Third grade - Munk debate (Katrina) by Shekinah Egan https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv Discussion questions en-us 2020-05-26 07:36:43 UTC 2020-06-05 07:21:08 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.net/icons/png/1f603.png What is Katrina attempting to say? Summarize shekinahregan https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612346050 2020-06-05 05:32:01 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612346050 What are her strongest points? What makes them (points) strong? Please state what paragraph and explain. shekinahregan https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612346465 2020-06-05 05:32:36 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612346465 What are her weakest points? What makes them (points) weak? Please state what paragraph and explain. shekinahregan https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612347004 2020-06-05 05:33:25 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612347004 Weakest Point https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612414344 She didn't eventually suggest the alternative overcoming the current capitalism. Even though she recited Canadian capitalism and Nordic one, it didn't lead to ultimate solution.]]> 2020-06-05 06:54:30 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612414344 Weakest Point https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612415673 Canadians may know the current situation but I could not deeply understand her argument. I think she should have explained more about her argument. 

+ I need more detail about capitalism 3.0
+ More explanation about B Corporation]]> 2020-06-05 06:55:48 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612415673 Weakest Point https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612415884 1. She did not explain the way to overcome the side effects of her way to increase the power of a nation, which regulates people in it.

2. She did not suggest any evidence that the poverty of the world became worse for recent 40 years. There are various evidences that proves that the situation have gotten better from several years.

2-1. She did not suggest evidence in other cases, except for the saying of 'leading business leaders.' But I think it would not be sufficient to fully support her opinions.

3. She described the world she wants as a ideal society, but I think she should've put more details (not just adding the positive aspects of it.]]> 2020-06-05 06:56:01 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612415884 Weakest Point https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612417335 I think her idea that we should make more thousandaires by reducing the number of billionaires is reasonable. However her idea is unrealistic in  that she didn't provide the way to make billionaires share their wealth for more thousandaires ]]> 2020-06-05 06:57:24 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612417335 Summary https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612417469 Current capitalism of US is undermining freedom since the wealth is concentrated to ultra-rich group. While the rich get richer, the poor get poorer, wage is maintained. She thinks redistribution is needed but she doesn't mean to be a socialism country. It is structural redesign that she thinks is necessary to be better capitalism.

]]> 2020-06-05 06:57:32 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612417469 Weakest Point https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612417788 Actually  laissez-faire capitalism support maximized freedom. Current problems are because of excessive freedom(that is given to big enterprises) and she should refer  this more if she wanted to point out current problems]]> 2020-06-05 06:57:48 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612417788 Strongest Point https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612418404 In 11th paragraph, Katrina said that capitalism is already dead and quoted an opinion of CEO, who knows the capitalism and the market system well. This makes her opinion more reliable.]]> 2020-06-05 06:58:23 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612418404 She argued that in her country, U.S, is a need for alternative to the current capitalism which is not idealized one with three reasons. First, there is an extreme inequality. She said, "... my country would be far better off if we had fewer billionaires and many more thousandaires." Second, there is consuming democracy.Third, pursuing excessive profit makes environment destroyed. https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612419157 2020-06-05 06:58:55 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612419157 Summary https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612419258 Capitalism is often equated with freedom, free markets, and democracy, but her country's extractive capitalism is deepening inequality, undermining freedom, endangering democracy, ravaging nature. the flavour and a well-funded attack on the government's role as a moderating, countervailing force. There is Canadian-style capitalism with stronger protections and rules to protect the common good; public investments to reduce poverty and encourage social mobility and innovation.  The next system(Canadian-style capitalism) would include the strengthening of a public banking and investment system designed for what she calls patient investment, not speculative capital, to rebuild decaying infrastructure. It will require planning alongside markets.]]> 2020-06-05 06:59:02 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612419258 she wanted to establish other, new capitalism to ensure equality, but actually she just assumed about possibility, not suggested effect alternative. https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612419343 we can check that through saying 
"I think we need to reassess, rethink, reimagine capitalism and move beyond what I said earlier" ]]> 2020-06-05 06:59:06 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612419343 https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612420366 She said that "We urgently need an alternative to the current broken capitalist 
system that will enable all people, not just the ultra-rich, to live lives of dignity and well-being. 
" in the first paragraph. But she didn't say the alternatives.]]> 2020-06-05 07:00:00 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612420366 https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612420674 I think her strongest point is in the sixth paragraph. Katrina argued that capitalism intensified the environmental destroy and causes extreme inequality.]]> 2020-06-05 07:00:19 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612420674 Weakest point https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612420878 She didn't explain why capitalism is consuming democracy enough.]]> 2020-06-05 07:00:28 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612420878 Katrina argued that we need an alternative to the present creaky capitalism. She pointed out that current capitalism produces extreme inequality. The rich get richer, the poor get poorer. She suggested that a redistribution policy is necessary to US. But it is not socialism. https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612422204 2020-06-05 07:01:38 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612422204 https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612422659 6th paragraph
“It is fuelling extreme inequality, it is consuming democracy, and it is destroying nature.”
   
socially => Inequality problem↑, environment problem ↑
]]> 2020-06-05 07:02:04 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612422659 10th paragraph, "Listen to some of our leading business leaders and investors ~." By using the example of the CEO of Salesforce, she can be more convincing to those who are believing in capitalism. https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612422711 2020-06-05 07:02:06 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612422711 Summary https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612423971 The debate on current capitalism is too much polarized―robber-baron capitalism, or freedom-zapping state socialism. But we need a fundamental reformation of economy system, not just tweaking capitalism. We don't need a monopoly, but individual freedoms.]]> 2020-06-05 07:03:05 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612423971 Neo-liberal consequences https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612436251 It accelerate the competition between enterprises and saves the rich's share. It also includes unconditional income gathering, which leads to real estate bubble. In 2008, we saw big shock.]]> 2020-06-05 07:13:01 UTC https://padlet.com/shekinahregan/rejwppfm76no32sv/wish/612436251