https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4 Made with a wink and a smile en-us 2018-03-20 18:38:04 UTC 2018-03-20 19:05:03 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244214939 - Does very well explaining their roles.
- Jaden explains his points very well with facts to support it.
- Eugenio does a very nice job of giving an example of if adults get remarried. 
- Jaden does a really nice job summarizing what Eugenio said. 
- Ty does a really nice job siting his source when he was talking about having 2 parents helps you later in life. 
- Issac brings up a good point about a mother can help their kids with their emotions. 
- Eugenio does a really nice job being clear with his questions or when he answers question.
- Jaden does a really well with refocusing on the main points.
- Ben does a really well going back to his points on having  a mom or not having a mom.
-  They all do a very nice job inviting everyone into the discussion about having another mom.
- Ben does a very nice job going back to the criteria before they for sure decide what mom they would want.

]]> 2018-03-20 18:39:54 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244214939 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215017 I noticed that Jaden had supporting details about his point of view which was important. Ben is good at asking questions and keeping the discussion going and asking the other people about what their opinions are. Eugenio I noticed had good eye contact and had good supporting details. I noticed that the entire group is having a good discussion with equal participation within the group. They do good with asking each other questions and putting other people into the discussion. They all have good facts and statistics that back up their points. I noticed that the group refers to others opinions and want what is best as a whole not just individually which is a good way to go about things. I noticed that they did go through all the steps and conclude to a single one that they all agreed upon, this discussion was very well done and seemed like they all came to a conclusion that they were happy with without leaving anyone out.]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:01 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215017 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215071 -They really thought about what each of their roles include.
-They do a good job discussing, not just stating what they want.
-Ty and Eugene have good statistics
-They do a good job on including eachother
-They did a good job on trying to be equal]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:06 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215071 18776 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215174 Good job with equally talking the same amount and equal amount of content. Everyone receives an equal chance to state their opinion. Everyone in the discussion is engaged in the conversation or person speaking. Everyone also clearly states their opinion, regardless of what others in the group believe. Good questioning, answering, and clarifying is exhibited. Also nice referring back to previous things group members have said when asking questions or making points. All do a nice job sticking to their group rolls in the family.]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:15 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215174 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215248 2018-03-20 18:40:21 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215248 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215275 I don't really see much eye contact, rather than Eugenio. Jaden continues with discussion by going off of Isaac. Jaden helps the discussion flow nicely by asking questions. They do a nice job on supporting their points by citing from their sources. They each have a good equal time to talk about their points. They brainstorm about their possible really well. They don't just chose a candidate out of random, they actually say the pros and cons of each candidate. They go over criteria. Ben does a great job on moving the discussion. ]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:23 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215275 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215301 *The whole group didnt have a main speaker. Instead, they all took turns going around and talking and bringin gup their points 
*Whole group is lacking eye contact
*The whole group has a nice structure, Meaning they all a very prepared and there isnt any log awkward silences
*Jaden has good stats and is able to back up his point with important information
*Eugenio asks very good questions. Also goes in depth while talk
*Ty makes eye contact and asks questions. Very nice sources
*Ben has very strong points and standards. Goes into depth and makes his ppoint clear
*Isaac Has strong opinions about what mom her wants. Tends to make eye contact through out the talk.]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:24 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215301 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215309 - Ben does a good job with asking everyone their opinion on what they want they want for a potential mom
-Jaden refers to one of his texts when backing up his point about having a new mom  
- They do a good job with having an equal amount of participation in the  discussing 
- Ty refers to texts and sites his source about being a child of two parents and how having more than one parent they influence your life choices. 
-Issac the mother tends to more of the emotional support to a child verses having just a father figure in your life to help you meet the goals in your life.
-Issac asks Jaden his opinion on having a step mother? 
-Eugene does a nice job on giving specific examples from his articles about children to single parents tend to most likely do drugs or go by a dangerous pathway.
-Ben refers to the text about characteristics about the certain mothers and considers the good personality traits of a mother and explains why they are a good fit as a mother 
Issac- does a good job explaining why older children feel the need to to not have a mother because, they are fully developed and a little more mature and more grown up and, the younger children should have a mother to help them grow more as an individual. 
-Refers back to their criteria to help establish who is the best fit mother to all five of them
-They all have an understanding to all the steps of Dewey's 
- they summarized the key points that were made]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:25 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215309 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215338 Good discussion 
Good points
On topic
They are asking each other a lot of questions which helps us fully understand each of their points
Notes are good
The conversation never really got boring 
Sounds more like a conversation rather than something that was scripted beforehand. 
Acts as the roles were true to their personalities 
Went above and made profiles for 5 different "moms" 
Compromised ]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:28 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215338 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215362 I don't see much eye contact. 
I like that it's a back and forth discussion. 
I heard a lot of good sources and evidence. 
I like the two question discussion of if they should get a new mom and which mom they should choose.

