Napoleon: Hero or Tyrant by Roberto Saavedra

Dalvin Q (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:21:55 UTC

i disagree with Nya zya because although he did take all there power it stated in the text of "hero of the revolution or traitor to the revolution" it states that he restored order in the community

Andrew (Group.5)

2024-10-10 16:22:32 UTC

Everyone in the inner circle added on, disagreed, and agreed with each other well, and kept the conversation going.

Andrew (Group. 5)

2024-10-10 16:23:45 UTC

If Napoleon really was a hero, why would he go on to engage in so many battles, steal and loot from places he conquered, and killed many people?

derek lin group 10

2024-10-10 16:24:07 UTC

danial said how he made every one equal but how can that be when did he brang back slavery

arlene cruz (group 4)

2024-10-10 16:24:19 UTC

In the inner circle everyone talked and gave their opinion. They added on to each other and debated wether or not they he thought he was a hero or tyrant.

Daniella A group 3

2024-10-10 16:24:20 UTC

everyone is adding onto eachother and using proper language as agreeing with eachother and disagreeing. and adding on with eachother

Julee G (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:24:33 UTC

Everyone in the circle are agreeing and disagreeing with each other but some people are not speaking up

Evan H(group 6)

2024-10-10 16:25:05 UTC

I disagree with group 2 because he did support the french revolution because in appraising napoleon by Trevor R .Getz it says that he defended the people from the royalists who didn't support the french revolution.

Ikkra J. (Group 8)

ikkrajaman — 2024-10-10 16:26:23 UTC

I disagree with Na Zha stating that everyone wasn't equal because he stated that there was no secret laws and every law applied to everyone no matter what social class they are in.

Miram A (group 7)

2024-10-10 16:26:41 UTC

Everyone is agreeing and disagreeing with each other, and are stating evidence to support their claim

Dalvin Q (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:26:44 UTC

Group 2 did not make it very clear weather they are rooting for hero or villan they stated that he both helped and dishelped does this mean they feel like he was neautral?

derek lin

2024-10-10 16:26:50 UTC

danial said how he made every one equal but how can that be when did he brang back slavery?

Ravin A (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:26:54 UTC

I like how everyone gave their opinion on Napoleon if he is a hero or tyrant. Everyone was disagreeing and agreeing with each to reveal if he's really a bad guy or not.

Jasleen C (Group 3)

2024-10-10 16:27:06 UTC

I agree with Fareed because he stated that the only reason Napolean killed many people was because he was trying to protect the French. He lived up to the ideals of the French Revolution by achieving the ideas of liberty and fraternity. He protected his people .

Helen L Group 7

2024-10-10 16:27:07 UTC

I disagree with Na Zha because he took all the power in order to help build France. He would need the power in order to do all plans he made. Along with setting up supportive allied states in Europe.

Muntasir Hossain

2024-10-10 16:27:49 UTC

I disagree with what group 9 said because he gave everyone equality but also brought back slavery

derek lin group 10

2024-10-10 16:28:40 UTC

people who belive that he is a hero are commenting together one after another

Argenis N. group 4

argenisn4 — 2024-10-10 16:28:46 UTC

Porque si napoleon apoyaba el ideal de la libertad reinstauro la esclavitud en las colonia francesas.

Melanin Garcia - Group 2

2024-10-10 16:28:54 UTC

I disagree with Daniel because if he cared about giving freedom to people why did he bring back slaver after the Revolution went against it?

Evan H (Group 6)

2024-10-10 16:29:03 UTC

If napoleon was really a tyrant then why he support the French revolution by defending it by people who wanted to stop the french revolution?

Daniella Alvarado

2024-10-10 16:29:07 UTC

what is napoleon really? is he a hero OR tyrant? there is so much evidence to back up both so what really is he? And does it all matter now even though he is dead?

arlene cruz (group 4)

2024-10-10 16:30:35 UTC

How was napoleon a hero if he crowned himself emperor after taking down a monarchy? And why did he bring back slavery in the colonies ?

