10HUMS Civil Rights - Warburton Ranges Controversy - Document Analysis by Mr. Heron https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98 Each table group answers select questions for 5 different sources, following the lead of a modelled example. UTILISE THIS AS A STUDY RESOURCE TO LOOK BACK ON. en-us 2024-05-10 09:56:24 UTC 2024-06-09 10:46:58 UTC hello@padlet.com Example (Teacher Modelling) jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979477 2024-05-10 09:56:43 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979477 Article Name jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979546 W.A. Parliament’s shocking report on Aborigines

]]> 2024-05-10 09:56:49 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979546 Publication Date jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979600 Wed, Jan 9, 1957

]]> 2024-05-10 09:56:55 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979600 What is the author’s perspective on the Warburton Ranges Controversy? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979639 The Tribune newspaper seems to hold the view of the controversy being very "damning" for the W.A. government (source 1). Sharing the viewpoint with the Select Committee that the controversy was a violation to Aboriginal Australians.

]]> 2024-05-10 09:56:59 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979639 What evidence do they use to justify their perspective? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979666 The Tribune newspaper evidence is all derived from the Select Committee's investigative report on the Warburton Ranges.

]]> 2024-05-10 09:57:02 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979666 Key Statistics and Dates jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979711

  • Report presented Dec 12th, 1956

  • Cases of 9 and 11 year old weighing 11 stone (21 lbs.)

  • Water holes 20 miles away

    • ]]>     2024-05-10 09:57:07 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979711     One sentence that summarises the article. Use a quote. jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979960 This article explores the details found within the Western Australian parliament's select committee report about the "conditions of ... starvation, ... bitter cold , ... disease and ailments" (source 1)experienced by Aboriginal Australians whilst on the Warburton ranges mission.

    ]]>     2024-05-10 09:57:30 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979960     Differences from your source and source 1 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979983


    • ]]>     2024-05-10 09:57:33 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987979983     Source 1 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987983865 2024-05-10 10:03:12 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987983865 Article Name jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984027 2024-05-10 10:03:32 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984027 Publication Date jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984127 2024-05-10 10:03:44 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984127 Key statistics and dates jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984245 2024-05-10 10:03:59 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984245 What is the author's perspective on the Warburton Ranges Controversy? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984548 2024-05-10 10:04:23 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984548 What evidence do they use to justify their perspective? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984669 2024-05-10 10:04:37 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984669 One sentence that summarises the article. Use a quote. (Andre) jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984705 To summarise, the article states that Aboriginals according to the Western Australia's Parliament Report mostly "lack even the most basic necessities of life" and also suffer from disease. (Source "Tribune", Wednesday, 9 January 1957, P.3)

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:04:41 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984705     Differences from (your) source 1 and source 2 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984738 2024-05-10 10:04:44 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984738 Source 2 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984779 2024-05-10 10:04:50 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984779 Article name jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984821 2024-05-10 10:04:55 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984821 Publication date jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984851 2024-05-10 10:04:59 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984851 Key statistics and dates jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984888 2024-05-10 10:05:03 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984888 What is the author's perspective on the Warburton Ranges Controversy? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984924 2024-05-10 10:05:06 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984924 What evidence do they use to justify their perspective? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984968 2024-05-10 10:05:09 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987984968 One sentence that summarises the article. Use a quote. jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985013 2024-05-10 10:05:13 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985013 Differences from (your) source 2 and source 3 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985094 2024-05-10 10:05:20 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985094 Source 3 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985201 Practical Aid for Aboriginals

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:05:31 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985201     Article name jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985279 The Age

    Practical Aid for Aborigines

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:05:39 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985279     Publication date jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985352 30th January 1957

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:05:45 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985352     Key statistics and dates jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985389 Published: 30 January 1957

    Author: Anna Vroland

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:05:50 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985389     What is the author's perspective on the Warburton Ranges Controversy? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985450 The author believes the problem is a humanitarian one and the Federal Government has a grave of responsibility.

