https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9 Comment on the 3 rules that you would be most shocked by, impacted by, or nervous about in Jonas' situation. en-us 2019-03-19 19:02:12 UTC 2019-03-21 03:20:09 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/icons/Apple.png bradley_crossett https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343408789 Having this burned into your brain for 12 years, I don't think he would even have the capacity to lie]]> 2019-03-20 16:03:08 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343408789 Jessernaut1 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409349 I would be confused if my whole life I wasn’t able to lie and now I just have the choice.]]> 2019-03-20 16:04:06 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409349 bradley_crossett https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409515 This is kind of weird... "HEY LOOK AT ME I'M THE RECIEVER TELL ME YOUR DEEPEST SECRETS" and actually getting answers?]]> 2019-03-20 16:04:26 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409515 onoasi_odoeffiong https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409821 Onoasi 
If I was in Jonas’s position I would feel weird because as a kid I would’ve been taught to never lie and lying would have had serious consequences. I would kind of feel bad lying to my friends .]]> 2019-03-20 16:05:01 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409821 alexa_mccloskey https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409954 I would be the most nervous about this rule becuase it could ruin some relationships you have like with your parents and friends. You would no longer be able to tell your friends and family about your day. For me, my mom and dad always ask how my day went and what I did so it would be hard to just say I can’t tell you.]]> 2019-03-20 16:05:16 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409954 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409964 I would be a little shocked, being nice all my life and being punished when being rude. Now not having to be punished and be free, different from everyone else]]> 2019-03-20 16:05:18 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343409964 coleton_cooper https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410109 This is a good thing for Johnas ]]> 2019-03-20 16:05:34 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410109 Jessernaut1 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410363 I would be confused as to why I can’t tell my family unit because normally we have to tell them everything]]> 2019-03-20 16:05:53 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410363 joseph_howell https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410581 I think this would be the wierdest for me, as I would usually get in trouble for lying]]> 2019-03-20 16:06:20 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410581 avery_robinson1 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410661 I would ne nervous about rule number 3 because he went from not allowed to ask questions to people because it would be rude, but he is allowed now because he is the receiver. I would also be shocked because I would get punished for being rude to people and now he can have options. If he asked certain questions and receive answers that were not expected.]]> 2019-03-20 16:06:28 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410661 bradley_crossett https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410873 Just don't even try? Snap your femurs in half "Oh well that sucks for you Jonas I guess you'll just have to deal with it"]]> 2019-03-20 16:06:49 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410873 Jessernaut1 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410926 I would probably wonder why they think I might want to apply for a release]]> 2019-03-20 16:06:56 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410926 anna_mcauley https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410986 If you were a kid and you were told over and over not to lie and if you did, you would’ve been beaten until you uunderstood the rule, it would be hard to lie. You would feel shocked and potentially overwhelmed if you were told to lie after being told not to lie for your entire life]]> 2019-03-20 16:07:02 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343410986 nichol_newtonwestman https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411003 Nick
I would be happy that I could lie because it would give me a lot of freedom that I didn’t have before.]]> 2019-03-20 16:07:03 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411003 coleton_cooper https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411022 This is gonna be hard for him because of all the pain he is going to experience ]]> 2019-03-20 16:07:05 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411022 alexa_mccloskey https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411159 I would not like these rules becuase there is no time to hang out with friends and family. There would be no time for homework or hobbies either. You would just sleep, eat, go to school, go to work, then repeat which does not sound like a life I would want to lead.]]> 2019-03-20 16:07:19 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411159 kate_schleihauf https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411186 This rule would have shocked me the most. Being able to ask any question and receive the answer is much different then what Jonas would be used to. This may lead to some issues in Jonas’ life because he could ask for something he wasn’t prepared to hear, such as the history of his “utopia”.]]> 2019-03-20 16:07:22 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411186 coleton_cooper https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411246 I agree ]]> 2019-03-20 16:07:28 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411246 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411412 I think that Jonas would be most impacted by Not being able to share any part of his trading with family or friends. I think that Jonas will follow this rule, but I think that it will have a reaction with his social life. If his friends or family asks how his day went since he is not allowed to share anything, he will feel more disconnected because he must stay secretive..]]> 2019-03-20 16:07:44 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411412 nichol_newtonwestman https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411563  ]]> 2019-03-20 16:08:00 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411563 joseph_howell https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411602 This would be extremely unsettling for me, as it implies that others have wanted to release, and now they have no option for to be released ]]> 2019-03-20 16:08:04 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411602 onoasi_odoeffiong https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411972 Onoasi 
I would feel alone and sad because I wouldn’t be allowed to tell my friends about how much fun or how boring the training was]]> 2019-03-20 16:08:38 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343411972 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412075 I would be confused since I was forced to tell my family unit everything and then being able to  not tell them anything. I’d be very confused, like I stated before, and would take a long time to adjust for me]]> 2019-03-20 16:08:47 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412075 avery_robinson1 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412214 Rule 2 and 3?
