Ancient India: the Untouchables by Ms. Beecher

Read article, discuss and respond to q's

amy_beecher — 2022-01-24 01:41:28 UTC

amy_beecher — 2022-01-24 01:57:52 UTC

Elijah

2022-01-26 20:21:05 UTC

I say yes not a strong yes. This is because if there was no system at all for anybody then there would be no order. Use America for an example, America is a very free country but there is a lot more violence compared to places like Canada. Like there is a lot more school shootings in America because a lot more people that are untrained have firearms. Also there has to be a lowest class because if there wasn't then there would be only a middle class and that would not be good because then everyone would have equal rights except the higher class so there would be a big abuse of power.

NO - Justin

2023-01-27 20:19:52 UTC

VERY UNFAIR you cant even go up a caste its based on birth

Mira, Amelia, and Lila

2023-01-27 20:20:52 UTC

they are similar to Mesopotamia and Egypt because they both sort them into pyramid's and they had a category where the people were treated like dirt. They also had priests at the top of the pyramid. All of the people are also really similar.

Mira,Lila,Amelia

2023-01-27 20:23:30 UTC

I don't think it's fair because they cant move up or do anything about it. It was also unfair because they had no choice. What did they do to deserve this?

-NevaeH- (:AudReY:)

2023-01-27 20:24:20 UTC

we do not think it is fair to have a social class like the untouchables because you should not be born into a category. you should be able to have freedom. at least give them like a chance or something to be able to have a better life. <3

India's caste system jackson/langston

2023-01-27 20:24:23 UTC

1. I think its similar in a way that there both based off a pyramid but mostly because in the higher ranks there is less people and most of the people are lower in the rank being poor or being a peasant.

2. No because your basically saying that its ok to force people to be poor and that you should treat them bad and they cant change that.

3. I think if I was one of them I would feel angry that i cant change what I work as and that i'm looked down on and that I have to work with disgusting stuff and that there's noting I can do about it.

4. Some of the rights that they were not granted are not being able to go up in rank and not being able to go to nice places not being able to warship at temple and last not being treated normal or being treated that your something unhumanly

Anabelle and Surionah

2023-01-27 20:24:55 UTC

They are all similar because they are all sorted into a caste system and they are all treated differently depending on their social class.

Kaiden and Davis

2023-01-27 20:25:01 UTC

1. They are similar because there are high classes and low classes like pharaohs and peasants.
2. I would say yes but not a big yes because in life you need order so their has to be some type of caste system.
3. they probably feel sad because they are not treated well and they are singled out.
4. Many untouchables could not have proper homes, or good meals. They probably did not have good medical assistance or technology.

Matty Amari

2023-01-27 20:25:13 UTC

I think they might not know how to feel because they are used to it and don't know how to change it. They wouldn't know how to feel because they were born into the class and don't know what its like to be outside of that class.

kenleigh and zeke

2023-01-27 20:26:32 UTC

We don't think its fair because you cant level up. We understand that you need to have rulers but in the lower classes the work should be split more evenly because there is a lot of lower classes, also a lot of work to be done. Some children will never understand what its like to have even some sort of a good life just because what class they were born into.

Lila,Mira,Amelia

2023-01-27 20:26:48 UTC

The untouchables would feel upset because they didn't do anything wrong they were just born like that.

justin

2023-01-27 20:27:38 UTC

the only difference between the Egypt social system and caste system is the caste system was more strict

Presley and Ava

2023-01-27 20:28:12 UTC

India's Caste System is similar to Egypt and Mesopotamia because they all have a system that shows peoples ranks and value and by their social- class. They are all different because they have different names and different values to their systems. They are also different because there ranks mean more or less then others ranks do.

Suri and Anabelle

2023-01-27 20:28:55 UTC

No because its unfair to the human society. to place them into groups depending on and wealth and smarts. Also they have no choice.

Amelia,Mira,Lila

2023-01-27 20:29:09 UTC

The untouchables were not allowed to be touched. They couldn't go to temples. They had to sit on the floor. Not allowed to drink from certain wells.