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:05:57 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985450     What evidence do they use to justify their perspective? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985652 The evidence being used was the view from the publicity about the western austrlian aboriginies. The author also brings in what the government has done already in the past as evidence.

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:04 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985652     One sentence that summarises the article. Use a quote. jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985693 "If the federal Government will not help at once, we, the people must take the matter into our own hands"

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:09 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985693     Differences from (your) source 3 and source 4 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985759 Our source talks about the Practical Aid for Aboriginals whilst source 4 is a public opinion on Aborigines

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:17 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985759     Source 4 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985965 2024-05-10 10:06:24 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987985965 Article name jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986139 Public opinion on Aborigines

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:27 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986139     Date of Publication jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986157 3rd February 1957

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:30 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986157     Key statistics and dates jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986190 Publication Date - 3 February 1957

    Annual General Meeting (AGM) - occurs annually depending on differing requirements (end of company's fiscal year, annual schedule)

    Engineering offices for aborigines - Victorian Aborigines Advancement League (VAAL)

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:33 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986190     What is the author's perspective on the Warburton Ranges Controversy? - Dean jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986219 The author, G. Walker, is apart of the association that was protesting the contreversy. He seems to be against the actions of the federal government "It was the unanimous opinion of the meeting that the Federal government was out of step with general public opinion on this matter."

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:36 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986219     What evidence do they use to justify their perspective? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986302 no evidence was used

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:39 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986302     One sentence that summarises the article. Use a quote. jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986344 Federal goverment was out of step with general public opinin on this matter -e

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:41 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986344     Differences from (your) source 4 and source 5 -Dean jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986364 The perspective of the two sources is completely opposite to each other. Source 4 is against the actions of the government, commenting about the group's outrage at the government's neglect over the lives of the Aboriginal people of the Warburton Ranges. However, source 5 seeks to disprove the allegations of "sick and starving natives". The author addresses the many contreversies with minimal evidence however other than "I was there and they were fine."

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:06:43 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986364     Source 5 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986495 2024-05-10 10:06:59 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986495 Article name jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986557 Sick , starving natives

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:07:06 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986557     Publication date jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986593 1st Febuary 1957

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:07:10 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986593     Key statistics and dates jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986618 Some of the key statistics are

    • there were traditions where babies were getting killed but it only happened when the baby was badly sick and it was considered "mercy"

    • people were sick but it was not as bad as stated in the report

    • 4.250,000 acres of land HAD been taken from native Australians by the feds

    • 150 people had "trekked" 800 miles

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:07:12 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986618     What is the author's perspective on the Warburton Ranges Controversy? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986642 The aurthors thinks the sick, starving natives is in the Warburton Ranges Controversy has been eggagerated. The author seems to be in denial as proven in the following statement: "no aboriginies in the Central Australian reserves are dying of thirst or starvation - or disease"

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:07:16 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986642     What evidence do they use to justify their perspective? jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986684 Evidence includes:

    • "white men made missionaries" allegedly meant no-one was allowed to starve.

    • The people who went to check on the Indigenous stated that "None of them can stand the light of full examination." Therefore, they were said to be fine and weren't struggling at all.

    • People shouldn't worry about the Indigenous because they were oblivious about the nations concern for their "misery".

    • They state that the natives wouldn't allow modern doctors to help, as they only cared about their traditional ways


    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:07:20 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986684     One sentence that summarises the article. Use a quote. jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986727 "No aborigines in the Central Australian reserves are dying of thrist or starvation - or disease."

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:07:23 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986727     Differences from (your) source 5 and source 1 jackheron2001 https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986764 Source 1 includes a statement of speculation about the starving aboriginies in the Warburton ranges , and includes them trying to find out if it is true or not , stating " if these reports are true , then every australian should be ashamed"


    Source one was also shared on 21st of january 1957 while source 5 was 1st of feb 1957 , instead of not knowing it is a informative piece , saying they were making excuses because they did not accept the help.


    Source 2 is informing us about how rhe aborigines are doing

    ]]>     2024-05-10 10:07:26 UTC https://padlet.com/jackheron2001/uaintyknndvnxn98/wish/2987986764