Should Jade be punished for what she had done? What Makes You Say That? by

Mdm Suzanna

suzanna_hashim — 2019-03-27 05:50:20 UTC

Yes. She ____________________.
(example)

Elijah Tan Yong En

2019-03-28 09:18:02 UTC

No.I think that Jade should not be punished as I think everyone deserves a second chance.

Caleb Kwan

2019-03-28 09:57:45 UTC

No. In my opinion, she desereves a second chance to learn from her mistake.

Titus

2019-03-28 10:03:14 UTC

Yes. She committed a crime and should take responsibility for her own actions. She should have thought before she acted.

Ioan lim

2019-03-28 12:58:26 UTC

2019-03-29 06:58:48 UTC

I dunno rly. I hv 2 contradicting ideas: the 1 st one is that she should be punished cuz she did do smith wrong but I do agree that she was actually sorta tricked by her friend and it’s not rly her fault tho ugh she should hv thought b4 she acted

Leong Ho Tim

2019-03-29 07:44:16 UTC

No. It was her first time stealing and she knew that she was wrong. Everybody deserves a second chance in life.

Paxton Chan

2019-03-29 08:26:22 UTC

No. Although she should not have stolen, I think everybody deserves a second chance. She also took the initiative to go to Mrs Hall to offer to wash the windows. This shows that she has responsibility.

Isaac Lim 😜

2019-03-29 08:41:36 UTC

Yes. Stealing is wrong, and she should have thought twice before she stole from the shop.

Zach Low

2019-03-29 08:51:52 UTC

Yes. She knew stealing was wrong but she still did it.

Judah Lee :3

2019-03-29 10:32:41 UTC

No. Jade should DEFINITELY be told off/warned/scolded, but everyone deserves a second chance. Although it was under the influence of Kayley she has no one to blame but herself. Besides it was her choice to steal. BUTTTTT above it all she apologised and helped Mrs Hall by vacuuming the floors. In conclusion Jade should not be punished or sent to jail. Why am I so long-winded ahhhhhh.

Max

2019-03-29 12:50:17 UTC

No. Jade stole, however she apologized and even requested to clean the windows for the shop owner.

Gareth Tong

2019-03-29 12:55:58 UTC

NO! Jane deserves a second chance just like everyone else.I think that she should just be warned and try and adjust her to do the right thing.So she can learn how to change and do the right thing.

Matthew Khoo

2019-03-30 00:08:02 UTC

No.Even if Jane stole, she should still have a second chance to change her character and also influence Kayley to change too

𝓒𝓮𝓭𝓻𝓲𝓬 𝓜𝓸𝓴

2019-03-30 00:11:55 UTC

No. I believe that everything is given a second chance to change her character.
Yes. I think that she has done something wrong and must be disciplined so that Jade would never do it again

Rickson Chen

2019-03-30 04:17:21 UTC

No. I think that Jade deserved a second chance. Everyone makes mistakes and most of the time they are forgiven. For Jade’s case, it is no different.

Zachary Tan De Wei

2019-03-30 05:23:35 UTC

Yes. She knew that stealing was wrong and she should have thought before she acted. Hopefully, with this lesson she will reflect and not repeat this act again.

Isaac oh

2019-03-30 06:55:58 UTC

No.Even though she committed a crime; Jade deserves a second chance like everyone in the world.

Matthew Syn

2019-03-30 07:27:06 UTC

Yes. Jade had committed a crime, so she had no excuse. Her punishment lets her reflect on her actions and understand why she was wrong.

Yes

2019-03-31 01:33:00 UTC

Yes.

2019-03-31 01:33:00 UTC

Ethan Koh

2019-03-31 01:33:00 UTC

Yes. Jane committed a crime, so she should be punished. That way, it would allow her to learn from her mistakes and realise what was the right thing to do.

KDS

2019-03-31 02:23:52 UTC

Yes. Jade should be punished because from what we read she had no apparent excuse to steal anything as she was not poor. And even if she was poor, she did not have to steal. so yea.

ZTME

2019-03-31 02:26:12 UTC

no she should not.she only commited her crime because she saw her friend do it.she deserves a second chance and her deed may allow her friend to also change.

2019-03-31 02:27:01 UTC

no she should not.she only commited her crime because she saw her frien

Christopher Chew

2019-03-31 10:40:26 UTC

Yes.She should be punished so she can learn from her mistakes so she will not steal in the future.

RAHUL DHAWN

2019-03-31 14:34:13 UTC

Yes. Jade should be punished as she is old enough to know that stealing is a crime. Punishing Jade will reinforce the importance of law.

