https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j This wall outlines the feedback from the online survey about the future NIME publication ecosystem, by topics. The workshop is organised by Alexander Refsum Jensenius, Andrew McPherson, Anna Xambó, Charles Martin, Jack Armitage, Niccolò Granieri, Rebecca Fiebrink, and Luiz Naveda. Workshop website: https://nime2020.bcu.ac.uk/nime-publication-ecosystem-workshop/ en-us 2020-07-15 17:59:53 UTC 2023-02-10 18:53:21 UTC hello@padlet.com annaxambo https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655346089 Is there a need? Internal study about viability? e.g. NIME data (see open data) but also other similar conferences e.g. ISMIR / TISMIR.

What criteria? High-impact factor? Low-entry vs high-entry level?
Good publisher? Editorial board?
Traditional peer-review vs more open approach? Open review?
Regularity vs. sustainability?
Open access as the conference?
How to keep the costs low?
e.g. avoid open access fees, asking authors to do typesetting.

What relation with the proceedings? e.g. extended articles? Reviews? Special issues?

What style? Online vs printed?
Printed + website for rich-media / interactive content? Formal journal vs innovative / online rich-media journal? Both? Conventional vs unconventional? Open access?
Journal with short videos + supplementary materials archive (ACM style)? How to meet external metrics from e.g. academic organisations?

How to document creative works?
Online galleries? e.g. Instrument collections? Curation of concerts? Research Catalogue model (https://www.researchcatalogue.net) with multimedia documentation and/or interdisciplinary research?]]> 2020-07-15 18:16:57 UTC https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655346089 annaxambo https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655359272 Indexation: How to solve indexation issues? Listing publications on ACM or Scopus for correct indexation? Losing authors because of this reason? Publish with DOI?

Rich media: Augmented experiences with videos and other media? How? e.g. short-papers based on artworks / tools e.g. see Leonardo.

Accessibility: Assure online web accessibility of content? User tests needed based on W3C accessibility?

Music / Installations / Workshops / Other: Inclusion of music and installations? e.g. see NIME 2019 Music Proceedings. Inclusion of workshops, non-poster demos, installations, and other new forms? e.g. themed panel discussion sessions with short position papers?

Impact music publications: How to improve the impact of music publications at NIME? Public event to the local citizens?

NIME conference template: ACM style excluding references to 6-page limit?

How to be more inclusive? Meritocracy vs divergence? How to accommodate all? e.g. pre-submission feedback process? (e.g. see pre-submission draft feedback at WAC 2019)

New tracks? Add a separate tool track? (short version that can complement a code repo). ]]> 2020-07-15 18:34:15 UTC https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655359272 annaxambo https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655369581 Eco-Future: How to assure a more sustainable conference? How to limit the carbon footprint of NIME?

Model: Multiple hubs vs online vs hybrid? (see attachment: "Grounding the ICMC: by Richard Parncutt to be published as letter to the editor in the forthcoming CMJ issue). ]]> 2020-07-15 18:48:38 UTC https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655369581 annaxambo https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655382805 The more the merrier vs less is more? Centralised vs distributed model? Holistic solution vs document with external links? Pros and cons? What media formats will be hosted natively? e.g. video repository for a greater future exposure. Online archiving of media in various formats? What platforms?  e.g. GitHub, Zenodo, video (e.g. YouTube, Vimeo) and audio platforms,... Integration with a repository for software / code / media / data? Arxiv.org for interdisciplinary work?
What resources are needed for a centralised vs distributed model?

Open data / Transparency: Always provide an open source / open hardware solution to promote accessibility? Transparency with submission / publication data? (see attachment: "Sixteen Years of Sound and Music Computing" by Mauro et al. 2020). Open source replicability of whole editing workflow offline? Online Accessibility (W3C) of documents?
Transparency, how? e.g. use of the wiki on GitHub repo to describe building instructions? Transparency of third-party service reuse of author's data?

Archiving standards? How to keep archiving standards? e.g. usability, impact, smooth publication process...

]]> 2020-07-15 19:07:53 UTC https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655382805 annaxambo https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655389494 What are the needs? Repository for open source instrument designs?
Instrument making tutorials (e.g. instructables)? Archive of performance and installation documentation? e.g. Vimeo channel? peer reviewed scientific video journal e.g. JoVE?
Experimental data? Aggregator of related publications to the NIME proceedings? How to balance traditional vs experimental? Art + Science?

What type of workflow? Self-hosted open publishing/reviewing platform? (e.g. PubPub, Wiki) + continuous publication process (conference, journal)?

Diversity: Workshops, papers... good start but how to move it forward and be more inclusive?

Social network? NIME forum? Another mailing list?

Professional hub? NIMEHub? (network of code, schematics, papers, videos...). A single repo where to access all/most NIME contributions (esp. tech details, code, designs) through a standardised interface? Creation of a researcher portal / hub? (skillset based) Career development?

Funding? Creative and future-focused ways of paying the envisioned needed infrastructure?

Implementation? How to implement this vision in a realistic, sustainable way? How to promote low barrier to entry and low maintenance? What are the available resources? How to start?


]]> 2020-07-15 19:17:45 UTC https://padlet.com/annaxambo/qsxjihgilp6cjf3j/wish/655389494