4K on Cancel Culture by 3 RVHS STA SNG MING LIANG EUGENE https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6 Beginning questions: 1) How are callout and cancel culture different? 2)How is this culture beneficial and how might it become detrimental? 3) One local / foreign example en-us 2022-02-21 04:31:12 UTC 2022-02-21 05:29:21 UTC hello@padlet.com Elyse, Xing Rui, Eloise, Jing Tong https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058095514 callout culture is a more gentle way to education and giving them a chance for improvement and to learn from their mistakes. however cancel culture is toxic and devalues progress, leaving a bad impression of them online for a long time, with no room for improvement. ]]> 2022-02-21 05:14:17 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058095514 melanie, xinyan, yixuan, enyu https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058096412
  • In 2018, Singaporean influencer Daryl Aiden Yow was found to be editing other people’s photos and passing them off as his own. In the days following the reveal, netizens called for him to acknowledge the mistake, and also approached his sponsorship partners to ask them to drop him.

    • ]]>     2022-02-21 05:15:00 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058096412     Zhien!!!!!!!!!! https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058096997 Callout culture provides a chance for people to learn from their mistakes by criticising them.
    Cancel culture boycotting or the mass withdrawal of people or companies due to their problematic actions.


    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:15:25 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058096997     Zheng Kang, Wenxi, Rene, Micki https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098095 Cancel culture is an aggressive way of putting down somebody which does not believe that someone is capable of growth and development. 
    Call-out culture is a calmer approach of pointing out someone's mistake, telling them how to change and hoping they will learn from it and change for the better in the future.]]>     2022-02-21 05:16:21 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098095     xinyan, melanie, yixuan, enyu https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098098
  • Cancellation refers to an attack on someone’s employment and reputation by a determined collective of critics, based on an opinion or an action that is alleged to be disgraceful and disqualifying

    • Calling out is criticising someone but also allowing that person to redeem themselves

    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:16:21 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098098     Elyse, Xing Rui, Eloise, Jing Tong https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098167 1. benefit: holding them accountable for their mistakes so that they won't make it again
    2. benefit: educating them an acting as a catalyst for growth
    3. detriments: lower thier self esteem and leave a bad impression of them in the long term]]>     2022-02-21 05:16:25 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098167     Sze Kee, Zhi Lin, Qin Xi, Trixie https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098994 Cancel Culture 
    The practice or tendency of engaging in mass cancelling as a way of expressing disapproval and exerting social pressure
    Call-out Culture
    The idea of a “call-out”, generally refers to interpersonal confrontations occurring between individuals on social media
    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:17:11 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058098994     Elyse, Xing Rui, Eloise, Jing Tong https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058099031 Harry Potter author JK Rowling slammed again for new tweets about trans issues

    Her new posts on Sunday (Jul 5) included one where she said that some people believe they "are watching a new kind of conversion therapy for young gay people”, referring to those who are being “shunted towards hormones and surgery when this may not be in their best interests.”



    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:17:13 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058099031     Trixie, Qin Xi, Sze Kee, Zhi Lin https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058099298 Benefits:
    - Callout culture allows marginalised people to seek accountability where the justice system fails.
    - Cancelling allows less powerful people to have a voice.
    - Cancelling is a tool to bring about social change.

    Detriments:
    - Callout culture amounts to online bullying, and can incite violence and threats even worse than the original offence being called out.
    - Call out culture is not productive and does not bring about social change.
    - Callout culture is a slippery slope and leads to intolerance in democratic societies as people systematically exclude anyone who disagrees with their views.



    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:17:28 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058099298     qierr xinra limqia alici https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058099823 cancel culture -> does not work. doesnt acknowledge or believe in growth. Judgement outweighs justice. target celebrities or social groups, mass withdrawal of support from public figures or withdrawal of support from public figures or celebrities who have done things that arent socially accepted

    call-out culture->helps people to learn something, bring about social change, brings about healing, education and self awareness. helps build community, relationships ]]>     2022-02-21 05:17:57 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058099823     From companies' POV sng_ming_liang_eugene https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058100141 2022-02-21 05:18:16 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058100141 melanie, yixuan, enyu, xinyan https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058100466 benefits
    • allows marginalized people to seek accountability where the justice system fails
    • gives a voice to less powerful people
    • to bring about social change
    detriments
    • amounts to online bullying, and can incite violence and threats even worse than the original offense 
    • not productive
    • leads to intolerance in democratic societies as people systematically exclude anyone who disagrees with their views

