4A Socratic Seminar Outer Circle by Natalie Lopez

Michael's question was actually really nice, and i've never even thought of The Rules like that.

28santiagoj — 2025-10-22 17:25:15 UTC

28spigelmoyerj — 2025-10-22 17:27:01 UTC

John explains why Will doesn't think it's a good idea to go through with the plan, because he explained how Will realizes that revenge has led to so many people close to him dying.

28connord2 — 2025-10-22 17:28:16 UTC

connor said something and really helped me place my self in hamlets shoes and got me thinking on how hamlet felt and why he acted how he did

28travise — 2025-10-22 17:28:25 UTC

Sam made a good point on how people do revenge due to their emotions.

28ramosn — 2025-10-22 17:28:33 UTC

I think Jerlin's point about revenge usually being in an irrational state of mind was very interesting.

2025-10-22 17:28:53 UTC

Michael made a good statement about revenge for a close member.

28connord2 — 2025-10-22 17:29:33 UTC

John really explained well on how revenge rippling effects work and made me understand how taking revenge hurts a lot more people than just the person your taking revenge on and their family.

2025-10-22 17:29:34 UTC

I think Jon made a good statement about how revenge is like a virus.

28rodriguezacostaj — 2025-10-22 17:29:36 UTC

Michaels response relating to how a father giving his son insight on how to take revenge made me relate a lot more to how Hamlet felt knowing I would do the same thing I think his response was really well thought out.

28smithh6 — 2025-10-22 17:29:39 UTC

I liked what Jerlin said about how the idea that revenge clouds your judgement. I think revenge is too influenced by emotion in a sense too.

2025-10-22 17:30:11 UTC

Jerlin used good evidence to back up what she said.

28spigelmoyerj — 2025-10-22 17:30:18 UTC

I like how Jerlin explained how revenge can lead to irrational thoughts.

28smithh6 — 2025-10-22 17:31:00 UTC

I like how Sam acknowledged the fact that we don't fully feel as satisfied as we did in the moment after we've cleared our mind.

I liked what jarrett said about wanting revenge never fully leaving

28betetahernandezm — 2025-10-22 17:31:05 UTC

28travise — 2025-10-22 17:31:08 UTC

I liked Genesis's point on how people don't think before they make their own decisions.

Jein responded to Jarretts question good on cycles of violence among communities

28alvaradom — 2025-10-22 17:32:11 UTC

28rodriguezacostaj — 2025-10-22 17:32:13 UTC

I Like how jerlin brought up how the direct result of revenge is more or less always going to be consequences. It was a very important question to ask especially for this topic

28ramosn — 2025-10-22 17:32:28 UTC

I think John's question about the comparison between Laertes and Hamlet's revenge was interesting and formulated well

2025-10-22 17:33:20 UTC

I liked michaels question regarding about if there is a time or place for revenge.

28spigelmoyerj — 2025-10-22 17:33:42 UTC

Micheal had a good question about if Hamlet got his revenge earlier, would the consequences have been worse, or less?

28betetahernandezm — 2025-10-22 17:37:36 UTC

I enjoyed how sam explored the idea of no one stopping hamlets actions

2025-10-22 17:38:53 UTC

I like sams point about Will starting to doubt whether he should still take revenge as more of the ghosts start to visit and talk to him.

2025-10-22 17:39:30 UTC

I liked how Jon explained what would have happened if Hamlet and Will switched places.

W

28lynchj — 2025-10-22 17:45:23 UTC

Daniel son's question was very pretty just like him and had a very in depth question that should cause a lot of in depth answers

28toscanom — 2025-10-22 17:45:27 UTC

I like the point about that people use their emotions to justify their revenge.

2025-10-22 17:46:03 UTC

Max's question was very thought provoking

I liked what Max asked about relating the stories situation back into your own life and what you would do.

2025-10-22 17:46:10 UTC

W

28lynchj — 2025-10-22 17:46:31 UTC

I think Micheal did have a very good point but couldn't express what he truly wanted to express

28franciscoj — 2025-10-22 17:46:51 UTC

I think Micheal's point on the different types of revenge can vary and depending on what people do the consequences vary.

I like Naelyn's point that when people take revenge it is more for them and not the people around them, or who they're getting revenge for.

28gonzalezg — 2025-10-22 17:47:04 UTC

2025-10-22 17:47:26 UTC

I like Joe's point on how Hamlet could have proved Claudius' crimes to others

I agree with Naelyn that if someone is taking revenge for me even though I'm dead, they're just wanting that feeling of satisfaction for themselves.

28jiangc1 — 2025-10-22 17:47:33 UTC

I agree with what Michael said because I feel that if someone is taking revenge, but isn't doing something crazy it would have less consequences, but if it is something crazier like killing someone that isn't okay.

2025-10-22 17:48:03 UTC

28toscanom — 2025-10-22 17:48:17 UTC

I like Joe's point that Hamlet could have made people know about what Claudius did to justify his revenge.

28franciscoj — 2025-10-22 17:48:25 UTC

I agree with Naelyn's point about how revenge is mainly for selfish reasons and people only really do it for themselves and to make themselves feel better. In reality it's not to help the person who was done wrong.

28kelleyc3 — 2025-10-22 17:48:30 UTC

Naelyn's response to Max's question was very fair, like getting revenge for my death by murdering the person that murdered me is a bit selfish because you are killing another because you're upset that I died, it just isn't right.

I like the question that Michael made, very interesting.

28spezialij — 2025-10-22 17:48:58 UTC

28toscanom — 2025-10-22 17:49:11 UTC

I like how Michael brought a different perspective of revenge. Not the person getting revenge but the victim of revenge.

I like Naelyn's question about getting revenge if that happened to you.

2025-10-22 17:49:28 UTC

I liked Luis's point saying that you may feel satisfied in the moment, but in the long run you won't.

28gonzalezg — 2025-10-22 17:51:16 UTC

I agree with what Luis said because getting revenge may feel good in the moment, but after you may feel worse than before.

2025-10-22 17:52:15 UTC

That's a good question by Luis, good thinking question.

28spezialij — 2025-10-22 17:53:25 UTC

I like Micheal's question on if someone should continue the revenge if it didn't work the first time.

28jiangc1 — 2025-10-22 17:53:26 UTC

28kelleyc3 — 2025-10-22 17:54:23 UTC

I like Michael's question because it's thought-provoking with how if you didn't get to get it right on the first time by trying to take revenge, do you attempt again or take what you can get.