Water Equity Principles by Ana Lucía García https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h Made with big dreams en-us 2021-09-27 17:58:28 UTC 2021-10-06 22:17:15 UTC hello@padlet.com Discussion garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772035771 2021-09-27 17:59:24 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772035771 HI! https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772110993 2021-09-27 18:26:02 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772110993 EDF's DEIJ vision is much stronger and emphasizes different priorities than the standard EDF descriptor language, like the first paragraph of what EDF puts on all job descriptions https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772125579 2021-09-27 18:31:10 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772125579 vanessa606 https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772129320  "traditional and historic resource users" - is this really a marginalized community?

]]> 2021-09-27 18:32:25 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772129320 Story telling garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772140757 Ted Talk goes back to the firt principle. In order to understand everyone's story the very first thing we have to do is listen to them first. 

Different versions of stories.

]]> 2021-09-27 18:36:26 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772140757 Questions to answer garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772165660 How do the principles confirm or challenge the work we are doing, or the way in which we are doing it?

What basic values or vision of  water equity is conveyed by these principles? Does it fit your values and vision?
]]> 2021-09-27 18:45:46 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772165660 #3. Commit to doing no harm dwmmclaughlin https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772170294 I like this. This would mean that we need to account for who benefits or who pays for each policy or program we promote. Normally, markets and economic solutions to problems only look at aggregate benefits. In contrast, we would need to ensure we are able to compensate groups who may lose as the result of a policy-making sure they are no worse off (and hopefully better off) than in the status quo scenario.]]> 2021-09-27 18:47:33 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772170294 Different visions garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772176299 How do Programs (missions) develop their own principles and how can we integrate the institutional and programmatic principles? ]]> 2021-09-27 18:49:59 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772176299 I wonder to what degree we should acknowledge past inequities in everything we say/write? https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772178782 2021-09-27 18:51:03 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772178782 How can we better incorporate these principles into action? https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772183445 2021-09-27 18:53:05 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772183445 I wonder about this paragraph as it relates to SGMA in CA disproportionately affecting small-scale farmers and how you balance that with the need for systemic change (less groundwater pumping): https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772185693
As we pursue solutions to local and large-scale water challenges, we must be certain that the interventions we endorse and implement do not result in (or perpetuate) inequities or injustices for individuals or groups at any spatial or temporal scale. ]]> 2021-09-27 18:54:03 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772185693 First impressions garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772186329 Reference to principle 1. Historic resource usage. In Texas big farmers and agricultural interests I think we need to define what traditional historic resource is that is and whether or not. 

Principles feel like a foundation. It will never be fully baked. As we continue inthis perpetual journey of learning we can continue revising. 
After we agree that this is a solid foundation we can look at our major work streams and are they aligned to the principles and what do we need to modify. How do these apply to the workstream we have going on. 

Problem: How EDF defines environmental [problems. " Environmental decisions are made based on economic dynamics. " But they are also made based on power dynamics. That is especially true in water and EJ issues. People and nature need to define problems in a way that we recognize that all people and nature, not just economics and nature. 

Lead service replacement board for Denver water and it is very far from what we do and I feel I am taking the seat because it is not my area of expertise. It is water and justice but is this a productive use of my time. I am curious how we strategize forward and cn we get more resources and activities to that and how do we navigate in a water

Growing interest and appetite to have a more measurable impact with DACs that we come into contact with. 

This is not some add one we are being much more intentional in the outcomes and partners we work with. 

It feels like our program's focus is a lot on water quantity but the biggest space around water is access to clean water and water quality. There needs to be both but that is just something we struggle. What is our role there, how d we message what our role is. 

We are trying to be good allies to our partner organizations. We haven't been able to figure out our role on the ground and there is a lot more on the TAP work. 

It seems like in addition to the crosswalk, moving forward what are the opportunities and filling some of those gaps. Future looking. 

These principles are amazing and we need to do more but what does that look like and what resources do we have to make some actions happen? 

Dan and Vanessa will go to West Texas to meet with stakeholders on spring flow protection near Fort Davis. The pools around there. Convening on the different science and data needs there is no policy in place to protect the springs and there is an overwhelmingly Hispanic population that doesn't engaged and is fearful of engaging. and then you have the landowners who are white and own property around the system. We are going in there with little on the ground understanding. We have talked to scientists and academics but we haven't talked to people who live there. 

I don't see that we immediately change the scope we are working on ( water supply system) upstream of the pumps. I don;t envision us changing that immediately 

Water quality, part of our strength is staying focused on a specific realm of work. It is very easy to see an issue that is adjacent and be part of that but we have to be careful to not expand into topics of what our expertise is. We should consider those but through the perspective of how to stay focused. 

Principle 3 resonates with me, in economics you have this opportunity as principle water is not allocated by economics. Being an ally on who is getting access or not getting access there are opportunities of equity in the line of work you are doing. 

]]> 2021-09-27 18:54:19 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772186329 garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772234317 On defining water problems and quality, quanitty etc, I found the 2014 Santa Cruz declaration declation helpful - https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02508060.2014.886936 ]]> 2021-09-27 19:14:15 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772234317 garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772238049 Clarity that we cannot disconnect water and justice considerations. We can have a do no harm principle when in reality we are still]]> 2021-09-27 19:15:54 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772238049 The Salton Sea also comes to mind as something that has evolved into an adjacent issue that EDF is not so focused on but that undermines the commitment to longevity and authenticity etc. https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772244294
But then I recognize we have to balance the fact we only have so much time in the day.]]> 2021-09-27 19:18:39 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772244294 Defining the problem garcibrion https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772252555 Defining the problem will help define our role as well. ]]> 2021-09-27 19:22:10 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1772252555 Next Steps? - some of my thoughts (MH) https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1774367529 Principles are not necessarily static. We can adjust as we move forward if needed, but these are a great start!
We definitely want to use these principles as a filter/lens on our work. 
Should we do this as an explicit, documented process, or in an unofficial way?
Should we do that individually -- team leads, for instance, taking a deliberate look and documenting our thoughts -- or do we assign a team (EJ committee?) to review the different threads of our work and provide recommendations to the various teams?
I'm don't have the answer -- interested in thoughts.]]> 2021-09-28 12:20:07 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1774367529 U.S. Water Alliance https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1797869234 The U.S. Water Alliance has some interesting resources. They outline 3 pillars:
  • Have access to safe, clean, affordable drinking water and wastewater services;
  • Share in the economic, social, and environmental benefits of water systems; and
  • Are resilient in the face of floods, drought, and other climate risks.

 They also have a clearing house of resources: http://uswateralliance.org/wec/search?field_org_type=nonprofit#search-results
]]> 2021-10-06 21:58:28 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1797869234 Accountability & self-reflection https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1797874282 I wonder if there are specific questions to ask ourselves at different stages of projects (design, implementation, evaluation) that could keep us accountable and help assess if we are making progress in terms of the DEIJ principles outlined (in both process and oucomes)?]]> 2021-10-06 22:01:59 UTC https://padlet.com/garcibrion/uznsegvbkod4rm5h/wish/1797874282