2nd Meeting Discussion_Should_XS3 by paulina rian

What makes 'Should go earlier' different from 'should have gone earlier'?

paulinarian — 2020-07-28 00:20:16 UTC

Apa bedanya Should go Should +V1) dengan Should have gone (should +have+V3)? Silakan teman2 jelaskan dengan gambar atau suara atau sarana draw di padlet ini.

How to pronounce 'shouldn't'?

paulinarian — 2020-07-28 00:20:16 UTC

Bentuk negatif dari should adalah 'shouldn't' coba buat kalimat sederhana dengan shouldn't lalu rekam dan kirimkan rekamannya melalui file dibawah ini. Ex.: You shouldn't answer him that way

What kind of verbs follow 'modal should' ?

paulinarian — 2020-07-28 00:20:16 UTC

Sekarang coba beri contoh dengan kalimat teman-teman sendiri beserta dengan fungsinya. Example: Paulina: You should move on (Advice) Paulina 2: You should have given it to him. He needs it, really. (Hal yang seharusnya dilakukan tapi tidak dilakukan di waktu lampau)

Why the shop they mentioned on the Audio isn't ethical?

paulinarian — 2020-07-28 00:20:16 UTC

The use of 'should' in the audio

paulinarian — 2020-07-28 00:20:16 UTC

If you hear so, please quote from the audio!

Titus Aryo Sasongko

titussasongko — 2020-07-28 03:28:58 UTC

"It isnt ethical. We shouldn't buy things there." (Carolina's Dialogue)

Arthur

2020-07-28 03:29:19 UTC

"it isn't ethical we SHOULDN'T buy things here"

Rilan

2020-07-28 03:29:28 UTC

Deo

2020-07-28 03:29:39 UTC

"it isn't ethical we shouldn't buy things here"

Gerald Arva

2020-07-28 03:33:06 UTC

yes,"it isn't ethical.you Should buy things there.

Ferdinand Hery

2020-07-28 03:51:03 UTC

Yes. "It isn't ethical. We shouldn't buy things here."

Edbert Gaynell Alrich Junawan

2020-07-28 03:51:57 UTC

" We Shouldn't buy things there."

Rajya Reevan

2020-07-28 03:53:03 UTC

it isn't ethical, we shouldn't buy things there

Yohanes Paskalio

2020-07-28 03:53:43 UTC

it isn't ethical. you SHOULD buy things there.

hieronimus satrio wibowo

2020-07-28 03:54:00 UTC

we shouldnt buy things here

Arthur Alloysius Jeremy Rafra

2020-07-28 03:55:04 UTC

You should have go to the party last last night
(Advise, for something that should have done in the past)

I really shouldn't have buy that car
(Regrets, of doing something wrong)

Alfonsus Arron

2020-07-28 03:55:36 UTC

"It isn't ethical. We shouldn't buy things there."

benedict saviola

2020-07-28 03:55:47 UTC

it is'nt ethical we should buy things there

Vincentius Jevon

2020-07-28 03:56:06 UTC

"We shouldn't buy things here"

Martino Panorangi Trihandika Tampubolon

2020-07-28 03:56:36 UTC

"We shouldn't buy things here"

Titus Aryo Sasongko

titussasongko — 2020-07-28 03:56:38 UTC

Because the shop makes the workers work in terrible conditions, and also the shop don't pay the workers with enough money

Marcellus Deo

2020-07-28 03:56:59 UTC

Because workers are not paid at the store

Ferdinand Hery

2020-07-28 03:57:08 UTC

Because it's employee isn't paid with the right amount of money. By that mean, underpaid.

Marcellinus loleq lewidarmaja

2020-07-28 03:57:19 UTC

Gabriel callyandra sylva yustha

2020-07-28 03:57:53 UTC

It isn't ethical.we shouldn't buy things here

Jason

jasonbudiman — 2020-07-28 03:58:05 UTC

Because the workers who is working at the shop are underpaid and forced to work long hours in terrible conditions.

Adriel Laurian Wikan A

2020-07-28 03:58:12 UTC

"It isn't ethical. We shouldn't buy things there."

marcellinus loleq

2020-07-28 03:58:15 UTC

because workes are not paid

Alfonsus Arron

2020-07-28 03:58:26 UTC

The shop isn't ethical because the shop make the workers work long hour in terrible condations and the shop don't pay the workers with properly

Raden Jeremy Farrel

2020-07-28 03:58:42 UTC

Yes, i notice it. "It isnt ethical, we shouldn't buy things here."

Felix Paramarta Nareswara

2020-07-28 03:58:43 UTC

"It isnt ethical. We shouldn't buy things there."

Martino Panorangi Trihandika Tanpubolon

2020-07-28 03:59:01 UTC

Because the shop's employee isn't paid with the right amount of money.

Yohanes Paskalio

2020-07-28 03:59:01 UTC

because they dont pay the workers with enough money and the workers work in the terrible condition with long hour

Ferdinand Hery

2020-07-28 03:59:18 UTC

I should have entered the Google Meet with my friends last saturday.
(Advise, for something I should have done in the past)

Nicholas Adi Prameswara

2020-07-28 03:59:51 UTC

it isn't ethical, we shouldn't buy things there.

Rajya Reevan C.H

2020-07-28 04:00:38 UTC

the shop not ethical
because they don't pay the workers enough money and make the worker work for a long hours and in the terrible condition

Christian Daniel Aditama

2020-07-28 04:00:51 UTC

we shouldn't buy things there

Jason

jasonbudiman — 2020-07-28 04:01:31 UTC

"We shouldn't buy things there."

Noverio Sandi

2020-07-28 04:01:34 UTC

Yes.
The function of should from dialogue , is for giving advice /recommendation.

I knew that when carolina said "It isn't ethical. We shouldn't buy things there."

the shop isn't ethical because,they don't pay their worker with enough money. And make them work for a long hours in terrible conditions.

2020-07-28 04:01:36 UTC

Adriel Lurian Wikan A.

Nicholas Adi Prameswara

2020-07-28 04:01:46 UTC

The shop isn't ethical because they make the workers work long hours in terrible condition and don't give the workers enough money.

Titus Aryo Sasongko

titussasongko — 2020-07-28 04:01:46 UTC

You should have woken up earlier yesterday. (Advice someone for something that should have done in the past)

marcellinus loleq

2020-07-28 04:02:39 UTC

"The shop is not ethical . we shouldn't buy things there"

Edbert Gaynell Alrich Junawan

2020-07-28 04:03:34 UTC

Because the t shirts are very cheap, they doesn't pay the workers enough money they make them work long hours in terrible condition.

Raden Jeremy Farrel

2020-07-28 04:03:47 UTC

"it isnt ethical, we shouldnt buy things here."

2020-07-28 04:04:05 UTC

Momo
“it isnt ethical.We shouldnt buy things there”

Ferdinand Hery

2020-07-28 04:04:38 UTC

You shouldn't done that to your ex. She will be very angry for that.

Arthur Alloysius Jeremy Rafra

2020-07-28 04:04:42 UTC

Edbert Gaynell Alrich Junawan

2020-07-28 04:04:59 UTC

You should be studying harder yesterday.

Dicky

2020-07-28 04:05:27 UTC

yes i pay attention. "isnt  ethical. We shouldt buy things here"

Rilan

2020-07-28 04:06:14 UTC

Because in this shop they are not paid.

Martino Panorangi Trihandika Tampubolon

2020-07-28 04:06:25 UTC

You should have studied yesterday. (Advise, for something i should have done in the past)

Rajya reevan C.H

2020-07-28 04:06:33 UTC

I should study harder next time

Vincentius Jevon

2020-07-28 04:06:34 UTC

Because the t-shirts are very cheap, and they doesn't pay the workers enough money. They make them work long hours in terrible conditions.

Yohanes Paskalio

2020-07-28 04:06:34 UTC

you should have took a nap like yesterday

Rafael Jodhi Kapitan

rafaeljodhi — 2020-07-28 04:06:54 UTC

Because the shop doesnt pay the workers with enough money and the workers are work in a long hours and teribble condition.

Adriel Laurian Wikan A.

2020-07-28 04:06:59 UTC

-You should sleep earlier next time
-I shouldn't play games with my friend yesterday

Richardus Arlo A

2020-07-28 04:07:05 UTC

It isnt ethical, we shouldnt buy things there

marcellinus loleq

2020-07-28 04:07:38 UTC

i should study hard every day

Gabriel callyandra sylva yustha

2020-07-28 04:08:35 UTC

Because the shop doesn't pay the workers enough and make the worker work long hours

Jason

jasonbudiman — 2020-07-28 04:08:42 UTC

"You should stop eating junk food and start eating more vegetables."
( Advice )

Rajya Reevan C.H

2020-07-28 04:08:56 UTC

you should not cheat in the exam
the teacher will be angry to you

Marcellus Deo

2020-07-28 04:09:01 UTC

you should have listened the teacher announce yesterday

Arthur Alloysius Jeremy Rafra

2020-07-28 04:09:17 UTC

we use 'Shouldn't have' for past tense, so "Shouldn't have gone earlier" means you 'should go earlier'" in the past

"Should go earlier" we used that sentences for 'present tense and future tense' so the word "Should go earlier" means we have to go early RIGHT NOW!!!

2020-07-28 04:09:20 UTC

Momo
The shop is not ethical because they dont pay the workers enough money and make the worker work for long hours in the teribble condition

Rilan

2020-07-28 04:09:34 UTC

Paskal,you should have written this chapter

Rizki Putrawan

rizkiputrawan — 2020-07-28 04:09:48 UTC

it isn't ethical, we shouldn't buy things there

marcellinus loleq

2020-07-28 04:09:58 UTC

you shoud not lazy to studying

Richardus Arlo A

2020-07-28 04:10:05 UTC

Because the T-shirts are very cheap because the shop dont pay the workers enough money. They make them work long hours in terrible conditions.

Felix Paramarta

2020-07-28 04:10:26 UTC

they doesn't pay the workers enough money and make them make the worker work for long hours

Noverio Sandi

2020-07-28 04:10:30 UTC

They mentioned the shop isn't ethical because, the shop doesn't pay the workers enough money, and they make the workers work for long time in terrible condition.

Raden Jeremy Farrel

2020-07-28 04:10:30 UTC

Because, the shop dont pay the workers enough money. And they make the workers work long hours in the terrible condition.

Nicholas Adi Prameswara

2020-07-28 04:10:59 UTC

Christian Daniel Aditama

2020-07-28 04:11:39 UTC

because the employees are treated badly

Alfonsus Arron

2020-07-28 04:11:42 UTC

You should have paid him
(Advice)

marcellinus loleq

2020-07-28 04:11:56 UTC

we use "should go earline " in future time and "should have gone earlier" in past time

hieronimus satrio wibowo

2020-07-28 04:12:00 UTC

not ethnic because of a misplaced place

Yohanes Paskalio

2020-07-28 04:12:40 UTC

You shouldn't go out because it's raining heavily

Nicholas Adi Prameswara

2020-07-28 04:12:41 UTC

You should defrost

Titus Aryo Sasongko

titussasongko — 2020-07-28 04:12:44 UTC

Vincentius Jevon

2020-07-28 04:12:50 UTC

I should do the homework now.

Jason

jasonbudiman — 2020-07-28 04:12:53 UTC

benedict saviola pradana

2020-07-28 04:13:01 UTC

because the shop not pay the workers enough money

Noverio Sandi

2020-07-28 04:13:31 UTC

You should change your shirt. It doesn't cool (advice/saran)

I should be training harder. So I can win the competition week. (Showing urgency thing/ sesuatu yang harus segera dilakukan)

I shouldn't have eaten in the class.
(Showing regret on something)

Ferdinand Hery

2020-07-28 04:13:33 UTC

We use "should go earlier" for the present and future time.
We use "should have gone earlier" for the past time.

Titus Aryo Sasongko

titussasongko — 2020-07-28 04:13:35 UTC

The difference between "should go earlier" and "should have gone earlier" is :

We use "should go earlier" for showing some action in present or future

We use "should have gone earlier" for showing action that should have done in the past

Putu Ardana

putuwidnyana — 2020-07-28 04:14:17 UTC

Martino Panorangi Trihandika Tampubolon

2020-07-28 04:14:21 UTC

You shouldn't leave your key in your locked car.

Nicholas Adi Prameswara

2020-07-28 04:14:50 UTC

You should have defrosted the meat before(regret)

Albertus Dandin

2020-07-28 04:15:20 UTC

it isn't ethical, we shouldn't buy things there

Gabriel callyandra sylva yustha

2020-07-28 04:15:20 UTC

i should study every night

you should not lazy studying

2020-07-28 04:15:22 UTC

marcellinus loleq

Felix Paramarta

2020-07-28 04:15:33 UTC

you should have took a drug

Benediktus Wahyu K.

2020-07-28 04:15:57 UTC

We shouldn't buy things here.

Christian Daniel Aditama

2020-07-28 04:16:28 UTC

you should have paid your debt last week

NIcholas Adi Prameswara

2020-07-28 04:16:30 UTC

"should go earlier"= used to give advice
"Should have gone earlier"=usde to show regrets

hieronimus satrio wibwo

2020-07-28 04:16:30 UTC

i shoud more disciplined

Dicky

2020-07-28 04:17:08 UTC

because they cannot pay their workers and make their workers work long hours in dire conditions

hieronimus satrio wibowo

2020-07-28 04:18:04 UTC

you should be aeting

Richardus Arlo A

2020-07-28 04:18:06 UTC

I should have studied last night (regret)

Putu Ardana

putuwidnyana — 2020-07-28 04:18:31 UTC

it isnt ethical, we shouldnt buy things here.

Martino Panorangi Trihandika Tampubolon

2020-07-28 04:18:47 UTC

Should+have+v3 itu digunakan untuk menyatakan hal yang seharusnya dilakukan di masa lampau seperti "You should have gone earlier" yang berarti "kamu harusnya pergi lebih awal"

Should+v1 itu digunakan untuk menyatakan hal yang harus dilakukan sekarang atau dalam waktu dekat seperti "You should go earlier" yang berarti "kamu harus pergi lebih awal"

Adriel Laurian Wikan A

2020-07-28 04:19:16 UTC

Raden Jeremy Farrel

2020-07-28 04:19:19 UTC

You should have learned the lesson last night, for the test today.

Putu Ardana

putuwidnyana — 2020-07-28 04:19:55 UTC

Because they can't pay the workers and make the worker work for a long hours

Alfonsus Arron

2020-07-28 04:20:01 UTC

You shouldn't cheating in the test bro

Rizki Putrawan

rizkiputrawan — 2020-07-28 04:20:19 UTC

because they dont pay the workers enough money and they make them work long hour and terrible condition

Rilan

2020-07-28 04:20:34 UTC

Benediktus Wahyu K.

2020-07-28 04:20:40 UTC

Because the Shop doesn't pay the workers enough and they make them work long hours.

Dicky

2020-07-28 04:20:42 UTC

You should have left because it was terrible (condition alone)

Christian Daniel Aditama

2020-07-28 04:20:51 UTC

"should go earlier" use for the present and future time
"should have gone earlier"use for the past time

Vincentius Jevon

2020-07-28 04:20:54 UTC

I shouldn't have left my wallet in my class.

Marcellus Deo

2020-07-28 04:21:16 UTC

You shouldn't play truant

Rilan

2020-07-28 04:21:37 UTC

The difference (should + v1 with s) and (should + have + v3) is that should + v1 be used to describe the actions that must be done now, while should + have + v3 to explain the actions that must be done in the past

Gabriel callyandra sylva yustha

2020-07-28 04:21:55 UTC

You shouldn't play games every day

2020-07-28 04:23:13 UTC

Gerald Arva Kristanto

Because workers in that place are not paid the proper money

Adriel Laurian Wikan A

2020-07-28 04:24:10 UTC

The different beetwen "You should go earlier" and "You should have go earlier" is

You should go earlier=Present, Future
You have go earlier=Past

hierpimus satrio wibowo

2020-07-28 04:25:54 UTC

should digunakan dalam kalimat saran

Christian Daniel Aditama

2020-07-28 04:26:02 UTC

Albertus Dandin

2020-07-28 04:26:17 UTC

because they don't pay the workers enough money and they them work long hour and teriblle condition

Raden Jeremy Farrel

2020-07-28 04:26:21 UTC

We use "Should go earlier" for/in the present and future time.
And....
We use "should have gone earlier" for the past time.

Vincentius Jevon

2020-07-28 04:26:31 UTC

The difference between "Should go earlier" and "Should have gone earlier" is "Should go earlier" is used for present activities while "Should have gone earlier" is used for past activities.

Rizki Putrawan

rizkiputrawan — 2020-07-28 04:26:32 UTC

You should do your homework(advice)

Jason

jasonbudiman — 2020-07-28 04:27:10 UTC

Because the use of have+V3 is implying that it's talking about the past.

Richardus Arlo A

2020-07-28 04:27:13 UTC

You shouldn't play games when class is ongoing

2020-07-28 04:27:36 UTC

I should play better nextime
Momo

Alfonsus Arron

2020-07-28 04:27:51 UTC

we use "should go earlier" for peresent or future.
"Should have gone earlier" use for past

benedict saviola pradana

2020-07-28 04:28:04 UTC

i should sleep earlier tonight

Gerald Arva Kristanto

2020-07-28 04:29:09 UTC

You should be drinking medicine early

Rajya Reevan C.H

2020-07-28 04:29:16 UTC

should go earlier is to tell him to go earlier
and should have gone earlier to tell him to hurry up to go earlier

Gabriel callyandra sylva yustha

2020-07-28 04:29:27 UTC

Should have go earlier for the past and should go earlier for now

2020-07-28 04:29:47 UTC

The diffrent is
“should go earlier”for present and future
“should have gone earlier”for past time
Momo

Dicky

2020-07-28 04:30:57 UTC

You shouldn't angry with me

Yohanes Paskalio

2020-07-28 04:31:23 UTC

"should go earlier" for present and future
"should have gone earlier" for past

You shouldn't have cheat on the next test.

2020-07-28 04:31:32 UTC

Rizki Putrawan

rizkiputrawan — 2020-07-28 04:33:27 UTC

Marcellus Deo

2020-07-28 04:33:43 UTC

"should go earlier " in future time. "should have gone earlier" in past time

Rizki Putrawan

rizkiputrawan — 2020-07-28 04:33:53 UTC

should go earlier= present or future
should have gone earlier= past

Benediktus Wahyu K.

2020-07-28 04:35:05 UTC

You should have to study now.

benedict saviola

2020-07-28 04:35:06 UTC

you shouldn't play game too much

Rizki

rizkiputrawan — 2020-07-28 04:35:59 UTC

dicky

2020-07-28 04:36:22 UTC

should to shoulf itu memebrikan nasehat yang sedang terjadi sedangkan should have gone itu untuk memberikan nasehat untuk waktu dlu/ yang sudah terjadi tetapi tidak dilaksanakan

Edbert Gaynell Alrich Junawan

2020-07-28 04:36:59 UTC

You shouldn't have cheat on the next test.

Felix Paramarta

2020-07-28 04:37:08 UTC

you shouldn"t go out in midnight

2020-07-28 04:37:25 UTC

You shouldn’t playing games in class meet

Richardus Arlo A

2020-07-28 04:37:59 UTC

Should go earlier is for future.
Should have gone earlier is for past, when it already happened.

Rafael Jodhi Kapitan

rafaeljodhi — 2020-07-28 04:38:28 UTC

It isnt ethical, we shouldnt buy things here

Noverio Sandi

2020-07-28 04:38:32 UTC

Edbert Gaynell Alrich Junawan

2020-07-28 04:38:44 UTC

The different between should go earlier and should have gone earlier is if they said you should go earlier it is an advice they give to you but if they say you should have gone earlier its mean that time on the past you should be going earlier.

Rafael Jodhi Kapitan

rafaeljodhi — 2020-07-28 04:39:12 UTC

I think we should go to the gas stasion, because the fuel meter is going to E.

benedict saviola

2020-07-28 04:39:45 UTC

should go earlier: for the future
should have gone earlier : for past

Felix paramarta

2020-07-28 04:40:12 UTC

You should go earlier=Present Future
You have gone earlier=Past

Rafael Jodhi Kapitan

rafaeljodhi — 2020-07-28 04:41:48 UTC

You should not late for the test tomorrow.

Gerald Arva Kristanto

2020-07-28 04:42:30 UTC

You shouldn't sleep in the classroom

Alfonsus N

2020-07-28 04:56:27 UTC

It isn't ethical. We shouldn't buy things here.

Gerald Arva Kristanto

2020-07-28 05:02:56 UTC

Should be used to provide advice, suggestions, used for present tense and future forms.

Should have been used in combination with perfect infinitive. Used to talk about things in the past that did not happen.

Benediktus Wahyu K.

2020-07-28 05:09:06 UTC

You shouldn't read a books

Putu Ardana

2020-07-28 05:22:09 UTC

Benediktus Wahyu K.

2020-07-28 05:22:50 UTC

Should go earlier for in the present and future time. And, Should have gone earlier for the past time.

Rafael Jodhi Kapitan

rafaeljodhi — 2020-07-28 05:27:04 UTC

Should go earlier is for future and continues because from verb "go" is a verb 1

Should have gone erliar is for past becaus from verb "Gone" it is the form of go in verb 3.

Putu Ardana

2020-07-28 05:28:20 UTC

you should have told him that he is adopted, he is old enough to know the truth.

you shouldn't be to hard on him, he is just a child.

2020-07-28 05:30:54 UTC

Putu Ardana

2020-07-28 05:33:17 UTC

"should go earlier" <- present and future time
"should have gone earlier" <- past time

Noverio Sandi

2020-07-28 13:05:43 UTC

Albertus Dandin

2020-07-28 14:13:27 UTC

I should have added English vocabulary a long time ago(

dora

paulinarian — 2020-07-28 14:42:34 UTC