he was influenced by by not only matheticians but also astrologers, physicians and philosophers

safeerajasmeen2 — 2025-05-27 07:23:38 UTC

In science, credit often goes to the first person to publish, not the first to discover

This leads to:

Historical inaccuracies
Ethical concerns

Discoverers can be forgotten if:

They don’t publish
They’re less famous or have less power

Raises the question:

“Is it fair to reward the first to publish even if they weren’t the true discoverer?”

safeerajasmeen2 — 2025-05-27 07:24:18 UTC

Tartaglia: Discovered method to solve cubic equations

Cardano: Asked Tartaglia to share it under a promise of secrecy

Cardano later broke that promise and published it

Claimed someone else had a similar solution → used that to justify publishing

Gave Tartaglia minor credit, but the method became known as Cardano’s Rule

safeerajasmeen2 — 2025-05-27 07:24:54 UTC

Why This Still Matters

These situations still happen today
Credit is often taken from:
- Less powerful scientists
- Women, minorities, or those in the background
When this happens:
- Science loses fairness
- Trust and collaboration are damaged
Example of broader impact:
- Promoting unethical behavior in the name of progress