The protagonist of the play, Peter is a young orphan boy who is on a journey that will eventually lead him to become the legendary Peter Pan.

Peter begins as an ordinary boy without a name or history, but throughout the play, he discovers his destiny as the Boy Who Never Grows Up. His character is innocent, curious, and brave, which sets him on the path to adventure and fantasy.

As the story progresses, Peter's courage, leadership, and belief in his own abilities are highlighted, shaping him into the legendary figure of Peter Pan.

Molly is the young, intelligent, and resourceful daughter of Lord Aster, a high-ranking official in the Queen’s service. She is a Starcatcher-in-training, a protector of the powerful, magical substance called starstuff.

Molly is both practical and imaginative. She possesses the ability to think quickly and solve problems, which becomes crucial as she faces pirates and other dangers. Her character adds a strong, heroic female presence to the story.

Over the course of the play, Molly becomes Peter’s ally and helps him discover his true identity. Her resourcefulness and quick thinking are central to the adventure’s success.

Lord Aster is Molly’s father and an esteemed Starcatcher. He is dedicated to protecting the starstuff from falling into the wrong hands.

Lord Aster is a wise and dignified figure who serves as a fatherly figure to Peter and as a mentor to Molly. His mission is to keep the starstuff safe, which involves battling against villains like Black Stache.

Lord Aster’s bravery and wisdom guide Molly and Peter throughout their journey. His character represents authority and responsibility in the world of Starcatchers.

A pirate who later becomes the infamous Captain Hook. In "Peter and the Starcatcher," he is ambitious, cunning, and easily angered. His quest for wealth and power leads him to pursue the starstuff.

Initially introduced as a minor character named "Stache," he evolves into the more iconic Captain Hook we know from the Peter Pan story. His iconic hook is symbolic of his eventual transformation.

As the play progresses, Black Stache’s obsession with becoming the most feared pirate drives him to extreme measures, including his infamous hook and rivalry with Peter Pan.

One of the orphan boys who accompanies Peter on his journey. Prentiss is kind-hearted, loyal, and optimistic, despite the harsh conditions they face as orphans.

Prentiss quickly befriends Peter and shares in his adventures, making him an essential part of the group. His interactions with the other characters add humor and warmth to the story.

Throughout the play, Prentiss’s loyalty and bravery are highlighted, especially as he faces danger alongside Peter and Molly. His character helps to humanize the harsh environment of the orphans’ lives.

Molly and Peter Meet:

• Molly joins Peter aboard the Neverland, hiding starstuff.

• Introduction to Black Stache’s villainy.

Storm at Sea:

• The Neverland breaks apart during a storm.

• Peter, Molly, and the boys wash ashore on a desert island.

Island Conflict:

• Peter and Molly work to protect starstuff.

• Black Stache’s crew arrives, leading to tension and a budding rivalry with Peter.

Search for Starstuff:

• Peter and Molly search for starstuff, facing Black Stache’s threats.

• Molly discovers Peter’s potential as Peter Pan.

Transformation:

• Peter embraces his destiny as Peter Pan.

• Molly’s role as a Starcatcher and protector solidifies.

Climax:

• Confrontation with Black Stache leads to his defeat.

• Peter, Molly, and the boys escape on a new ship, The Jolly Roger.

Elice transitioned into playwriting with a focus on collaborative musical theatre. His work is known for its humor, heart, and inventive storytelling.

"Peter and the Starcatcher" (2011), co-authored with Rick Elice and based on the novel by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson, is one of his most acclaimed works. The play serves as a prequel to the classic tale of Peter Pan, exploring how Peter becomes the legendary hero.

"The Addams Family" (2010), another collaboration with Marc Shaiman and Scott Wittman, is a musical comedy based on the iconic characters from the cartoons and TV series. It showcases Elice’s ability to adapt well-known properties into engaging, humorous, and heartwarming stage productions.

"Jersey Boys" (2005), for which he wrote the book, tells the story of the Four Seasons rock band and is another testament to his skills in creating engaging and detailed narratives.

Elice’s plays often blend humor with emotional depth, exploring themes of identity, growth, and the importance of imagination. His work has a whimsical quality that appeals to both adults and children.

He has a knack for blending historical and fantastical elements, as seen in "Peter and the Starcatcher," where he seamlessly integrates adventure, humor, and meaningful character development.

North American Tour (2012-2013):

• The show toured major cities across the United States and Canada, giving audiences across the continent the opportunity to see the production.

• The touring version retained the creative team’s vision and showcased the flexibility of the script and set design to adapt to different venues.

UK Tour (2015):

• After its success on Broadway, "Peter and the Starcatcher" was adapted for a UK tour.

• It featured a British cast and was adapted for British audiences while maintaining the heart and humor of the original.

• The tour ran from February 2015 through October 2015, visiting cities like Edinburgh, Cardiff, Birmingham, and London.

Australian Premiere (2013):

• Sydney Theatre Company in Sydney, Australia, staged the play in 2013.

• The Australian production was praised for its inventive design and local casting, bringing a unique interpretation to the tale.

International Productions:

• The show has been adapted and staged in various languages, including French, Spanish, and German, for international audiences.

• Productions have been seen in countries such as Japan, South Korea, Germany, and The Netherlands, showcasing the universal appeal of the story.

Regional Theaters in the United States and Community Theater groups have also mounted productions, reflecting the play’s adaptability to smaller stages and its suitability for community engagement.

These productions often feature local actors and a variety of creative adaptations to suit their specific resources and audiences.

Many high schools and colleges across the United States have produced "Peter and the Starcatcher" as part of their drama programs, recognizing its appeal to young actors and the opportunity it offers for inventive staging and ensemble work.

The play’s flexible set design and ensemble cast make it an excellent choice for educational settings.

Minimalism with Maximal Impact:

• The play relies heavily on an inventive, minimalist set to allow the audience’s imagination to fill in the gaps. Designers must balance simplicity with functionality, creating multi-purpose props and set pieces that transform quickly and convincingly into ships, islands, or other fantastical locales.

Fluid Transitions:

• The story moves rapidly between locations (e.g., the Neverland ship, ocean scenes, and an island), requiring seamless transitions. Designers must create modular, flexible elements to support quick changes.

Thematic Cohesion:

• Maintaining a cohesive visual language while representing both grounded and fantastical environments can be challenging. For instance, the ship's realism must contrast with the magical starstuff and island scenes without feeling jarring.

Character Transformation Through Costumes:

• Black Stache’s flamboyance must be reflected in his costume without overshadowing his menace. His transition into Captain Hook (post-hand loss) requires a clear visual cue.

• The orphans’ costumes need to reflect their scrappy, vulnerable nature while remaining versatile for physical performances.

Creativity in Creating Non-Human Elements:

• Designing for animal characters like the crocodile or fantastical elements such as mermaids requires a mix of practicality and imagination. These costumes must communicate the essence of the creature while allowing for actor movement and visibility.

Durability and Movement:

• Costumes must endure physically demanding performances, including climbing, running, and stunt work. Fabrics and designs need to allow for freedom of movement while maintaining their integrity across shows.

Conveying Shifting Tones:

• The play shifts between humorous, adventurous, and emotional moments. Lighting must adapt seamlessly to highlight these changes without disrupting the audience’s immersion.

Creating Magic Through Light:

• Starstuff is a pivotal element in the story, and its ethereal glow must feel magical. Achieving this effect may require creative use of color, intensity, and light sources like fiber optics or projections.

Defining Spaces:

• With a minimalist set, lighting often defines the boundaries of a scene (e.g., a ship’s deck, the ocean, or an island). Lighting designers must use shadows, color, and angles to create distinct, believable environments.

Transforming Actors into Multiple Characters:

• Many actors play more than one role, such as pirates, sailors, and island natives. Their makeup needs to change quickly or be neutral enough to work for all their roles while still being clear to the audience.

Creating Unique Characters:

• Characters like Black Stache (a funny but scary pirate) need bold, exaggerated makeup to show their personality. The makeup must be detailed enough for the audience to see from far away.

Blending Realistic and Magical Elements:

• Some parts of the story are realistic (like the orphan boys and pirates), while others are magical (like the starstuff and the glowing effects). Makeup needs to balance these styles so they fit together.