]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:30 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215362 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215484 Jaden-where did you get that information from? Sources? good job on taking charge 
Issac-used sources! good points about having a mother as a child i like how you asked questions about the topic to the guys 
Ben- making good points good info
Eugenio- i like the eye contact you are putting your point out there and looking at everyone 
Ty-i like that you used your sources,  
good topic 
use sources 
very well though threw good topic ]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:43 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215484 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215528 Jaden- Very strong about is criteria and respectfully disagreed with his "siblings" and explained why. 
Issac- Politely disagreed and did a good job showing his points. 
Ben- Did a good job asking questions. 
Eugenio- Doesn't have as strict of rules and is open to ideas. Has good statistics. 
Ty-  had good points of why he wants a mom. 
Everyone- They all did a good job speaking the same amount of time and nobody really led the discussion, the all participated.  Everyone was on topic. People were open to suggestions, and were willing to suggestions.

]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:48 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215528 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215603 -Discuses each criteria thoroughly asked
-Made sure everything was clarified
-Stated a fact then elaborated on it to make the point clear
-Everyone is involved in the conversation
-They are all prepared with notes
-Has Women as options even though there is a lot more people out there
-If Sydney is busy how is she supposed to play sports and do "boyish" things with the kids.
-They would just make their dad go on a date with one of these women
You don''t have to get married to have a mother-like a figure she could just be the dads girlfriend


]]> 2018-03-20 18:40:56 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215603 59188 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215679 -I noticed that they stated one thing and had others opinions then moved to a new fact/question
-I like that it's an actual discussion not just making statements 
-They should've use more eye contact
-I really like when they refer or question what the others say]]> 2018-03-20 18:41:04 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215679 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215714 -Not much eye contact to each other. 
Jaden- Cited source
Eugenio- cited source.
Ben-
Issac-
Ty- cited source
Invite each other into conversation. Good facts from sources but do not have much statistics or other facts to help prove the original fact. could have perhaps started with the candidates and then talked about whether they want a mother or not. I would like to see the characteristics to the mothers more than loving, hardworking, etc. what are the bigger personalities. I think that Eugenio and Jaden(?) are over powering the discussion a little bit and not letting the others talk. Chose a person and brought it back to the main question to make sure it fit the criteria. Had good appropriate humor to the conversation. Good way of figuring out how to fix the problem. wish more discussion from Ty. less from Eugenio and Jaden(?). I know the story roles but what were their discussion roles, who was the time keeper and such. questions posed.]]> 2018-03-20 18:41:08 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215714 187113 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215757 -Good with going through each step and being prepared for the discussion. 
-All are involved in the discussion 
-Could pay attention to others more while they are speaking. 
-Good job with asking questions to help with others participation. 
-A lot of textual evidence  
-I like how they Talk as if they are having a conversation not a presentation
-Good with figuring out a solution that fits the criteria ]]> 2018-03-20 18:41:10 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215757 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215857 made it more as a discussion/conversation rather than assigned talking
Jaden
- no eye contact
- reading voice
- comfortable tone
Ben
- asked questions
- good tone
- some eye contact
Eugenio
- "comfortable" talking voice
- good info
- no actual sources(all)
Ty
- uses a source
- should talk louder
Isaac
- good volume
- uses a good source
- ]]> 2018-03-20 18:41:20 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244215857 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244216138 I liked Jaden's Ideas but I think he needs to established his criteria and decide what would be best for his family considering he is the oldest he should hold a strong censorship with deciding the best for them. Not being relaxed and not caring. Although he is not the one caring for her because his dad is marrying her he should still feel like this is the best. I like how Jaden also rebuttals others arguments it help to bring more depth to the conversation.  I like how Jaden considers although he knows that the new mother isn't going to be like the new mother they want a nice lady who they know they can trust. ]]> 2018-03-20 18:41:51 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244216138 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244219600 -overall good work giving all participants in the discussion an equal time speaking and paying attention to the points addressed by the others
-i liked how everyone made sure to  bring in their textual evidence early on when addressing and analyzing the problem
-jaden did a good job asking questions
-all were bringing good counter arguments to the table and being respectful of other's views at the same time

]]> 2018-03-20 18:47:53 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244219600 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244220332 I think the Eugenio has good points and has more of a developed idea of what is best for his family. He seems to also have a lot of data based on what a good mother looks like and would be like. I really like all of there arguments but I think they have to also consider what the father would want also not just what them want. I think it is great that he wants a mom that is both hard working as well as caring because that is crucial for a mother. They want to be happy with her. ]]> 2018-03-20 18:49:08 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244220332 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244222841 -Ty seemed to do a really good job of bringing his sources up when countering or responding to questions
-I can tell a lot of hard work was put into the discussion, it seemed to be very well thought out and lots of details were included
-I liked how although they were very well practiced, they still seemed to bring up countering arguments throughout the time which is very good because it is supposed to be an active discussion]]> 2018-03-20 18:53:05 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244222841 https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244223050 I think that Ty has a big role in this argument because he is the youngest he will be pending the most time with the new mom. I think that he has a large say in the women that the father chooses. Ty needs factors of caring and love because he is most likely going to be around her the most. ]]> 2018-03-20 18:53:27 UTC https://padlet.com/amymettlach/oveg8a2wabf4/wish/244223050