Aaliyahh (group 2)

Shaiann — 2024-10-10 16:30:48 UTC

I agree with nahza because he did betray the french revolutionist in many was because he did show everyone that he was doing good for them but he went behind them to do his own bitting.

Ravin . A (group 1)

2024-10-10 16:31:25 UTC

How was Napoleon power hungry if he saved people from the British ?

Melanin Garcia - Group 2

2024-10-10 16:32:05 UTC

I agree with Nya because he did not give women the right to chose things on their own. They had to get approval by their husbands.

Jasleen Cruz (group 3)

2024-10-10 16:32:42 UTC

Group 5 stated that Napoleon was power hungry which is what made him a tyrant. If he was only a tyrant then why would he live up to the ideal of the French Revolution; such as liberty, fraternity, and equality? He protected many people and brought peace and organization to the French Revolution. How does this make him a tyrant? Many people idolize him.

Yasser (g 9)

2024-10-10 16:32:43 UTC

If Napoleon was a tyrant, why did he support the French revolutions?

Argenis N. group 4

argenisn4 — 2024-10-10 16:32:53 UTC

estoy en desacuerdo con yengrifer porque dice que Napoleon apoyaba la revolucion, pero en el papel "Tasando a Napoleon" nos dice como napoleon deshizo los pocos avances durante la revolucion de las mujeres

Melanin Garcia - Group 2

2024-10-10 16:33:02 UTC

I agree with Nya because he did not give women the right to chose things on their own. They had to get approval by their husbands.

Ikkra J. (Group 8)

ikkrajaman — 2024-10-10 16:34:24 UTC

Could Napoleon be neutral? Does he really have to be a good person or a bad person specifically? He is a human, so he cant be perfect of course so there could be good things but also bad things like a normal human being. If he's dead, does it really matter now if he's a good person or a bad person?

Muntasir Hossain Group 10

2024-10-10 16:34:46 UTC

How has Napoleon give people freedom if he brought back salvery

Aaliyahh (group 2)

Shaiann — 2024-10-10 16:34:53 UTC

If he was a hero then why would he kick out the royal family's that were entitled to the thrown to then put his own family and friends and over throwing many surrounding areas.

Helen L

2024-10-10 16:35:36 UTC

If Napoleon is a tyrant, how come was he able to gain many supportive allies? And in our present period , how come are the laws and codes he made still relevant today when people considered him as a tyrant?

Julee G (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:35:59 UTC

If Napoleon was a tyrant why would he defend france in the first place?

Dalvin Q (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:38:18 UTC

Napoleon achived the ideals of the french revolution because he put laws that applied to all groups, ranks,economy levels of the french empire

Bryan Group 10

2024-10-10 16:39:01 UTC

Why is Napoleon making women get arranged marriage even though everyone should be equal no matter what?

Selena (group 8)

selenab43 — 2024-10-10 16:39:17 UTC

Napoleon is a hero because he cared for all the kids who's parents passed.He also lived up to the ideals of the French revolution.

Daniella Alvarado

2024-10-10 16:39:21 UTC

i disagree with derek that napoleon was trying to take all the power to himself, but the adding on with nerizza and derek are doing well and they are stating valid statements

Daniel Agit (Group 7)

2024-10-10 16:40:50 UTC

I Think that napolean helped out a lot of people and he gave them lots of freedom, then they had before.

Dalvin Q (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:40:50 UTC

If you are questioning Napoleons Loyalty to the ideals of the french why would he be so on top of putting order and equal rights back into the french empire?

Muntasir Group 10

2024-10-10 16:41:16 UTC

Napoleon betrayed the ideals of liberty because in a document called Napoleon and the French revoulution by holmberg,tom

It states "it was liberty which suffered most under Napoleon

Ikkra J. (Group 8)

ikkrajaman — 2024-10-10 16:41:38 UTC

I disagree with Derek because he did achieve the ideals of the revolution. He helped spread the revolutionary ideals across Europe. He promoted the basic ideas of the Revolution. Nerriza and Derek did very good adding onto each others claims.