I would be shocked because I would be so used to being able to spend time with my friends and family, but now he has to go straight home after training and wouldn’t get to stop and see your friends I would also be impacted by this because i would be used to seeing people instead of just myself]]> 2019-03-20 16:09:03 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412214 brooklyn_best https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412416 I would not like rule 1 and 2 because I would like to have a life outside of school, work and home. I would want to hang out with my friends and do fun things instead of doing the same boring routine every day.]]> 2019-03-20 16:09:23 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412416 kaitlyn_nix https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412432 I would hate to go there right after school I would like to see my friends and family ]]> 2019-03-20 16:09:25 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412432 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412561 I was literally scolded my whole life not to lie. Even if I did lie it would probably connected to a joke or something.]]> 2019-03-20 16:09:39 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412561 joseph_howell https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412709 This would be weird for me because I share most of my life with my family and friends, and I wouldn’t be allowed to with this rule in my life ]]> 2019-03-20 16:09:57 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343412709 lauren_whelpley https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413013 This rule would be weird for me because I would get grounded at home if I lied to my parents. ]]> 2019-03-20 16:10:27 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413013 onoasi_odoeffiong https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413106 I like this rule because I wouldn’t have to tell about any weird dreams or «stirrings »]]> 2019-03-20 16:10:37 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413106 nichol_newtonwestman https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413182 Nick 
That would suck because in your training if you get an infection,your dead.]]> 2019-03-20 16:10:44 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413182 kaitlyn_nix https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413234 WI would hate to lie I don don like to lie ]]> 2019-03-20 16:10:50 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413234 kate_schleihauf https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413604 This rule would be difficult for Jonas. Especially for the fact that he may be told something by the older Reciver Of Momory and later figure out that what he was told was a lie. Jonas may not know what to believe anymore and start asking questions that give away too much information. Being able to lie he could loose friends and cause trouble in the community.]]> 2019-03-20 16:11:28 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413604 anna_mcauley https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413642 This rule, in a way, is similar to the lying rule because for your entire life you would’ve had to share your dreams to your family for your entire life and then you’re not aloud to anymore, you would’ve grown up with all these rules, only for you to be told to break them. With your dreams your are meant to share them, but then once you become Receiver Of Memory you’ll never be able to present your dreams, you’ll have to lie about having one.]]> 2019-03-20 16:11:32 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413642 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413758 If I was in Jonas position I would feel awful to be able to lie. You always get caught in a lie and there is always concaquences. The rule was you may lie. So Jonas doesn’t have to lie it’s just out there for him. Whenever you lie you feel awful about it and there will always be regrets. Jonas needs to keep in mind what the consequences will Ben if he lies to his family’s and friends. Do you think Jonas will lie?? I have a feeling Jonas will lie to his friends / family and be very upset and regret everything. He will not be a receiver of memories because it I see crumpbiling his life. I would not ever lie if I was in Jonas position. That’s what I feel about the rule ”you may lie.”]]> 2019-03-20 16:11:45 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413758 brooklyn_best https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413759 I would not like this as I would feel very secretive. Not being able to tell people would most likely result in me losing the trust of friends and family. ]]> 2019-03-20 16:11:45 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343413759 lynken_vosburg https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414011 If i was in this position I would probably feel really weird because I am able to lie now but as a kid if I lied I would be in trouble]]> 2019-03-20 16:12:14 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414011 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414348 I think that this rule will be the most confusing to follow. Having something drilled into your brain for 12 years can become a normal habit. If Jonas is told that he is allowed to lie now, I think that he would feel a lot of guilt after he lies because he is now the only person in the community who is allowed to.]]> 2019-03-20 16:12:51 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414348 nichol_newtonwestman https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414360 This would be nice because then you wouldn’t have to pay attention to what you say and then “upgrade” your vocabulary ]]> 2019-03-20 16:12:52 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414360 roha_imran https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414404 2019-03-20 16:12:56 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414404 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414570 this rule is quite the block. (If you know what I mean) you basically can’t even think outside of this wretched community. What this rule is saying is, even if you wanted to go somewhere else, you can’t. However, most of the releases are caused by an individual betraying the rules/community.]]