Should Orca Shows Be Banned? by Adrienne Heilich https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux Answer the questions from the email link on your Padlet. What is the claim of the article? If more than one, write about both! What reasons do they provide in the article? If there are reasons for both sides, explain the reasons for both sides. Do they provide any evidence for one side, other side, both, neither? Explain. Based on the article, what do you think? Should Orca shows be banned? Explain, your thinking! en-us 2018-02-06 17:41:27 UTC 2025-11-02 21:01:06 UTC hello@padlet.com Aiden,Baron,Clay I https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228828396 1. The claim states that orcas should be banned in captivity.
2.That people have died and it makes the whales deppressed.
3.They provide evidence for one part its the part where it states orca shows should be banned.
4.We all think Orcas should be held in captivity to reduce chances of them going extinct!

]]> 2018-02-06 19:51:41 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228828396 Kate 7, Abby 18 https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228829647 1.Having  Orcas is dangerous and trainers can get killed. On the other side they claim they have gotten better after continuous kills and they spent $70 million dollars on that to make sure .
2. The reason why the shows should stop is because it could stop customers from coming because they are thinking they a likely to get killed. The reason on the other side is strong because they said it doesn't matter about the kills it matters about the experience you had.
3. Both because they both say why they think so, for example on one side says it should stop because it is dangerous for their company and lives. For the other side they say its fine because having them do tricks is live changing and they think every person should see that.
4. Kate - I think no because trainers could get killed for other peoples experience which isn't right, especially for the trainer.
Abby- Yes, because trainers could die and no, because it is cool to watch the shows and people can make memories.]]> 2018-02-06 19:54:04 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228829647 clayton 21 , caleb 24 25claytonsmith https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228829883

1.caleb-clayton-orcas should not be in captivity because of death and small crampt spases.

2.clayton-caleb-the pepole think that thay skol not be contaned   

thay thenk that thay shold keap the orkase becase thay make them money

3.clayton-caleb-orcas should not be in captivity because oecas half to live in a small space when they are suppost to have big and wide spaces instaed of little small ones.

4.clayton-caleb-yes becase thay hurte the orkase and the peaple]]> 2018-02-06 19:54:32 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228829883 Kiarra, and Amelia https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830167 1. they should cancel all orca shows because they need to live in the sea where its way more open.
2. they kill people and they need to live in the sea and also its not humaine.
3. they provide evidece for the no show.
4i think that they should not do the orca shows anymore -kiarra
I think they should not have orca shows anymore because it is forcing them (the orca's) to do what they don't always want to do- Amelia]]> 2018-02-06 19:55:04 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830167 landon daniella https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830257 this artical claims that oracs should stop being in in shows because all those human deaths that accured because of captivity.
2. since the whalez are in captivy they get angry and start making accidents from being angry.
3. evidence for the  this side is that the acrtical states  animals in captivity get sad when they are captive and when they are out in the wild they are free and happy. animals in captivity useally die quicker.
4. Me and landon agree on orcas should be banned because all those deaths accured by the whales are not teated right right ]]> 2018-02-06 19:55:14 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830257 Dillon and Sammy 25samamnthabesore https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830314 1. The claim of this article is that they don't want killer whales to be imprisoned in small tanks. They say that they get depressed  and angry. That's why they keep on killing people.
2. Why they don't want killer whales to be in shows because deaths have occurred during the shows.
 this shows the reason why they want no killer whales in the show.
we think there is one reason to interrest people and for them to make more money!
3. We both agree that the right thing to do is to not imprison wild killer whales in tiny tanks because they get depressed and mad so that is why they kill people.4. we both think that orca's should not be imprisoned in tanks. And that they should be free in the wild and go into their pods]]> 2018-02-06 19:55:21 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830314 Olivia and Abby D 25abigaildeeter https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830850 1. the article claims 2 things orcas should not be kept in captivity. on the other hand sea world claims that it is good because they are studying them and bringing marine life awareness to the public. 
2. naiomi rose says that orcas usally swim up to 100 miles a day in big pods but in their cramped tanks with oly 1 other orca they get frustraded lonly and depressed.
and sea world claims that it is teaching kids and adults about marine awarness they also claim that they can watch the marine animals closer and study them and understand more.  
3 the article claims they are homsick and want to comunicate with more orcas so yes they give evidence seaworld claims it helps them study and give the public info about marine care they do to. 
4 they should not be in captivity because they are sad and want to go back to the ocean so we agree with the article]]> 2018-02-06 19:56:08 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228830850 Gavin 19 Eli 6 https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228832087 1.That there is a mandatory problem with orca.   

2.The orca are very dangerous because they get aggressive at zoos because they are surrounded by other orca they are really scared and bored and depressed


3.Yes they do provide different reasons in different paragraphs

4. but only for kids because it could easily scare them the opinion we have is it should be banned for kids.

]]> 2018-02-06 19:58:42 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228832087 Natalie #22 & Delaney #11 25nataliewilliams https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228832980 Answer #1: The claim of the article is that the orcas  should live in a more open area (The Sea) , and they if they should ban the orca shows.
Answer #2: I think they should not have orca shows is because they get lonely and depressed which makes them go mad,  they only live with stranger orcas that are not in their family, and very little space. Also they have been doing orca shows for a long time ( Since the 1960's) , and it's time for an end to it.
Answer #3: They have evidence for both sides because if you think that they SHOULD NOT get rid of orca shows, the reasons are that they it gets them money to study, and learn more about them. If you think that they SHOULD get rid of orca shows, these are the reasons why. They keep them in small tanks with orcas from different pods which makes them  sad, then the people are likely to get killed because the orcas are bored. 
Answer#4: Yes, we think they should be banned because it is not fair that they barely have any space, and we know that they raise money to do research and study them, but why can't they just do that from the sea
]]> 2018-02-06 20:00:33 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228832980 Evan, Caedmon https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228833356 1.the orcas should or should not be in captivity
2. they get depressed and turn aggressive
 3. only the "save the wales  and set them free" side 
4.we both think we should save the orcas]]> 2018-02-06 20:01:09 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228833356 Grace, Mackenzie https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228835349 1. they should have more shows  because it is a rare species that will probably not exist for not much longer 
2. they should not have more shows because it is very dangerous to the people who come to the shows, they can even get killed! they should because some people are in love with how interesting the creatures of the sea are and they want to learn more
3. Yes they do because they should they said they have spent so much money on them and they have been there sense the 1960s. they should becausee someone has died from it and it can be very dangerous
4. Mackenzie; i think they should not be banned because the trainer was way to close and it his fault he died
Grace; i think the same thing as Mackenzie because the trainer just needed to be careful.]]> 2018-02-06 20:04:52 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/228835349 hi brian5627 https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1028973605 hi]]> 2020-12-17 18:45:36 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1028973605 https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1132652128 I think is good 

]]> 2021-01-27 17:00:03 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1132652128 https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1132659497 2021-01-27 17:01:19 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1132659497 Unknown https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1227242684 I agree that orca shows should be banned because o]]> 2021-02-22 16:12:25 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1227242684 sweerasekara https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1231665482 Orca shows should be banned because if they keep killing people like this then eventually places like Orlando will lose business and then ]]> 2021-02-23 14:40:33 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1231665482 I don’t think so! https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1348768730 I don’t think orca shows should bebanned because without entertainment for the orcas and people its just not fair!  (From 5th grader Janiyah Harris)]]> 2021-03-24 16:09:54 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1348768730 https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1383267100 2021-04-05 14:22:06 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1383267100 https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1460569646 2021-04-26 16:55:09 UTC https://padlet.com/aheilich/tgld7l0g0vux/wish/1460569646