Elliott, Caroline, Karsyn

2023-01-27 20:30:43 UTC

the untouchables in India if you were born an untouchable you will be a untouchable forever there isn't anyway to change it unlike in Egypt you are able to possibly go higher in the caste. I do not think it is fair to have a social class like the untouchables because you are treated in humanly and its not fair because you cant change you social class. I think that they probably felt very left out especially knowing that there wasn't anyway they could move up in the caste system and that there children or other family members would have to go through that as well having to be treated like they weren't worth anything. they weren't paid as much as others. they cant get better jobs.

Gannon and Mark

2023-01-27 20:31:47 UTC

they are similar because they both have high class with priests and lower classes as peasants and workers and slaves.
2. I think its not fair to be born into it but if you do something bad then it is maybe ok. Its fair if your a good untouchable to be moved up in the caste but its not fair to be born into it with no choice and not be able to be moved up in the caste system.
3. I think they feel depressed and are not happy and are maybe mad there stuck in such a poor and bad life also maybe traumatized because they have to clean dead bodies and facies
4. They weren't allowed to touch priests go into temples and cant go to some schools and other bad stuff they cant use like town wells and stuff that higher ranked use a lot

justin

2023-01-27 20:31:49 UTC

i think the untouchables would feel almost like slaves,they are so low that theyre outside the system

aUdREy <3 -NevaeH-

2023-01-27 20:32:23 UTC

India's caste system is similar to different social structures because they all have a ranking of importance and the sections are very similar

they are different because they have different names and make different profits

Anabelle and Suri

2023-01-27 20:33:14 UTC

They would feel left out and upset that they could not change their social class. And they would more than likely be stuck in that social class for the rest of their lives.

justin

2023-01-27 20:34:15 UTC

the untouchables were denied to drink from a well ,and worship at temples

-NevaeH- (:aUdrEy:)

2023-01-27 20:34:26 UTC

we think the untouchables feel sad and depressed. they might feel frustrated because they know the deserve a chance to be in one of the higher classes

kenleigh and zeke

2023-01-27 20:34:35 UTC

They are similar because the bottom has the the most people and the worst work. The top has the least people and the easiest work. They are different because you can level up.

matty amari again

2023-01-27 20:34:46 UTC

They are similar because the bottom class is treated really bad :( and the higher class are priest. They cant change classes.

AudReY -NevaeH-

2023-01-27 20:35:49 UTC

some of the rights that the untouchable's were denied was to have better foods houses and jobs and rights

Eli, Cole, Grady

2023-01-27 20:39:04 UTC

1. The social class ladder is similar because
it has the top witch is the most respected and the bottom witch has the least clean jobs. It is also structured the same with the pyramid style. But it is also different because not all the castes are the same.
2. I think it is fair but not fair. This is because well we need people to do those jobs. But at the same time is is completely unfair because if you are born a untouchable you can never change even if you love the thin you cant do.
3. I think the untouchables would fell disrespected but honored at the same time. This is because they have the most important job because everyone depends on them. And they would be disrespected because they are "untouchable"
4. The "Untouchables" where not allowed to go in temples, and they where said to be dirty physically and spiritually.

Ancient India: the Untouchables by Ms. Beecher

Read article, discuss and respond to q's

Elijah

NO - Justin

Mira, Amelia, and Lila

Mira,Lila,Amelia

-NevaeH- (:AudReY:)

India's caste system jackson/langston

Anabelle and Surionah

Kaiden and Davis

Matty Amari

kenleigh and zeke

Lila,Mira,Amelia

justin

Presley and Ava

Suri and Anabelle

Amelia,Mira,Lila

Elliott, Caroline, Karsyn

Gannon and Mark

justin

aUdREy <3 -NevaeH-

Anabelle and Suri

justin

-NevaeH- (:aUdrEy:)

kenleigh and zeke

matty amari again

*AudReY* -NevaeH-

Eli, Cole, Grady

AudReY -NevaeH-