https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh In what way might John and his wife both be right? en-us 2018-12-06 12:35:05 UTC 2018-12-06 16:42:17 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/icons/Bigthunderstorm.png https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311886829 There is definitely something wrong with the narrator, she may not be depressed, rather insane, but something is wrong with her. The narrator and John both are right about her resting, she shouldn't be doing anything vigorous, but she cant just sit around she has to have some type of stimulus to keep her from going crazy, which she does do. John was right about her needing to see someone else for a diagnosis because his diagnosis was not correct. He was also right about her needing to forget about the wallpaper but he does not handle any of these things in the right way. John does not give his wife any input and is very controlling when he need to give some leverage and listen to her side as well. Both were right and both were wrong its just a matter of what specific point you look at. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:20:31 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311886829 21msipe https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311886882 Both John and his wife could both be right for many different reasons. John may be right because there may be nothing physically wrong with her. She may only be ¨depressed¨ while she is away. His wife may be right because she knows what she is feeling on the inside. She knows about her true emotions and how she is really feeling. As she describes in the short story, she obviously has some kind of weird feelings that John doesn´t really know about.]]> 2018-12-06 16:20:37 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311886882 21kbradish https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887032 John and his wife could both be right in different ways. John may be right because he feels that the there is something wrong with the narrator. Because of his job, he could be qualified to say that there is something wrong. He thinks she is depressed, which may not be the case. However, there is something of some sort wrong with her. His wife, the narrator, could be right because she knows internally what is going on with herself. Only she knows her true feelings and emotions better than anyone else. Her husband is very controlling and will not let her do the things she likes to do, which does the opposite of what he is trying to do. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:20:52 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887032 https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887056 Both John and his wife make good cases as to why they are both right. John believes that she has hysteria, which can be true from some of her signs. John is also a physician so he also knows what he is talking about. You can see that there is something wrong with the narrator, but we dont know for sure what is wrong. His wife knows what she feels and understands her emotions more than someone who is not her that just sees what is happening to her.They are both right in the fact that she should not be doing any activites that can strain her mind to much, such as writing. John is also right about his wife needing to forget the wallpaper but he does not help her in any way to forget the source of her depression and troubles. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:20:54 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887056 https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887064 John might be right because John has never really noticed her being sick. He understands that something weird is going on but not necessarly thinking she is mentallly ill. John is a physician so he knows what he is talking about leading him to think that it is hysteria. But the narrator definitley has something going on that isn't right. His wife could be right in the fact that she mentallly is struggling to cope with things. This makes her believe she is ill because she understands her feelings and emotions more than anyone else.]]> 2018-12-06 16:20:55 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887064 21aansell https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887100 J]]> 2018-12-06 16:20:59 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887100 21ejackson https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887186 John and his wife may both be right.  John  may be right because he knows that his wife has a mental  illness and there is clearly something wrong with her. She should not do anything too strenuous with her mind when battling an illness.  His wife might be right as well.  Although she shouldn't be doing much, being trapped in a nearly empty room doing absolutely nothing is not going to help. I think his wife is right and should continue to write, but should not be doing anything much more than that. They are both right in their own way. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:21:07 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887186 https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887193 Both John and his wife both have their own opinions, however they may both be right. It is clear that the narrator has something is wrong, it seems to be something mentally wrong but nonetheless there is a problem.  According to John the only way to heal is to rest and not doing any strenuous work, and if she is depressed, maybe a break is just what she needs, to get away from her propblems.  On the other hand, the narrator can not just sit there her whole life waiting to get better, she needs something to do to keep her from losing it and start seeing things. The narrator is the only person who knows how she is feeling, and only she knows what she has to do to feel back to herself.]]> 2018-12-06 16:21:08 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887193 https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887231 John and his wife could both be right. They both believe something is something wrong with the narrator. John thinks it is something to not really worry about because he is basing his analysis off of her physical state. He thinks that her mental state may be weak but it's not serious. While the she is sure that there is something seriously wrong with her mental health. So on a physical stand point John is right but on a mental standpoint she is right.]]> 2018-12-06 16:21:10 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887231 https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887356  They might both be right because  she could have something wrong , but Johns cure might also not be the right cure for it. She knows that there is something wrong her. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:21:20 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887356 21dbierer https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887370 2018-12-06 16:21:21 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887370 21rdiroma https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887420 2018-12-06 16:21:26 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887420 21clayman https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887467 2018-12-06 16:21:32 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887467 21cmulnix https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887590 John and his wife might both be right in a certain sense. John could be correct in the way of the treatment given to his wife. It seems clear that he knows something is wrong, but without any of the knowledge of whats going on, he is unable to give an actual treatment other than the rest cure. John's wife may be depressed, but as the reader we know she is mentally unstable. The narrator could be correct in her own way. She didn't like the house, which tells us something is going with it anyway, and she doesn't like the wallpaper. She doesn't think that this treatment is needed, and she thinks she should be doing something other than sitting inside all of the time (going insane).]]> 2018-12-06 16:21:41 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887590 21tstokes https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887653 John and his wife might both be right in the way that there is something unusual going on. For example, the wife feels something unusual going on with the house. This unusual problem with the house makes her very cautious and concerned of the nursery room. John may be right in the way that something unusual is going on because his wife's mental health seems to be altered than it once was. John feels this unusual change within his wife. He is so concerned by it that he recommends her to only sleep around the house, and not engage in any activities that may challenge her mind. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:21:47 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887653 https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887887 John and his wife both have their own reasons for being right. John believes that his wife is not actually sick but that she is just temporarily depressed. He is a physician which adds to him thinking that he understands what she is going through. The wife on the other hand is the person who is going through the "temporary depression," which gives her a better understanding of what is happening. She is the only one who can truly understand what she is feeling.]]> 2018-12-06 16:22:07 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887887 21aansell https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887919 Both John and his wife may be right for different reasons. They both believe there is something wrong. John believes that her mental health is not very good; severe. John tells her that she can not do any activity that can cause her health to become worse. He sees the physical problems. His wife may be right because she knows what is going on because it is her body and mind. She is feeling depressed and only she knows why. John doesn't fully understand why. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:22:09 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311887919 21snicolette https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311888555 Both John and his wife have their own ways of being right in the story. John believes that his wife has something wrong with her, and is definitely right about that. John just does not understand his wife's condition, however he could be right about her needing to rest and relax. However, his wife is also right in her point of view about how her husband is handling the situation. Although her condition may not be extremely concerning, John should still be taking her seriously as his wife, and showing more thought about what she thinks of her condition. Alongside this, John should also be taking her opinions into consideration about what is best for her and her own treatment options as well.]]> 2018-12-06 16:23:00 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311888555 21ehamilton2 https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311888994 2018-12-06 16:23:37 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311888994 21nregish https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311890064 John and his wife may be right because They both feel that she is sick and that she needs to be helped. John is a doctor, so he is using his skills. He is trying to help her all that he can. She may be right because John seemed to see something in the wallpaper too, as did Jennie. ]]> 2018-12-06 16:25:07 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311890064 21mporterfield https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311890085 2018-12-06 16:25:09 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311890085 21rdally https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311890904 John does not think his wife has a concerning illness. He is somewhat right. Her condition is not shown and is not much of a sickness where physical symptoms are shown. She has more of a mental sickness. It is hard for a mental sickness to be helped with. And the condition that can not be too shown is not that concerning to other people. John should take her serious  since she is describing her condition.]]> 2018-12-06 16:26:16 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311890904 21dbierer https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311893335 John and his wife may both be right for a few reasons.  John is  a physician and has experience so his opinion definitely has some value. He is defintely right that theres is at least something wrong with her. However, his wife may be right in the fact that all these things that she wants to do that John won't let her do may actually make her feel better if she is truly depressed.  She may also be right because she knows herself better than anyone else.]]> 2018-12-06 16:29:38 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311893335 21creilly https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311898094 john and his wife could both be right in this situation. johns opinion is definitely pretty valid. John has said that there is something wrong with her and he is definitely right. However, there would be better ways to handle her depression. she aslo ]]> 2018-12-06 16:36:16 UTC https://padlet.com/ksanzone/u1673rjrg6nh/wish/311898094