https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if Made with the help of a typing monkey en-us 2020-08-20 20:02:38 UTC 2022-04-25 17:51:22 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972413 I think its dystopia because utopia everything fun and joyful but in the village its not fun and they kill people for mistakes.

]]> 2022-04-25 17:06:04 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972413 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972543 1. Too controlling, it doesnt seem fun at all.

2. Distopia. A utopia is supposed to be fun and perfect! In The Giver they literally kill people for making mistakes.]]> 2022-04-25 17:06:07 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972543 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972698 It is a Dystopia because it is very controlled, the people don't have any freedom and if they don't follow the rules they're killed.]]> 2022-04-25 17:06:12 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972698 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972871 Dystopia because you are being controlled and watched 24/7 and there are barely any freedoms. You MUST do what the higher ups tell you which sounds like a dystopia to me.]]> 2022-04-25 17:06:16 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156972871 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156973400 It is a dystopia, the government iscontrollingg, and overpowering, they control everything in these peoples people's]]> 2022-04-25 17:06:35 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156973400 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156973770 I think it is a dystopia because this society is focusing a lot on being perfect but when they try to be perfect they are just going to end up making things worse]]> 2022-04-25 17:06:48 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156973770 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156973996 I think the community if "The Giver" is a dystopia. This is because you don't have much of a choice of what you do with your life. You get your career chosen for you and you're basically forced to share your feelings every day.]]> 2022-04-25 17:06:57 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156973996 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974139 I believe this society Jonas lives in is a dystopia. With the amount of rules and regulations they have, the people are not properly able to be themselves without worrying about rules; such as bragging. Jonas couldn't even take an apple without being called out for it, and the little girls must wear bows (properly tied and NEAT) every day until a certain age. Something about this society, that comes off as so calm and perfect, does't quite feel right.]]> 2022-04-25 17:07:02 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974139 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974186 I think it is a dystopia because it is a very controlled society where nobody has much freedom and it is the same everyday life for everyone.]]> 2022-04-25 17:07:04 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974186 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974510 I think Jonas society is a dystopia because I don't think any society could be so perfect and organized. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:07:14 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974510 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974553 DYSTOPIA if you do wrong you are killed. there is no choice of what you can do when your older. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:07:16 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974553 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974967 I think that Jonas's society is a Dystopia because everything is being surveillance, and controlled which results in no freedoms or little to none]]> 2022-04-25 17:07:30 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156974967 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975088 I think its dystopia because it seems very controlling and it looks like evreything is chosen for them and they dont get a say and they just follow along]]> 2022-04-25 17:07:34 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975088 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975125 I think it is a dystopia because they control you by announcing the "bad things" you do while "not targeting" one person

]]> 2022-04-25 17:07:35 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975125 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975856 I think its a dystopia becuase because they are being watched and being controlled]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:01 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975856 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975927 The Giver appears to be utopia but is revealed to be dystopia as the story progresses.]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:05 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156975927 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976110 I think its a dystopia,
1. You don't get free will

2. You don't get to go in or out of the place you are already in

3. Everything you do has to be perfectly done

4. You must seem happy]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:12 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976110 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976343 I think it is a dystopia because it is being controlled and the people cannot really make their own decisions. which can turn into an outbreak of something bad.]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:20 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976343 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976506 I think Jonas lives in dystopia because they get controlled with everything they do.]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:26 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976506 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976510
Dystopia. A utopia is supposed to be fun and perfect! In The Giver they literally kill people for making mistakes. It is definitely a dystopia because its too controlling, it doesn't seem fun at all.]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:26 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976510 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976719 The reason it is a distopia is because the laws take away some rights given and opress or evenhold back the community keeping some from exspressing there opinionn and presentig there ideas]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:33 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976719 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976810 I think it's a mix between the two. Yes, the community is well put together and they are all polite and have strict rules to run by so nothing goes wrong, but imagine having to live by such strict rules all the time. It would get tiresome and you would probably want to leave. You are basically being assigned your life instead of getting to decide who you want to be. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:08:36 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156976810 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156977606 I beileve that the book the Giver is a dystopia, i beileve this because the the people of the community have no choices and have to follow the rules if not they will get punished.]]> 2022-04-25 17:09:03 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156977606 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156977669 In my opinion were Johan lives is a dystopia because it's very stricked and and demanding.  ]]> 2022-04-25 17:09:05 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156977669 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156979361 Dystopia because if you pay attention it feels like the people are being controlled. Like when the loud speakers came on and everyone automatically went inside. There is also the fact that if you do anything bad then you can be thrown out no matter what age and no one can do anything about esspecially at three strikes you are out that is why i think that the country or town the giver is based in is a dystopia.]]> 2022-04-25 17:09:53 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156979361 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156982501 The community in the giver is Dystopia. This is because everything there seems so suspicious and the rules are unusual. First of all, why is anyone "released"? What does it mean? Why does it happen to children and especially the old? Does it mean execution? Because that's what it sounds like. Why is everyone forcibly given a certain job randomly and the people can't choose for themselves? Why do strangers name the child instead of the parents? It's definitely Dystopia]]> 2022-04-25 17:10:46 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2156982501 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157042143 i think jonas lives in a dystopia because everything is so controlled and the rules are strictly unusual.]]> 2022-04-25 17:41:09 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157042143 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157043791 I think jona lives ina dystopia because his community is strict of everything and if you break a rule you are basically a criminal.]]> 2022-04-25 17:42:01 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157043791 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157044539 I think that jonas lives in a dystopia because everything is strict and very controlling. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:42:24 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157044539 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157044867 Jonas lives in a dystopia because there strict and very controlling.]]> 2022-04-25 17:42:35 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157044867 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157044966 I believe that the community in the giver is a dystopia, because everything and everyone are being controlled. Such as their jobs, their spouse, and even their children, they're all assigned and chosen for them.]]> 2022-04-25 17:42:37 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157044966 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157045143 i think its a dystopia because they don't much freedom to do what they want. they have very controlled life's ]]> 2022-04-25 17:42:42 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157045143 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157045279 I think Jonas lives in a dystopia because the rules are bizarre and strict. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:42:46 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157045279 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157046684 I think Jonas society is a dystopia because I don't think any society could be so perfect and organized. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:43:24 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157046684 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157046988 I think it's a dystopia because they do nothing under free will. The rules are very strict and controlling. EVERYTHING is controlled.]]> 2022-04-25 17:43:34 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157046988 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157047560 I think the world in The Giver is a dystopia because even though everyone seems happy, they seem restricted. Everyone has to follow certain rules and there is information hidden from the people. It feels like a dystopia because there is a hidden side to everything.]]> 2022-04-25 17:43:51 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157047560 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157047587 I think dystopia because the people must seem happy and the assignments are given to you.]]> 2022-04-25 17:43:52 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157047587 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157047658 The community in The Giver is a dystopia because the world is controlling. All of the rules they have are very strict.]]> 2022-04-25 17:43:54 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157047658 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048489 I think the giver community is a dystopia.I think this because it seems hidden from the outside world. It very controlling of it’s people and assigns them kids.]]> 2022-04-25 17:44:22 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048489 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048585 I believe that it is a dystopia, because everything and everyone are being controlled. 

]]> 2022-04-25 17:44:24 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048585 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048870 The society in The Giver is a dystopia. Everyone is controlled by a set of rules and there is something called "releasing". Any misbehavior can result in you getting released which is oppressive. There is barely any free will or choice since everyone has to be or act the same way. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:44:34 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048870 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048987 The community in The Giver is more of a utopia than a dystopia because there is not a lot of bad in this community. There are no repressing people or telling them what to think or feel as long as it's allowed in the rules. There are certain things you cannot do but as long as you follow those rules nothing bad will happen to you.]]> 2022-04-25 17:44:37 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157048987 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157049504 I believe Jonas lives in a dystopia because there are very strict rules, and they are being controlled. Also their jobs and pretty much their whole lives are chosen for them.]]> 2022-04-25 17:44:54 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157049504 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157049893 Jonas’ society is a dystopia. This is because everything is controlled, even emotions. A utopia is something perfect, but the society Jonas lives in is depriving the people from needed experiences, resulting in a dystopia. The community in the giver is a dystopia disguised as a utopia. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:45:05 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157049893 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157050162
The community is very brainwashed, but it's not their fault, because they grew up in that lifestyle they don't necessarily know that it's wrong

I would say it's both a utopia and dystopia. Or rather, it appears as a great utopia, but it is actually a hidden dystopia.]]> 2022-04-25 17:45:12 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157050162 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157050866 The community in "The Giver" is a hidden dystopian community. At first, everyone seems happy and there are no problems. But, everyone looks the same, wears the same thing, and live identical lives. People also don't get to make any choices. The Elders choose everything for everyone like their job and their spouse. While on the surface, everything seems perfect, there are many things that are far from a utopia. ]]> 2022-04-25 17:45:30 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157050866 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157050912 I believe Jonas' society/community is a dystopia because he and the others barely have any freedom to do what they actually please. If they have interests, they get limited careers, only what relates to the thing they want to do when they are older. They have certain jobs, and stern laws that they won't let go unpunished.]]> 2022-04-25 17:45:32 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157050912 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157051670 I think that the community in The Giver is more dystopian than utopian because the government (or whoever has power over the citizens) is very demanding and controlling. The community can't choose their jobs, kids, spouse, or how they act. They have very specific rules about how to do things, and very clear choices for the citizen's lives.]]> 2022-04-25 17:45:55 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157051670 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157055524 I think Jonas lives in dystopia because its the community is so controlled ]]> 2022-04-25 17:47:55 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157055524 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157057486 I think it is more of a dystopia because even through everyone seems happy, it seems restricted as if someone is controlling everyone.]]> 2022-04-25 17:48:53 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157057486 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157058204 I think that Jonas lives in a dystopia because they get no say and everything kinda has to be perfect so they dont have a choice.]]> 2022-04-25 17:49:14 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157058204 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157061023  1.) The community in The Giver conform to all the rules and laws, even if it's to their disadvantage or goes against their morals.

2.) It's a dystopia because the community is complying to strict and unnecessary laws and rules, that have severe consequences, if someone breaks them. The town is almost comparable to a cult.]]> 2022-04-25 17:50:37 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157061023 https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157062212 This place is a dystopia. Many rules are simple forceful rules that if broken can cause you to be released(killed). Everything is controlled by the Elders and other higher ups, everything is like a simulation.]]> 2022-04-25 17:51:14 UTC https://padlet.com/martha_belcher1/qytt0jrr3wa2r5if/wish/2157062212