Edward Tulane Ch. 15-16 Discussion Question by Andy Hedin https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12 Why does Edward not find comfort in the stars anymore? en-us 2017-05-24 16:16:41 UTC 2017-06-01 16:49:02 UTC hello@padlet.com Ch. 15-16 E.T Discussion Question: Dean#28 :) https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696614 I think that Edward does not find comfort in the stars anymore because he has no hope and is tired of being alone and thinking negative thoughts. I think Abilene would comfort him now and he knows that he didn’t love her and he should fix his mistake and he would be happy with her with her calling him his own name too.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:07 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696614 AHMAD https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696684 I think happy thought of his old owners will make him happy. He will think of all of the good times and not the bad times. He will be how he was when Bull and Lucy were his owners.]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:26 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696684 Cooper # 20 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696713 I think he can not find comfort in stars anymore is because when he is looking at the stars he is always in a bad situation. And because the stars remind him of Pelligrina. I think Edward will find confert in a girl that Bryce takes him to and he will find confert in her squizing him.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:33 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696713 Grace Duty's answer to 15-16 discussion question https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696751 I think Edward does not find comfort in the stars anymore because he has given up hope. Why find comfort in something if you have given up all hope?
I think Edward will be happy with Bryce
]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:43 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696751 Angelina https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696753 I think that since Edward doesn’t find comfort in the stars anymore, he finds comfort in being held tightly. Bryce brings Edward to a girl and the girl holds him in a way that seems to comfort Edward. ]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:43 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696753 Eden Mcgraw's DQ answer ; ) https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696758 I think it is because Edward feels sad that he never loved Abilene and he thinks he has lost all hope. I think he will find comfort in the birds. 
; ) 
 # 1]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:44 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696758 Josh joshtiano https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696765 I think Edward doesn’t find comfort in the stars anymore because he knows Pellegrina is in the stars somewhere so he doesn’t like them anymore. I think Abilene will comfort him. Edward felt guilty that he did not love Abilene enough so only she will comfort him.


]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:47 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696765 Tyler Starling https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696785 I do not think he finds comfort anymore with the stars because he is not back to loving someone again because no one has loved him again yet.  I think what will comfort him now is that he is off the pole and hopefully Bryce starts loving him and he gets to love the stars again.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:36:52 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696785 Addi Reyes :D https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696841 I think Edward does not find comfort in the stars because he is like “ What's the point My heart's been broken so many times, I am not getting back with Abilene, Bull and Lucy, Nellie and Lawrence so what's the point to have faith anymore” What I think Edward will find comfort in is his previous owners and the good times he had with them.


]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:04 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696841 Alex's Answer :D alexahause2307 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696885 I don’t think he finds comfort in the stars because he doesn’t care about anything any more. If he doesn’t care about anything, he clearly doesn’t care about stars. Stars are things, so he doesn’t care about them, Soooo, he doesn’t find comfort in them. Also, I think that Bryce will bring him to his little sister. Then, she will make hi a pair of plastic wings. When he puts them on, they will comfort him.
 

]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:15 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696885 David.Bamm XD #2 Ch. 15-16 Edward Tulane https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696888  I think it does not comfort him because when he is loved the stars comfort him but since everyone always loses him or throws him away he does not find comfort or sometimes he does not care about love like when he was with Abliene. I also think the people who had loved him comfort him because he would think of them and remember either what good did they do to you or songs, stories.
 
  

]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:15 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696888 Christabelle https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696896 I think Edward does not find comfort in the Stars anymore because I think he just feels lonely now since he keeps getting lost from everyone he loves. Now I just don't think he finds comfort and anything. When the old lady put him on that pole he had nothing but the clothes and so now I just think he's disappointed and sad. I think it's because he's lonely because when he was with Abilene he was treated so well and then with Nelly and Lawrence he was also treated well and then was Bull and Lucy he was also treated well and now we show alone with no one. 

]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:17 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696896 Quinn https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696910    I think Edward has no interest in the stars because he has looked at the stars many times and they haven’t helped him in times of need even though they comforted him. I think Bryce will comfort him now because he seems very nice and has a personality a lot like how Edward’s personality is now. 
 


]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:19 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696910 Pablo Shiloah #23 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696936  He probably does not find comfort in the stars anymore because there are so many things that he loves and regrets, he realizes that the stars have been guiding him through his life. He will probably take comfort in recognizing the people who loved him and trying to forgive for what he did wrong.]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:24 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696936 Lyri Tayeb lyritayeb1907 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696975 I think Edward doesn’t find comfort in the stars  because he gets scared from them. Now he likes the wings.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:34 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173696975 katelyn TREVINO https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697010 I think that he thinks of how he was nailed onto a pole. That is why he finds no comfort with the stars.i think that kids will comfort him because a little kid found him and got him out. 

]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:43 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697010 Jayden;) https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697073  I think that Edward is now not comforted in the stars anymore because him thinking of Abilene comforts Edward more.  I think Abilene will comfort him now.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:37:56 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697073 Miriam Gygax miriagygax5307 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697178 Listening changes Edward because it enables him to find out what people are like and be able to love them. It also makes him happier because he makes others happy.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:38:14 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697178 Cole https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697336 I think that Edward does not find comfort
 in the stars anymore because  he has lost belief in everything now because he feels that everyone he gets will just go away from him so there is no reason to try that is why he doesn't find comfort in the stars I think he is also going to find comfort in Brice next because Brice is the one who saved him and made him start to feel good again so he will decide to like him more

]]> 2017-05-24 18:38:49 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697336 maja https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697366 I Edward does not find comfort in the stars anymore because he is all alone and the stars all together and also the stars don't love there just there.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:38:57 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697366 Brody Matheisen:) https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697488 I think Edward does not find comfort in the stars because he doesn’t really care about anyone and thinks that the stars were being rude to him. I think what would comfort him now is him seeing and finally being with Abilene again.

]]> 2017-05-24 18:39:32 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173697488 Sydney :) https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173698121 I think Edward does not find comfort in the stars anymore because the stars reminded him of all the people who loved him, and how he didn’t get to say goodbye to them. I think if Edward says the names of the people who loved him, that would comfort him instead of the stars.]]> 2017-05-24 18:42:14 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173698121 John https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173698309 2017-05-24 18:43:03 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173698309 My Answer ahedin https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173698934 I think Edward does not find comfort in the stars anymore because he has changed as a "person". He is learning what love is and how to care about people. Stars don't comfort him anymore because he can't love something that is so far away. I think Edward can only find comfort in being loved by other people and loving them back.]]> 2017-05-24 18:46:23 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173698934 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173699575 2017-05-24 18:49:57 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173699575 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173699581 2017-05-24 18:49:58 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173699581 https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173699594 2017-05-24 18:50:02 UTC https://padlet.com/ahedin/pb64sax1wf12/wish/173699594