Selena B Group 8

selenab43 — 2024-10-10 16:41:42 UTC

If napeolen was not a hero then why would he support the french revolution?,and why would he care for the kids who's parents passed when he could just forget about it?

Aaliyah (group 2)

Shaiann — 2024-10-10 16:42:09 UTC

Napoleon betrayed the ideas of the french revolution because from liberty he undid the the freedoms that were brought from the revolution.

Helen L

2024-10-10 16:42:13 UTC

Napoleon achieved the ideals of the French Revolution with the following ideals of liberty and equality. He brought equality for all and liberty by winning the title with success.

Bryan Group 10

2024-10-10 16:42:18 UTC

Why is Napoleon afraid of public criticism and why is he censoring writing about him?

Evan H (Group 6)

2024-10-10 16:42:19 UTC

I agree with group 8 that Napoleon did achieve the ideals of french revolution like for example in appraising Napoleon by Trevor R.Getz it said that he open religious freedom which gave freedom for people to do their religion.

Nya R -Group 4

2024-10-10 16:42:20 UTC

Napolean did take all the power, changed all the laws, and he even took womens rights away.

Abigail Group 5

2024-10-10 16:42:37 UTC

I disagree that napoleon is a hero because he was only power hungry and took away rights from the lower class.

muntasir Hossain

2024-10-10 16:42:49 UTC

How has Napoleon achieved the ideals of equality if he arranges marriage for women?

Daniella Alvarado

2024-10-10 16:42:53 UTC

did anyone believe that napoleon had equality?

Julee G (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:43:03 UTC

i notice that there are some not giving others a chance or enough of a gap to communicate out there thoughts.

nazha heny

2024-10-10 16:43:16 UTC

if Napoleon was a hero of the french revolution why did he concentrated and put all the power in his own hands and he democratic aspiration of the french revolution this is a question

selena B Group 8

selenab43 — 2024-10-10 16:43:25 UTC

I disagree with Derek because he helped to spread the ideals of the french revolution.

Nya R - group 4

2024-10-10 16:43:38 UTC

If he was such a hero why did he take away womens rights?

Evan H (group 6)

2024-10-10 16:44:15 UTC

If Napoleon betrayed the ideals of the french revolution then why many of the people wanted him to become emperor.

Jayleen E (Group 6)

2024-10-10 16:44:37 UTC

Napoleon had conquered Germany and France. However left his brother in charge of Germany and ordered him to grant them the rights they fought for in the rev

Ikkra J. (Group 8)

ikkrajaman — 2024-10-10 16:44:47 UTC

If Napoleon betrayed the Revolution, why would he ask his brother to give his subjects a higher degree of liberty, equality, and prosperity?

Argenis N. group 4

argenisn4 — 2024-10-10 16:44:54 UTC

Napoleon traiciono los ideales aclarando que para el no existian las amistades y no le importaban sus soldados sacrificandolos importandole solo su meta de conquistar el continente de europa

Fareed R. (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:44:55 UTC

I agree with what group 8 said. Napoleon did achevie the ideals of the revolution by giving people more rights

Julee G (Group 1)

2024-10-10 16:45:35 UTC

If you are argueing that Napoleon did not support the ideals of the french why would he state in "hero of the revolution or traitor to the revolution" in evidence 1 he states that one must support the winning side which devastates loots and burns meaning if he supports the french hes trying to bring them to victory so whats your opposing arguement to that?

Abigail Group 5

2024-10-10 16:46:21 UTC

If napoleon was a hero why did he act cruel and unsympathetic to the lower class and anyone who disagreed with him?

Daniel Agit (Group 7)

2024-10-10 16:48:20 UTC

Napolean helped out alot of people and he gave them new laws, and freedom.