> 2019-03-20 16:13:14 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414570 avery_robinson1 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414645 I would feel impacted because my whole life I would be taught to not lie and if you lie,I would get in big trouble. Now as the receiver of memories he can lie and tell his community lies that he says are true. Although, I would be shocked because I have so many questions. Did my parents lie?, did the Community lie? You wouldn’t know but now you do. You can tell lies and not get in trouble for it]]> 2019-03-20 16:13:22 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414645 alexa_mccloskey https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414840 This rule would be hard to follow becuase for twelve years of your life you were told that you must not lie and that lying was bad and now suddenly you can. People would not really trust you anymore becuase they know that you can lie and you could whenever you felt like it]]> 2019-03-20 16:13:40 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343414840 alex_coulombe https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415015 I know that I would like going to the dwelling because the view is so peaceful and nice plus I love living on the edge and no a-fence to Joann’s but his family sucks thay are so plan and that giver guy is so cool and full of coller (see what I did) and that is why I would like go to the dwelling after work.]]> 2019-03-20 16:13:55 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415015 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415186 I’d be really shocked because if I lived in this “utopia”, from a young age I’d be told  over and over to not lie and if I did it would have very serious consequences. So now, being able to lie would change my life..]]> 2019-03-20 16:14:11 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415186 kate_schleihauf https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415570 Not being able to tell his dreams may affect him. Jonas won’t be able to tell what he is feeling. What if he has a dream that might come true. He won’t be able work with his dreams.]]> 2019-03-20 16:14:52 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415570 lauren_whelpley https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415661 “What happens if I get a really bad injury. What happens if I need surgery. It will hurt so badly. This will be really hard not to take pain killers.]]> 2019-03-20 16:15:00 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343415661 brooklyn_best https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416184 I would be very worried about the reason to why they need this rule. This implies that in some ways you have a higher chance of getting hurt than I would have thought. I would not really want a job that has this rule.]]> 2019-03-20 16:15:53 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416184 anna_mcauley https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416468 Receiver Of Memory probably wouldn’t be aloud to apply for a release because there is usually only one Receiever of Memory (R.O.M.) in The Community, if a R.O.M. applies for a release and is granted permission for it, then there would be no one else left to share the memories of the past to the future Receiver Of Memory. In fact, the R.O.M. that was before Jonas, might’ve applied for release and granted it, only for the community to realize they made a mistake, but that’s just what I think.]]> 2019-03-20 16:16:22 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416468 lynken_vosburg https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416510 I think this would be really hard because everybody would bug you about the training and you wont be able to say anything ]]> 2019-03-20 16:16:26 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416510 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416602 I would not enjoy this rule. I think this because if i had homework or basketball afternoon school I would not be able to attend them due to my commitment. This job would stress me out and would not Ben fun. I would would be stressed about being on time following the rule, wanting to know the consequences if I didn’t follow the rules. Finally I wouldent be able to have my after school snack and get tutored for education reasons. I wouldent even be able to see my family and my angels from heaven my dogs.]]> 2019-03-20 16:16:37 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416602 lauren_whelpley https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416923 This rule would be hard to stay with because I tell my parents all about my dreams I have. “What happens if I have a bad dream?” I need to tell someone ]]> 2019-03-20 16:17:09 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343416923 alex_coulombe https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343417442 I would love to lie because no one would ever expect it and would believe you know mater what ]]> 2019-03-20 16:18:07 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343417442 roha_imran https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343417999







I would not like rule #1and 2 because I would have like, no life I’d have to wake up go to work/school and then home.I would never see my friends or family whom live not with me.like I would hate my life without my friends.There would be no time for me to do stuff I actually enjoy like my hobbies or homework.aits like eat sleep and repeat]]> 2019-03-20 16:19:07 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343417999 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343418640 WHAt happen if I hurt my self and I needed to go to thr hospital. I wouldent be able to train because I would need rest and would Ben in pain Andy would need my family and friends.]]> 2019-03-20 16:20:09 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343418640 https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343420469 This would be extremely uncomfortable for others, and i could never bring myself to do this. It is literally harassment taken to the next level.]]> 2019-03-20 16:23:26 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343420469 roha_imran https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343424953 I would not like this I  would feel like I’m being secretive.like I  share every thing with my family and friends.I think that Jonas will follow this rule,but there must be some reaction for example he might loose his friends or he might me kicked out of the place.I would feel lonely and sad i couldn’t even tell my friends ]]> 2019-03-20 16:31:10 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343424953 roha_imran https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343594566 2019-03-21 01:08:56 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343594566 roha_imran https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343615643 Not being able to share your dreams would be hard it could have a negative effect on jonnas.Jonnas can’t share his feelings or dreams , what if his dream comes true he wouldn’t be prepared mentally and physically. What’s the point of having a rule that you can share your dreams and now all of a sudden you can’t anymore,Jonnas grew up know he can share his feelings and dreams with his family and friends and now he can’t.this rule would be to hard for me cause I share mostly  everything including my dreams and feelings with my family and friends and now I’m kinda banned from doing that.If I were in jonnases position I would probably break the rule cause I can’t really keep my dreams  to myself.]]> 2019-03-21 03:11:32 UTC https://padlet.com/courtis1/thegiver_chapter9/wish/343615643