1130320_Chapter 8-10 by 王詠瑜

careness

2024-03-20 06:47:48 UTC

Be able to prioritize the well-being of the whole community.

Indifferent

s21010024 — 2024-03-25 12:36:42 UTC

The giver shouldn’t be emotional, because he has all the good and bad memories, but he can’t let anybody know.(group3)

open-mindedness

2024-03-27 00:38:48 UTC

The Receiver should possess an open mind to consider alternative perspectives.(group6)

Patience

2024-03-27 02:32:38 UTC

Learning and processing various memories over a prolonged period of time requires patience and perseverance. (Group 5)

Insistence

2024-03-27 02:36:10 UTC

Because the process will be painful and last for a long time. (Group 2)

Resilient

2024-03-27 02:36:48 UTC

The job need to receive not only delight memories but also painful memories
(group4)

Group 1

2024-03-27 02:52:01 UTC

Rule 8: The Receiver In Training may lie.

This rule frees the receiver in training from certain aspects of sameness, which is an important part of the receiver's job.

Rule 7: The Receiver in training cannot apply for release.

This rule might have been implemented after the last receiver applied for release.

Group 3

2024-03-27 02:53:25 UTC

We think the rules astonishing us the most is that Jonas is allowed to lie. The education we receive from childhood tells us to tell the truth, so when we are told it’s okey to lie, we feel surprised and guilty.

group 5

2024-03-27 02:54:01 UTC

Rule 7, because usually no one would like to be released. However the receiver may want to be released according to this rule.

Group 1

2024-03-27 02:54:20 UTC

Rule 3, because in our society, even though we have freedom of speech, we are still not completely exempt from rudeness, and we cannot ask whatever we want to other people, such as women's weight!!!!!!!!

Group6

2024-03-27 02:54:37 UTC

8️⃣You may lie
The government hopes that the receiver can keep the secret of the memory, so it allows the receiver to lie.
6️⃣Except for illness or injury unrelated to your training, do not apply for any medication.
The government wants to ensure that the receiver won’t be influenced by the medication so that the receiver can keep their real feelings.

Rule 4 and 8 (group 2)

2024-03-27 02:55:19 UTC

Rule 4: Because the training of The Receiver might be beyond the understanding of the society. The residents don't have the knowledge of the memories that were given to Jonas and might unable to accept them.

Rule 8: Because Jonas is not allowed to tell other people about his training so when other people ask, he can lie to them.

Group4

2024-03-27 02:56:21 UTC

From this moment you are prohibited from dreamtelling.

The fifth rule is to avoid Receiver reveal the things that can’t be know through the similar scenes of dreams.

You may lie.

The eighth rule is to deal with some conditions that others are curious about their secretive job.

Group 2

2024-03-27 02:58:41 UTC

Rule 4. Because sometimes people urge to share their experience and feelings to others. If he can't tell things to parents and elders, he can only process the feelings by himself.

group 3

2024-03-27 02:58:44 UTC

To control the thoughts and behaviors of the people.
Some negative memories about the deed of government.

(group4)

2024-03-27 03:00:02 UTC

1. They don’t want to cause any unexpected thing happen because it may cause chaos in the society.

2.The memories may be the double edged sword .For example color may cause racist so they decide to cancel it.

Group 4

2024-03-27 03:00:25 UTC

The one is the most astonishing is number 5 because I think the "dream" not only mean the memorys which is about his job but also mean the freedom of dreaming himself.

Group 6

2024-03-27 03:01:02 UTC

The possible reasons for taking away the memories of the past include social stability, elimination of painful and traumatic memories, and preservation of community values and unity. These reasons can help the Elder control the community, and also help community members avoid unnecessary pain and emotional distress.

The memories may involve historical events, wars, disasters, and individual identity and emotional experience.

group 5

2024-03-27 03:01:03 UTC

Rule 8:You may lie

To avoid the memories from being leaked to other people

Rule 7: You are not permitted to apply for release.

Because it is hard to find the successor of this job.

Group 3

2024-03-27 03:01:23 UTC

Rule 4: Do not discuss your training with any other member of the community, including parents and elders

Because Jonas’s job will know a lot of secrets.

Rule 6 : Except for illness or injury unrelated to your training, do not apply for any medication.

The giver doesn’t want the medication influence Jonas.

Group 1

2024-03-27 03:01:33 UTC

They will not have critical thinking skills, therefore becoming easier to control.
The memories might be about war~

Group 6

2024-03-27 03:04:04 UTC

I think the rules most that astonishing for me is rule 5, “From this moment you are prohibited from dream-telling. In our society , dreams play a crucial roles in our daily lives. Though most part of dream is not real, it can inspire our creativity and imagination. Thus, if we can’t share our dreams to others, our society will lack of new ideas.

Group 2

2024-03-27 03:08:05 UTC

1. Because some memories are too dangerous, and if they try to imitate them, they may disrupt the harmony of the society. Memories that are too happy or too sad can also cause emotional turmoil.

2. The memories related to the weather may be taken away because the weather is controlled by the community, and the governor wouldn't want the residents to know the other weather except for the good weather.

Group 5

2024-03-27 03:18:35 UTC

The memories might cause damage to the community or society.
The memories might be about the dirty things the government did in the past, maybe involved killing people.

Group 6

chenmax20051007 — 2024-03-27 03:30:29 UTC

In Jonas's world, the government wants to ensure that all residents use accurate wording to ensure that everyone has a correct and consistent understanding of matters.

group 3

2024-03-27 03:31:15 UTC

Because wrong word leads to wrong ideal.

Group 1

2024-03-27 03:32:56 UTC

In Jonas's world, every word is used for a specific meaning. When imprecise words are used, people may believe that other people may have underlying motives.

Group 4

2024-03-27 03:33:52 UTC

In Jona’s world , elder think wrong words lead to wrong actions so they have to make sure everyone use the correct words.

group 5

2024-03-27 03:34:34 UTC

In their society, they think using wrong words means the people have bad ideas, and they may have chances to become bad with their ideas.

Group 2

2024-03-27 03:34:56 UTC

Because imprecise words is untrue and exaggerated, so others may be confused by the wrong words.