    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:18:37 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058100466     Zhien! https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058101373 - can help promote social justice, holding people accountable for their actions especially celebrities and public figures when fans are quick to excuse their actions 
    - can be easy to get carried away and overpunish people, ganging up and taking the moral high ground, public shaming 
    - doesnt encourage the idea of giving people a second chance to learn from their mistakes and grow as a person
    - online bullying > can incite violence and threats even worse than the original offense being called out


    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:19:27 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058101373     Shi Huang, Hannah, En Xian, Michelle teo_rui_en_michelle https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058101816 In 2020, Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling, has faced intense criticism from her own fans since she began to voice transphobic beliefs. She became on of the most prominently “canceled” individuals at the center of the cancel culture debate.


    One of her tweets includes "Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like. Sleep with any consenting adult who'll have you. Live your best life in peace and security. But force women out of their jobs for stating that sex is real?"
    She added the hashtags "#IStandWithMaya" and "ThisIsNotADrill," making it clear that she was referring to Maya Forstater, a British researcher who lost her job at a nonprofit think tank following a series of tweets that were criticized as transphobic





    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:19:52 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058101816     Zhilin Szekee Qinxi Trixie https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058102322 - Sylvia Chan, boss of NOC had allegations of workplace abuse as she used slurs and mistreated her employees

    -JK Rowling tweeted a transphobic post and completely did not consider the thoughts and feelings of transgender 
    people

    - Ellen DeGeneres producers allegedly engaged in sexual assault and misconduct]]>     2022-02-21 05:20:22 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058102322     En Xian Michelle Hannah Shi Huang https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058102327 Benefits:
    1. Allows marginalized people to seek accountability where the justice system fails
    2. Gives voice to less powerful people
    3. can help to bring about social change
    4. allows them to realise what they did wrong and will learn from their mistakes

    Detriments:
    1. results in cyberbullying, and can even incite violence and threats
    2. not productive and does not bring about social change
    3. may not be tolerated in democratic places as everyone's views should be taken into account
    4. the comments may hurt people's feelings]]>     2022-02-21 05:20:22 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058102327     xrn qra alc lmq https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058106199 examples of cancel culture:
    - tony lopez in 2020 (child predator)
    - james charles in 2021 (child predator)
    - sienna mae gomez in 2021 (sexual assault)
    all lost many supporters after the incidents and disappeared off of social media for a period of time, still get hate although it happened quite a while back
    examples of callout culture:
    - kevin hart received backlash about being homophobic, transphobic and racist in the past, yet still receive acclaim, support and views]]>     2022-02-21 05:21:43 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058106199     enxian, hannah, shihuang and michelle https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058109974 cancel culture:
    - someone who has been ostracized for their opinions or actions and thrust out of social groups 
    - toxic and unnecessary for the growth of a society 
    callout culture: 
    - a statement drawing critical attention to someone's unacceptable actions or behaviour, but not meant to hurt anyone's feelings
    - necessary for society to progress forwards]]>     2022-02-21 05:22:09 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058109974     Wen Xi, Rene, Micki, Zheng Kang https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058111291 Cancel culture is effective in getting one to stop, but it may come with major emotional side effects.
    Call-out culture is more constructive and will help the person more in the future, but may not be effective in the short term to get someone to stop doing something.]]>     2022-02-21 05:22:24 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058111291     J.K. Rowling example hon_qin_xi1 https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058119660 https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-her-reasons-for-speaking-out-on-sex-and-gender-issues/]]> 2022-02-21 05:24:33 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058119660 zhien https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058121151 Dee Kosh
    Xia Xue
    Soh Rui Yong
    Eden Ang]]>     2022-02-21 05:25:56 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058121151     Local marathoner Soh Rui Yong sng_ming_liang_eugene https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058121286 2022-02-21 05:26:05 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058121286 https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058121912 https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/influencer-accused-of-doxxing-after-compiling-list-of-men-on-dating-apps-to-blacklist-and]]> 2022-02-21 05:26:37 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058121912 Pros and cons of cancel culture https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058123334 https://www.procon.org/headlines/is-cancel-culture-or-callout-culture-good-for-society/#arguments


    ]]>     2022-02-21 05:27:58 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058123334     Wen Xi, Rene, Micki, Zheng Kang https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058124708 Tiktoker boonkikikiki was accused of doxxing after she started a chat group for women to share details of Singaporean men not to date.]]> 2022-02-21 05:29:21 UTC https://padlet.com/sng_ming_liang_eugene/puxi3clicwnuiac6/wish/2058124708