2.Think about who took the cookies and why they would do it.

    - Everyone had their own plausible alibis. But Mina found out who ate the cookies. It was… 

4. Confirm and write the reason for each person in groups.

2. Share your diary and give comments to each other.

3. Edit it with the comments. 

Mina’s sister ate cookies because  (                                                        ).

                                  vs.

Mina’s sister didn’t eat cookies because  ( she had a cavity. She couldn't eat anything.                                                     ).

Mina’s dad didn’t eat cookies because he had enough fish food. He didn't need more cookies for fishing.

Hi

 [Suspect  2. mom ]  

Mina’s mom didn’t eat cookies because  ( she was on a diet ).

Mina’s brother ate cookies because  (            he was hungry
                                           ).

                                 vs.  

Mina’s brother didn’t eat cookies because  (
                                                      ).

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift.

Name :         / Comments:

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift. It was one of my dream to have my own cookie jar in my own drawer of my own room. Being too excited, I forgot to lock the drawer. This morning, when I woke up, I couldn't believe myself!! The jar was missing! 
Of course, it was dad. Everybody knows he has sweet tooth. I went to the bedroom to ask him but he had already left for fishing. Mom said dad could't be a suspect because he had enough fish food. She denied herself being the one either. Yeah, my mom and my sister are never on the list because mom's on a diet and my sister had a cavity(The dentist warned her to eat any sweet!).
At that moment, my little brother walked to me and said he ate the cookies because he was too hungry. What a little cute thief! However, I wasn't very angry because he gave me a hug and told me he would bake cookies for me. 
No, my boy! I would make some for you. I feel sorry that I didn't share the cookies with my brother.

Name :         / Comments:

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift. I tasted just one cookie from the jar, and it was soooooo tasty like heaven! So, I decided to eat only one cookie a day. 
This morning, I was going to have today's cookie but the cookie jas was gone! Somebody stole my cookies! 
I searched all over the house, and I found the empty jar in the kitchen. My mom was washing the jar! 
"Mom, why did you eat my precious cookies!", I shouted.
"What? I didn't eat the cookies! You know I'm on a diet! Look at your mom's muffin-top belly!", mom cried out.
Then my brother said, "I'm sorry. I ate them."
I was so mad at him but I felt sorry for him. I should've shared my cookies with him.




Name:          / Comments:

Yesterday my sister got a cookie jar for her birthday gift.
I didn't eat lunch for a diet so I was very very hungry..
So I ate only one cookie. And I lied. " I did exercise.."
But I didn't want to tell my family because they think I was on a diet. What a shame!!!!

Name :         / Comments:

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift.
I was really happy to get the gift. It was so precious that I put it in my drawer. But the next morning, I lost it. I felt so sad. I asked my family where my cookie jar disappeared or who ate my cookies. And finally I got who did it. My brother ate my cookies because he was starving. And I was angry, but he said "I will make cookies for you. Forgive me." So I'll forgive him.

Name :         / Comments: