2024英文辯論比賽台東高中隊 by 愛麗兒

Introduction to public forum debate

arielchenway — 2024-03-05 12:05:26 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-05 12:10:33 UTC

Resolved: Media outlets bear a greater responsibility than viewers incombating sensationalism

arielchenway — 2024-03-05 12:12:11 UTC

The phenomenon of sensationalism, a tactic where news stories are presented in an
exaggerated or provocative manner, has become increasingly common. It raises a critical
question: To what extent should media outlets versus viewers be held accountable?
Supporters of media outlets bearing greater responsibility claim that these outlets hold
power to shape public opinions and ought to counter the prevalence of sensationalism.
However, critics assert that content reflects audience preferences, and thus, viewers
should consume news more responsibly by evaluating news sources and supporting
outlets that prioritize accurate reporting. This debate hinges on the comparative impact
of media outlets and viewers. Which side has a more significant role to play in reducing
sensationalism?
The word "sensationalism" in the resolution refers to the practice of presenting news
stories in an attention-grabbing manner to generate interest in the audience. As opposed
to media, which refers to methods or channels of communication used to transmit
information (e.g. TV, radio, and print), "media outlets" specifically denote organizations
(e.g. CNN, BBC, and Formosa News) that produce and distribute news, information, and
entertainment through various channels. "Viewers" are individuals who consume media
content through media platforms. Also note that the word "greater" is vague, and thus,
the debaters should set up a comparative framework from the outset. This can be done by
arguing that one impact is bigger (in terms of magnitude), faster (in terms of time frame),
or more likely (in terms of probability) than another. Such a framework provides a set of
standards that will weigh into the judges’ decision.
As this is a public forum debate, the emphasis should NOT be placed on how
sensationalism can be curtailed. The pro side thus need not detail a plan for media outlets
to fight sensationalism, nor should the con side ask questions concerning that issue.
Instead, the debaters should focus on arguing the reasons and presenting evidence for
more responsibility on the part of either media outlets or viewers.
Following is a list of references meant to serve as some groundwork for debaters, which
means it is by no means comprehensive or flawless. Many of the references also contain
information or arguments that may not be directly relevant and thus warrant closer
examination. Students are still encouraged to continue researching in order to deepen
their understanding of the issue and strengthen their arguments in preparation for their
debate rounds.

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:47:46 UTC

證據卡格式

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:51:58 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:55:09 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:55:35 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:56:02 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:56:24 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:56:55 UTC

https://www.sjuhawknews.com/the-disadvantage-of-sensationalism-in-the-media/

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:58:18 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:58:55 UTC

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.3102/0002831216679817

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 14:59:30 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 15:02:33 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 15:03:00 UTC

Training 0309

arielchenway — 2024-03-09 15:09:22 UTC

1. Review the contest rules
2. Explore the subject matter of the debate resolution.

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:04:22 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:04:40 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:05:46 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:06:11 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:06:29 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:06:49 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:07:12 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:07:46 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:08:08 UTC

0316/0330

arielchenway — 2024-04-03 10:09:57 UTC

Notes

Online practice contest

arielchenway — 2024-04-10 02:56:58 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-10 02:57:14 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-10 02:59:04 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-10 02:59:23 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-10 02:59:40 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-10 03:00:14 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-11 00:41:11 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-11 00:41:22 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:26:20 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:26:38 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:27:03 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:27:28 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:27:43 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:28:23 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:28:51 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-12 09:29:12 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-13 11:01:30 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-13 11:01:51 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-13 11:02:28 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-13 11:02:44 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-13 11:03:03 UTC

arielchenway — 2024-04-15 01:51:57 UTC

庭安

arielchenway — 2024-04-20 10:12:45 UTC

感謝嬿羽老師願意擔任指導，以及組員的應允，使台東高中能夠成隊。辯論的處女賽，即以英文進行，帶來了莫大的挑戰，身為隊長必須掌控訓練節奏以及線上會議，學到同理心和責任心的重要，過程中有許多摩擦，曾想過放棄，但嬿羽老師耐心鼓勵，激發好勝心，比賽前深夜的會議，也讓我認知道自己不是一個人作戰。比賽當天的狀況有些不滿意，但組員間的鼓勵和現場應變，讓我學到了很多，也認識來自他校的對手，比賽間十分刺激，雙方的你來我往令我愉快，希望能在將來創立英辯社，讓更多人得以接觸英文辯論。

彥銨

arielchenway — 2024-04-20 10:19:39 UTC

非常感謝帶隊的嬿羽老師，老師真的非常認真。我覺得辯論是道高牆，我還在牆的底端。經過幾個禮拜的熬夜準備、午休團練，原本以為能輕易進入前三，卻發現我們想得實在太簡單了。對手不只熟讀資料，更想出不少觀點獨到的例子使我們難以招架；反觀專注於準備資料卡的我們，因為疏於配合和練習，反而出了不少醜。因此對此狀況我提出以下建議：1. 增加對內相互練習的機會。2.在獲得辯題時先分析辯題得核心。3.增加與他校的練習機會增廣視野。明年還有參與辯論比賽的機會，而我必定會參加，誓要和隊友拿下全國賽的代表權。

理恩

arielchenway — 2024-04-20 12:02:18 UTC

這是我第一次參加辯論比賽，我得到很多新的經驗與技能。其中包括快速記錄對方的論點、尋找漏洞來攻擊別人、以及如何應對別人提出的各式各樣的問題。我覺得自己說英文的口才有變好，唸一大段文字時能說得更加順暢。但是比起其他更厲害的人，我還有非常多要改進的地方，需要日後再努力訓練。我們花了很多課餘時間練習，有時在週六晚上開線上會議討論辯題，還有幾次請公假在輔導室的樓上一起訓練、查資料做證據卡。在這幾次的聚會中，我有機會跟隊員們交流、學習，收獲滿滿。比賽當天，我感到十分緊張，但是有隊友的幫忙讓我們能順利完成比賽，我非常感謝。謝謝嬿羽老師費盡心思和努力帶我們比賽，您的付出讓我不勝感激，您把我們這些萌懂無知的小朋友，訓練成優秀的辯士！

嘉營

arielchenway — 2024-04-20 12:27:33 UTC

這是我第一次參加英文比賽，也是我第一次參加辯論比賽，所以有很多不熟悉的地方，但我的組員都有參加過不同活動的經驗，幫助我們在準備階段有效率地推進工作。我是備取辯士，被分配到後勤工作，負責創意發想、協助製作證據卡和紀錄對手在比賽中提出的觀點和內容。我目前還不具備作為正式辯士的口說和反應能力，這次比賽讓我看到其他辯士各自擁有的優勢，也從他們身上學到一些方法。我很感謝隊友們的幫忙以及學校老師的鼓勵，幫助我順利的完成工作。

arielchenway — 2024-04-21 03:09:06 UTC