Argument Map-Should America Give Back Land to Native Americans? by Jason George

Should america give back land to Native Americans?

jasongeorge2006 — 2024-11-14 19:47:57 UTC

Provide contextual background behind history of native americans, colonization, land disputes, further conflicts, aftermath, and current res life situation

Source 1: Examine if American sovereignty and treat rights have been undermined by US Federal Policies

jasongeorge2006 — 2024-11-14 19:58:26 UTC

Introduce and let reader conclude if native americans are undermined by federal policies

Evidence

jasongeorge2006 — 2024-11-14 19:59:28 UTC

Case studies, personal accounts, policies

Source 2: "We Want Our Land Back"

jasongeorge2006 — 2024-11-14 20:01:42 UTC

Article describes how Natives deal with land dispossession and how it impacts their daily lives. Good for further interpretation

Question

jasongeorge2006 — 2024-11-14 20:04:07 UTC

Can Native American's find ways to increase standard of living despite land disposession? Question important because it asks if you can still develop by yourselves independent of US Influence (independent society)

Source 3: Land rights,quality, and indigenous poverty

jasongeorge2006 — 2024-11-14 20:11:50 UTC

Explains complexities and importance of returning land to indeginous communities through several dimensions, complexities and cooperations can lead to this not being possible however. Poses final question

Final Question

jasongeorge2006 — 2024-11-14 20:12:52 UTC

Is it worth collaborating with the US to gain stolen land back, or should Native americans find other methods of improving quality of life. Is it worth going through the trouble of trying to collaborate with the US when you can fix the problem by yourself in the same amount of time?