Critiquing Treatment Fidelity by Rae Walker, PhD RN FAAN (they/them) https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3 Based on the article by Lavoie & Dube on a nurse-led intervention involving motivational interviewing. Please add your contributions below! en-us 2021-04-24 17:39:42 UTC 2021-05-04 02:55:10 UTC hello@padlet.com Was the problem clearly stated & well-justified? r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454970914 2021-04-24 17:53:54 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454970914 Intervention Theory r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454971309 Was theory underlying the design of the intervention made explicit? ]]> 2021-04-24 17:54:14 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454971309 Was the overarching Goal of the Intervention, and associated Objectives/Aims well-explained? r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454974333 2021-04-24 17:56:36 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454974333 r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454975753 Was the theory appropriate for this research context? ]]> 2021-04-24 17:57:42 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454975753 r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454976126 And was there any way their presentation of the theory and its role in guiding the study have been improved or made clearer? ]]> 2021-04-24 17:57:58 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454976126 And was it clear this problem/target for intervention was one that the study population saw as a priority? r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454976513 2021-04-24 17:58:16 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454976513 r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454976911 Did they flow from the theory and problem? ]]> 2021-04-24 17:58:34 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454976911 r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454977111 Were key intervention components/activities described for each of the objectives/aims, & did they seem reasonable/well-justified?]]> 2021-04-24 17:58:42 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454977111 Enhancement r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454978753 How did the research team enhance the likelihood that the intervention they proposed would be delivered as described? Did they use a treatment manual, interview guide or other means?]]> 2021-04-24 18:00:05 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454978753 Monitoring r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454980724 Did the research team describe methods by which to MONITOR the design, delivery, receipt, and enactment of each component of the intervention?]]> 2021-04-24 18:01:40 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454980724 Measurement r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454982766 Did the research team describe specific PROCESS measures for the design, delivery, receipt and enactment of their intervention?]]> 2021-04-24 18:03:16 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454982766 Matching Aims r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454985270 Did the outcome variables the team measured match the purpose & aims of their study?]]> 2021-04-24 18:05:08 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454985270 Match with Theory r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454985938 Did the outcome variables the team measured line up with the theory underlying the research? ]]> 2021-04-24 18:05:34 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454985938 Appropriate? r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454986763 Did the outcome measures for this pilot study appear appropriate? Briefly note any strengths or limitations in terms of validity (or trustworthiness); reliability and completeness. ]]> 2021-04-24 18:06:13 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454986763 r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454988745 How well did researchers capture and describe the costs associated with this intervention (in terms of time, labor, cost-effectiveness, cost-benefit, etc.)?]]> 2021-04-24 18:07:45 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454988745 Power r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454989772 How was power attended to in this research?]]> 2021-04-24 18:08:33 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454989772 Ethics r_walker6 https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454989993 Was this research ethical and were appropriate steps taken to protect the safety well-being and privacy of study volunteers?]]> 2021-04-24 18:08:45 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1454989993 Cost was not detailed in this study although I anticipate it was a significant consideration given 5 x week visits by the RN to each participant. It would be interesting to repeat the study on a broader scope and apply both a CBA an CEA https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1487633801 2021-05-04 00:12:48 UTC https://padlet.com/r_walker6/ohxu4dnv3zzf6zc3/wish/1487633801