3G SS evaluation by Goh Zhi Qing

goh_zhi_qing2_1 — 2025-07-25 04:43:22 UTC

In your pairs, finish at least 2 PEE paragraphs and answer the question
You can start with
Source A agrees/disagrees because Point. Evidence/Explanation
Reminder: Link back to the question and need to provide a point

Daniel

ho_ming_yuan_daniel — 2025-07-28 03:42:33 UTC

Source E agrees because it shows the conditions the migrant workers have to go through.Source C states:”They stay in overcrowded dormitories and are packed likes sardines with 12 persons to a room.”This means that the migrant works do not have a good condition to live in singapore

Daniel

ho_ming_yuan_daniel — 2025-07-28 03:46:11 UTC

Source C disagrees because the government has promised to take care of the migrant workers.Source C states: “We will look after your health,your welfare and your livelihood.We will work with your employers to make sure that you get paid.” This shows how the government is working to help the migrant workers

Yorick and Lebin

2025-07-28 03:47:31 UTC

I agree with Source E that the way Singapore treats its migrant workers will result in having a negative impact on the country. As stated in Source E,” They stay in overcrowded dormitories and are packed like sardines with 12 persons to a room.” This suggest that migrant workers in Singapore are not being treated fairly and are instead being treated differently from singaporean citizens and this might have a negative impact on the country as migrant workers who witness and experience these treatment might not help build Singapore infrastructure in the future, which will affect Singapore development. Therefore I think Source C agrees in the way Singapore treats its migrant workers will have a negative impact on the country.

However, Source C disagrees with the statement that the way Singapore treats its migrant workers will have a negative impact on the country and source C actually states the opposite saying that Singapore cares deeply for migrant workers. As stated in Source C,” we will look after you health, your welfare and your livelihood.” This suggest that the Singapore government actually cares and provides for their migrant workers, therefore source C disagrees with the statement and that the positive way Singapore treats its migrant workers will not have a negative impact on the country.

stephan and ilyf

2025-07-28 03:47:57 UTC

The author in Source B would disagree with the Prime Minister in Source C about the treatment of migrant workers.
In Source B, migrant workers are shown trapped in a pot labelled "Denied medical," "Exploited," with an authority figure ignoring them and saying "Stay there and do not loiter or I will fine you."This suggests that migrant workers are mistreated and neglected, contradicting Source C where the Prime Minister promises to "care for you... look after your health, welfare and livelihood," showing concern for their well-being.

However, the author might agree slightly with Source C’s acknowledgment of migrant workers. Source C thanks migrant workers for "cooperation during this difficult period" and mentions arrangements for Ramadan celebrations.
This shows recognition of migrant workers’ contributions and cultural needs, which may align with the authors intention to highlight their plight, even though the author focuses more on neglect and exploitation.

Daniel

ho_ming_yuan_daniel — 2025-07-28 03:50:00 UTC

Source D agrees because of the living conditions the migrant workers have to endure.Souce D shows “He mentioned that the government crams them like sardines in small dormitories, and condemn the poor sanitary conditions of the dormitories.”This shows the bad conditions the workers have to stay in

thansin and miu

2025-07-28 03:50:07 UTC

Source C disagrees as they are grateful for migrant workers and would take care of them.Source C states that”We will look after your health, your welfare and your livelihood.We will work with your employers to make sure that you get paid, and you can send money home.And we will help you stay in touch with friends and family.”This shows that Singaporeans do care for migrant workers and appreciate them.

rezky & daylan tofu brother

2025-07-28 03:50:08 UTC

I agree with Source C as it suggests that Singapore's treatment of migrant workers does not have a negative impact. It shows that the government acknowledges the contributions of migrant workers and expresses care and responsibility for their well-being. Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong clearly states, “We will care for you, just like we care for Singaporeans,” and assures that their health, welfare, and livelihood will be looked after.

This includes making sure they get paid, stay connected with their families, and have proper arrangements for religious observance.

Qi San and claire

2025-07-28 03:50:56 UTC

Source B agrees because migrants are being treated poorly in Singapore. In source B, it shows two migrants being in a bin asking for help but the Singaporean said "to stay there and do not loiter, or I will fine you". This shows the migrants being discriminated even though they did nothing wrong.

miu and thansin

2025-07-28 03:51:00 UTC

Source E agrees because it shows us the treatments that migrant workers receive from people in Singapore. Source E states "They stay in overcrowded dormitories and are packed likes sardines with 12 persons to a room. The dormitories are not clean or sanitary". This shows us that they are living in poor conditions and do not have a clean place to live in.

Claire and qisan

2025-07-28 03:51:07 UTC

Source C disagree about how the way singapore treats its migrant workers will have a negative impact on the country since singapore acknowledges them." We will look after your health,your welfare and your livelihood. We will work with your employers to make sure you get paid and you can send money home." This tells us that singapore is thankful to the migrant workers and does take care of their wellbeing so that they don't fall sick and they would still be able to contact family members in other countries, singapore is not as ignorant as they make it seem to be

kennice

2025-07-28 03:51:18 UTC

source E agrees because it shows how the singapore government treat foreigners as they don't treat the migrant workers fairly compared to how they treat the singapore locals. "they stay in overcrowded dormitories and are packed like sardines with 12 persons to a room. the dormitories are not clean or sanitary." singapore government should treat everyone equally, not because the migrant workers are foreigners so they get a treatment not as good as the singapore locals and they should have a better living environment.

Kiean and Jae Xun

2025-07-28 03:51:53 UTC

Source F disagrees that the way singapore treats its migrant workers will have a negative impact on the country.Source F says "Over the past five years, I have befriended different workers from various countries and even visited some of them or families in Bangladesh and india." This shows that migrant workers are treated well by singaporeans. This means there is no negative impact on the migrant workers

Source E agrees that the way singaporeans treat its migrant workers will have a negative impact.Source E says "The way Singapore treatd its migrant workers is not First World but Third World." This shows that singapreans treat the migrant workers bad.

Jayden and Lu Heng

2025-07-28 03:52:00 UTC

I disagree with the statement because source D says that “but we also see that the government is continuously improving the newly build dormitories They have new bed frames mattresses and cabinets, and the beds are arranged according to the room frames, mattresses and cabinets, and the beds are arranged according to the room size, which meets the standards set by the authorities.” this shows that the Singapore’s Government is treating the migrants workers well by meeting their meets such as reducing overcrowding in their dormitories and new bed frames for them.

However I also agree with the statement because the majority of the migrant workers have habits that is unhygienic. Source D says that, “ Their living habits will accompany them, such as eating with their hands, eating under the trees and on the grass, gathering together to drink and chat “ this shows that most of the migrant workers brought their living habits over from their countries