Watching these two options there are some points I would like to comment.

Considering these two options, there are some things we need to mention (or we need to take into account).

Firstly the yellow one is less waterproof than the blue one, although the blue has less punctuation about the colour, so I don´t know how important is, colour than waterproof. It is up to you.

First of all, the yellow one has less waterproof resistance than the blue jacket. However, when talking about colors,  it is true that the blue one is less appreciated than the yellow jacket. I don't know how important is for you the colour. So, you need to consider both things. It's up to you.

On the other hand, about comfort in the blue one has all stars so I think it is better than the yellow. But if we are talking about the price, obviously the blue one is more expensive than yellow.

Regarding comfort, the blue one has the highest score. In my opinion, it's definitely much better than the yellow jacket. On the other hand, if we consider the price, obviously the blue jacket is more expensive than the yellow one.

But at the end if we pay attention (at) in the overall rating the blue one has more score than the yellow.

But, in the end, and taking everything into account, I firmly believe that the blue jacket is worth as/since its quality is better.