Four pitfalls of labeling LTEL-considered students by DIANA PURWANINGRUM https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc Share your lived experiences (either as a learner/teacher/educator) related to pitfalls of labeling LTEL-considered students. Discuss the implications of labeling. One student will become a reporter for each group to share the discussion. en-us 2025-02-12 00:18:40 UTC 2025-02-19 15:16:02 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.net/icons/png/1f4ac.png dianapurwaningrum1 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324992895 Pitfall 1: English language orientation

"the ways in which identification, services, assessment, reclassification, and the EL label itself are all oriented toward the English language" (p. 129)

]]> 2025-02-12 00:48:15 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324992895 dianapurwaningrum1 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324993903 Pitfall 2: Homogeneous and inappropriate services

"a tendency for EL-classified student-centered services to take a one-size-fits-all approach, an approach that often fails to meet the educational interests and needs of many EL-classified students, and LTEL-considered students in particular." (p.132)

]]> 2025-02-12 00:49:04 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324993903 dianapurwaningrum1 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324995645 Pitfall 3: Labeled and stigmatized

"the stigmatization and disempowerment that students experience as a result of their EL and/or LTEL designations" (p. 135)

]]> 2025-02-12 00:50:27 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324995645 dianapurwaningrum1 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324996122 Pitfall 4: Unequal opportunity to learn

"the limited opportunities to learn they may encounter as a result of the EL and/or LTEL label" (p.136)

]]> 2025-02-12 00:50:56 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3324996122 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334456680 Administrators worried about socializing students into English for college, instructed to teach English-only in International Baccalaureate (IB) high school in China and assessed by scores on TOEFL


]]> 2025-02-19 15:03:42 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334456680 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334459050 TOEFL scores used to exclude students from courses (Chinese IB school), non-American students from American universities, naturalized students in American universities

]]> 2025-02-19 15:05:30 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334459050 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334459726 1st pitfall, labeling students and ignoring qualitative inputs about the students assets and needs.

]]> 2025-02-19 15:06:02 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334459726 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334461140 Designated "ESOL" students excluded from IB "honors" program in U.S.

]]> 2025-02-19 15:07:02 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334461140 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334465773 The services and assessment continue to fail students over the years. In elementary, they continue to get pull out services, additional supports can be personalized but by being pulled out, students almost had to do double the work cuz they lose content by being out.

]]> 2025-02-19 15:09:37 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334465773 https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334470964 Nonsense words to decode reading patterns positions students as unable to read because they feel they do not know the meaning of the words. (which no one does because they are nonsense)

]]> 2025-02-19 15:13:16 UTC https://padlet.com/dianapurwaningrum1/tlgaetf07xk1g6jc/wish/3334470964