https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk Was the United States justified in taking the Native Americans land that they had been living on for hundreds of years and relocating them somewhere else? [ Period 2 Class ] Minimum response 3 - 4 sentences. You must also respond/comment on at least 3 other people's responses. *** Put your first name, last initial as title to your response. en-us 2019-01-27 22:55:39 UTC 2019-03-05 21:29:50 UTC hello@padlet.com 25bhallgren https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392579 The Americans were not justified in taking this land from the Native Americans.  As the chief of the Shawnee tribe says, "The white people  have no right to take this land from the Indians, because the Indians had it first." Manifest Destiny is the belief that we had this right, and is not listed in Bill Of Rights. The Native Americans had settled on this land for thousands of years and had claimed this land before the Europeans had came to America. If this was agreed with by the Native Americans, than this would be okay, but the Europeans went and killed all of them. In conclusion, the Americans were wrong in taking the Native's land.]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:25 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392579 25adunay https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392583 I believe the Americans (colonists) were NOT justified. I believe this because they were taking away the Native American's land. The Native Americans had been living on that land for thousands of years. The Americans (colonists) had not been there for more than 50 years at most and were taking the Native American's land. In my opinion, that was unjustified, perhaps even unconstitutional!]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:25 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392583 https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392611 I don't believe the americans were justified to take the Idians space.  The americans just took up all there land.  The idians had it first.  The americans weren't even fair to the idians.  They would of probalty just of killed them. The americans were just caring about what would be good for they country and the didnt care about other countries. The idians had there land for probaly 100 years. It was totally not write for the americans to take all there land]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:28 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392611 25nwexler https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392654 No the United States was not right in kicking out the Native Americans to go west. This was rude because when it became part of the states the Native Americans lived there for years and years and they should have the right to stay there. They were doing very well with everything. How would you feel if your ancestors made the land and someone comes and steals it away from you. That is not right at all. America made this bad decision that changed the lives of people. ]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:32 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392654 https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392672 I think the United States was correct taking the Native Americans land. I think this because from this we gained more population and more land for people. The Expansion helped us with the young U.S to make it great.

]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:33 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392672 25zkeenan https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392714 I believe the United states and the native americans were put in a very unjustified place. Instead of trying to form a bond with the Natives, they instead had tried to get them to leave. This, I believe, would be a very heinous crime. Though, the Americans had bought the land, which made them now own the land. How were the Americans supposed to know the natives were there before they bought the land? Did France know these people lived on the land? So in all, I believe both sides could have worked a settlement out, but that did not happen, as blood was spilt in wars Natives and Americans. ]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:36 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392714 25aavella https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392733 What i think the right thing to do was to make diffrenet states but let the native americans stay there. I only think that they should stay because they have been on that land for over 100 of years. It is unfair for the Indians who were there longer. I know that if this was me and i was the Indian i would not give up with out a fight because that would be unfair. I think that america was wrong to be taking away these people land i think that since we took there land that then they could live in it. ]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:39 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392733 25bfischer https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392745 The United states was not complety justified in taking land from the Native Americans. The Americans wanted to expand outwards, but the area was ocupied by many Native Americans, the Amercans wanted to make their country bigger to have more natural resources and more land for farms and people. As the Americans expanded outwards, the number of Native American tribes and villages decreased. From this, the Americans gained more land but also took away from Native Americans.]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:40 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392745 25ostokes https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392746 I think that the United States was not  justified because the United States took the land away from the Native American. The Native Americans wouldn't be able to have property because the United States would just take the Native Americans land. The United States did a bad thing to the Native Americans. ]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:40 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392746 25ggaub https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392759 The United States wasn't justified in taking the Native Americans land because, what happens if the United States takes the land from the Native Americans? The Native Americans would not be able to have their own property without the United States taking their stuff/land. In my opinion I think that it just wasn't right for the United States to take the Native Americans land because that is like someone coming into your house saying that they are going to be taking your house. Which isn't right, if they want to just live their life in peace. 


]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:41 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392759 25milluzzi https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392760 In my personal opinion I think that the United states were right in taking the Native Americans land because even though the Natives were there first the Young United states had to grow. The New land would provide the US with many resources and lots of land for farmers to expand their land. The Young Unites states had lots or resources and they needed more so that everyone could stay happy and healthy. The Native Americans could have just stayed on the land because they were really nice and they made many items that were really useful. The US had many reasons for buying this land and The Natives  could have just simply stayed.]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:41 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392760 25lhernandezbarrient https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392765 I think the United states made a good decision taking the Native Americans land. I believe this was the right thing to do because from this decision we gained more population and more territory for people that now live here. Therefore the Expansion helped us with the young U.S to make it great. ]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:41 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392765 https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392801 It wasn't the right thing for the Americans to push the Indians out of their land that they were at first. The Americans can't just take others peoples land. The Americans made the Indians lived somewhere else, more west.]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:45 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392801 25tfragoso https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392807 I don't think it was fair for us to just take the native Americans property without them allowing us to, if I was a native american I would be mad for somebody to just walk into my land that I have been living on for 200 hundred years and just say"this is our land you have to relocate.  I get why they did it but they really shouldn't of done it because it is an unfair way for us to get more land, maybe instead of kicking them out they could just make a compromise and share the land so then the U.S. would expand and nobody would get kicked out.]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:45 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392807 25saboudaoud https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392955 I think that the United States was not justified in taking the Native Americansland that they had been living on for hundreds of years and making then relocate them somewhere else because they were here first and I think that we just pushing them out isn't fair to them. I think that we should have found other land so that we didn't seem like we were just pushing them away. We shouldn't have made them find another place to settle because we could have found another place and just have left them alone.]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:58 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392955 25smarinaro https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392961 I dont think the United States was right to go and take the Native Americans land from us becuase the Native Americans have probably had that land for hundreds of years and for them to just take that land from them. That's just not fair, the indians had it first so they have the right to keep that land for themselves. Just imagine havving your home and everywhere you know taken away from you and then having to leave, and you can't come back.]]> 2019-01-29 14:23:59 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325392961 25smorrison https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325393244 I do not think the United States were right in taking the land of the Native Americans. They have been living there for hundreds of years. Now they have to move to another place to live that could be miles away. The land that they move to might not have the enough food or water to live.  ]]> 2019-01-29 14:24:25 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325393244 25napostle https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325393286 The Americans should have let the Indians share the land with them because they had it way before them. You can't just make someone move out of a house because you want it that's not how it works. The Indains were all ready settled and had their villages built and the Americans came and destroyed it and made them leave. You can't just take peoples rights and make them leave their villages.

]]> 2019-01-29 14:24:29 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325393286 25cperfetto https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325393414 I think that is wasn't the right thing to do because that was there home and they liked it there. they were used to that land and now they have to move to another piece of land. they can't just take there land when there living there and just take were there livin and move them some where else]]> 2019-01-29 14:24:42 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325393414 25jmiceli https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325398355 I think that the Americans were right in taki]]> 2019-01-29 14:32:38 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325398355 25adunay https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325399296 I think that the Americans were right in taking the land from the native Americans because the Americans bought the land it was their land but i think they could have shared it with the native Americans or reloaded some of them. The Americans should have kept the native Americans friend because they had very good survival tactics and they had lots of goods that could benefit the united states. ]]> 2019-01-29 14:34:10 UTC https://padlet.com/paul_levesque1_1/p2aqvxvnj4rk/wish/325399296