2.Think about who took the cookies and why they would do it.

    - Everyone had their own plausible alibis. But Mina found out who ate the cookies. It was… 

4. Confirm and write the reason for each person in groups.

2. Share your diary and give comments to each other.

3. Edit it with the comments. 

Mina’s sister ate cookies because  (  Usually kids like sweets and unlike her brother who wants to loose weight, she did just play game. She might need snacks while playing ).

                                  vs.

Mina’s sister didn’t eat cookies because she didn't want to gain another bad teeth.

Mina’s dad ate cookies because (                                               ).
                                  vs.

Mina’s dad didn’t eat cookies because (                                                        ).

 [Suspect  2. mom ]  

Mina’s mom ate cookies because  (                                                                  ).

                                  vs.

Mina’s mom didn’t eat cookies because  (  she had tooth problem and she must not eat sweets  ).

Mina’s brother ate cookies because he is on a diet. Have you ever be on a diet? Then, you know that it's really hard not to eat something.

                                 vs.  

Mina’s brother didn’t eat cookies because he is on a diet.

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift.
And today, now I see that someone took my cookies.
Who got the cookies? Hmm...
I think my sister took my cookies.
Because, the others have no reason to take that cookies.
My mother got an appointment to dentist and she must not want to get another trouble.

Name :         / Comments:

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift.
When I opened the cookie jar, the cookies are gone.
I suspected all of my family members.
My sister is baby, so she might wanted to eat them.
My dad might need something to eat when he went to fish.
My mom already has bad teeth. It means she likes cookies.
My brother was on a diet. You know that it's really hard not to eat when you are on a diet.
Honestly I suspected my brother the most at first. Come on, he's on a diet and I did have his candy once without noticing him.
But, Tadah, I was wrong. The thief was my sister!!!
After all my thoughts

Name :         / Comments:

Yesterday I got a cookie jar for my birthday gift. I wanted to eat the cookies today as a snack, but I found that the cookies are eaten by somebody.
I was sad, so I decided to find out who it did.

First, I asked to my dad, but he said "I don't like cookies that much. And I was fishing today, so I didn't even recognize your cookies."

Next, I asked to my mom, but she said "You know, I have a toothache. A dentist said me not to eat any sugars."

Because both of my parents are not the criminal, I about to ask to my brother. But I fount out that he was on a diet, so he doesn't want to eat any snacks.

So, the left one is only sister. I asked to her, and she said the truth while crying.

Name :         / Comments:

I think the culprit is her sister. Because she was playing video game and she was in the house. And she is so young, usually kids love cookies.
But her mom went to the dentist to take care for her teeth.

Name :         / Comments: