Do Now 11/12 LLG by Veronica Csak https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x en-us 2021-11-12 12:52:02 UTC 2021-11-12 17:51:19 UTC hello@padlet.com Rebekah rebekahfaithsoyigbe https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887179855 Elie had complete rights to lie he is looking out for his people and he knows that if he told stein his family was most likely dead he would have killed himself so he lies to help restore Steins hope and give him some hope as he was obviously losing hope from all the tragedies he was facing.]]> 2021-11-12 17:38:02 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887179855 Eliezer wasn't justified because he's lying to someone about a sensitive topic. Also telling him the truth could have motivated stein to try and get out to honor his family. When stein finds out he was lying this could demotivate him or completely cut ties with Eliezer. Also think of all the tragedies they went through. In conclusion Eliezer wasn't justified for many reasons. jacekingclark https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182237 2021-11-12 17:39:12 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182237 Maya S mayasarr https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182747 Eliezer should tell the truth to Stein. Eliezer is giving false hope to Stein due to his family being separated from him as he stayed in the concentration camp. By Eliezer giving Stein false hope it would could hit Stein harder in the face when he realizes that his family is dead even when he thought they could still be alive.]]> 2021-11-12 17:39:22 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182747 Ethan ethanzapata https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182860 Elie was not justified to lie. That was not his lie to talk about and giving false hope to Stein that just wants his parents back. Now Stein has hope but will never get to see them since there dead.]]> 2021-11-12 17:39:27 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182860 pedropizarro3 https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182947  Eliezer should not tell Stein a lie, he should tell the truth. I say this because if i was Stein i would want to know what happened to my family instead of false hope. Also after Stein finds out his family is dead he is going to be mad at Eliezer for telling him that theirs still hope for his family when he knew they were dead.]]> 2021-11-12 17:39:30 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182947 Nia niahinds https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182991  Eliezer did the right thing by lying to Stein because if he did tell the truth he would of ruined Steins hope.  I think Eliezer did right by lying because it was rare that Jews still had hope even though lying is wrong Eliezer wouldn't have been responsible for ruining another persons hope through what they've been through. ]]> 2021-11-12 17:39:31 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887182991 I think that Eliezier should have told the truth to Stein because that is going to make him more hurt. This is because his family died and when he finds out he is going to feel more hurt because he thought that he could trust Eliezier and instead of telling the truth he lied and gave him false hope. mameboussadiop https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183053 2021-11-12 17:39:33 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183053 Eliezer is justified because with him lying hes keeping everyone's hope and hope is going to keep them from giving up, giving them a slightly better chance survive. laurenhoward11 https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183057 2021-11-12 17:39:33 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183057 aminatakeita1 https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183378 Elie should lie to himself because he has been through so much already in the holocaust. "I no longer felt anything except the lashes of the whip." He took his time between lashes. Only the first really hurt."Elie should lie to himself becuase if he tells the truth he will only get effected more then he has already been. ]]> 2021-11-12 17:39:45 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183378 Eliezer is kind of right for lying because him telling Stein that his family is not alive might make him lose hope and that is what the Nahzis want. They want the Jews to lose hope and have no faith so they can lost their dignity, but by telling him this this will allow him to continue to have hope and strive through. judahwalford https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183391 2021-11-12 17:39:45 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183391 aevalopez https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183491 Eliezer should of been honest. He shouldn't bring hope because Stein's going to have the wrong idea. Also, Eliezer might feel guilty for giving Stein hope that his family's alive. If Eliezer keeps saying his families alive, Stein might find out what actually happened.]]> 2021-11-12 17:39:49 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183491 Elie is justified to lie to Stein giving him false hope beacuase the holocaust is all ready a depressing time so him grieving about his famliy could mentally break him so he is trying give him hope. robertcraig2 https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183632 2021-11-12 17:39:53 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887183632 brycethompson5 https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184054 I feel like Eliezer should have just told Stein the truth. Stein is already worried about his family,and I feel like lying will make the situation worse because he doesn't know if his family is alive and lying to him is not the best idea because he is worried]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:06 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184054 Atiaa atiaaasante https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184168 I think that Elie should have lied.Because when it comes to going into the concentration camp it is very sad.And Stein says in the book that the only reason he is alive is as long as his wife and children are okay.So if he thinks they are okay then he would still try to be alive]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:09 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184168 gabrielperaltarojas https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184448 Eliezer should have not lied because if he told Stein that his family was dead but even though he would be depressed he would know the truth of his families death]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:18 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184448 ꧁ঔৣ☬ΣŇr͢͢͢ΐqմe✞☬ঔৣ꧂ https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184491 Eliezer should have been honest because lying in a Jewish place / environment will be wrong. Also this will also lead to bad relationship wit parents.]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:20 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184491 Nina ninavalentin https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184550 I don't think Eliezer should have lied. Logically, it doesn't make sense. Giving people false hope is cruel and it's better to just face the truth. It will cause more psychological damaged this way.]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:22 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184550 saliou salioumbow https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184603 it is justtified becuse elie wwants stein to stay alive becuse he knows it is the only thing keeping them alive rigth now and he want that to go on ]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:24 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184603 Osvaldo osvaldogonzalez https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184732 Eliezer was in the right for telling Stein a lie instead of telling him the truth. Stein family was the only thing that keeps him feel hopeful. If Stein Knew that his family was killed he would lose hope and give up on trying to stay alive. Eliezer was just trying to make Stein feel good

]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:30 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184732 Jazaire https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184735 Eliezer should be completely honest because giving him false hope can effect him]]> 2021-11-12 17:40:30 UTC https://padlet.com/veronicacsak/phvfk5r5z8lsib3x/wish/1887184735