ELZY

2019-04-01 06:50:40 UTC

NO i believe she deserves a second chance .Also she also stole because her friend did it but i believe that she is still in the wrong for committing a crime and stealing something.however i feel she should be more thoughtful and think of the consequences of her actions before committing a crime in the future .i hope she has learnt her lesson and will turn over a new leaf and not steal again.

Elijah Ng

2019-04-01 06:52:21 UTC

No she deserves a second chance as she had apologized and volunteered to clean the windows of the shop as a sign of apology

Michael Cheong No, as Jade only attempted to steal the calculator because Kayley told her it was easy and everyone does it. She also did not try to steal anything else even though the store prices were high and even showed she was truly sorry by vacuuming the carpet for them every afternoon.

2019-04-01 10:35:25 UTC

*My computer does not have Microsoft word, so I used Notepad instead.*
(◉͜ʖ◉)

javius

2019-04-02 12:26:38 UTC

No .even though Jade stole the calculator(which is a wrong deed),she should be given a second chance as she apologised to 'the shop owner'*I forgot the name of the shop owner*and offered to help to...

javius(the continuation)

2019-04-02 12:40:26 UTC

...clean the windows of the shop for the shop owner.

Ethan H

2019-04-02 12:50:48 UTC

Yes,but gently.If Jade is not punished at all,it might give her a wrong mindset that stealing is acceptable.However,she should also not be punished too severely as she apologised and offered to clean the windows of the shop.

2019-04-02 22:26:35 UTC

Yes, even though she heard her friend stealing from a shop, she herself should not have stole the calculator. She committed a crime and I think that she should be scolded

Timothy

2019-04-03 13:49:13 UTC

No.Even though Jade had been tempted by her friend to steal the calculator and she did,she showed her remorse by apologising to the shop owner and offering to clean the windows of the shop.

Jason K

2019-04-03 14:20:22 UTC

Yes, I think she should be punished for her crimes. But she showed remorse for her actions by apologising to the store owner,and offering to vacuum the floor of the store.Furthermore, it was her friend, Kayley who first thought of the idea to steal the calculator. So I think she should only be punished lightly.

luke seetoh

2019-04-04 12:07:19 UTC

No as even though she did wrong she apologised and offered to clean the floor and she was really sorry not to mention that she only considered stealing under her friend's influence of her friend.

Jesse Ong

2019-04-04 12:55:07 UTC

yes she should be punished for her crime.But she regretted doing it by offering to vacuum the floor of the store.It was her friend kayley who persuaded her to steal the black calculator.If Jane were to get punished,it should not be that severe.

Aidan Auyok

2019-04-06 07:07:54 UTC

No as she has already learnt her lesson and regretted committing the crime.

E.W

2019-04-11 08:31:00 UTC

No, because this was her first time shoplifting, unlike Kayley, who had did it multiple times. Jade was also sorry for what she had done, and she only did it under the pressure of Kayley

2019-04-16 11:52:56 UTC

PETER
Yes I do.She must remember not to steal even if her friends tell her to.

Zhikang

2019-04-17 10:01:01 UTC

Yes,since she is old enough,she should know that stealing is a crime and she should be punished for her crime

Daniel Ng

2019-04-17 11:54:57 UTC

Yes.Jade knew that stealing was wrong but she still did it

Nathan Mak

2019-04-17 12:56:04 UTC

Yes.Jane knew that stealing was a crime but she still stole a calculator

Josh Ng

2019-04-17 13:43:25 UTC

yes.She stole a calculator even though she knew stealing was wrong

Riley

2019-04-18 07:58:41 UTC

Yes.even though Kayley told her that "everybody does it" she knew it was wrong.
Timothy Chin still has not told Mr Koh that he stole the staple bullets

OCT

2019-04-18 09:40:25 UTC

Yes.Jane knew it was not right to steal but she still stole

Aaron Lo

2019-04-18 13:08:37 UTC

Yes, as she stole a calculator right under the shopkeeper's nose. YEET P.S. Everyone, Timothy has finally told Mr Koh about(it was in P2)

Caleb Chng

2019-04-19 04:06:29 UTC

Yes as Jade had stolen a calculator and even though she was aware that stealing was wrong, she still stole the calculator. She was also dishonest with the shopkeeper.

2019-04-20 10:37:22 UTC

Yes.Jane should be punished for what see had done. She knew it was wrong but still went to steal the calculator and she lied to the shopkeeper

Marc

2019-04-21 10:16:30 UTC

Yes, Jane knew that stealing is wrong but she still did it. he should be punished.

Isaac

2019-04-21 14:18:52 UTC

Yes. Jade already knew stealing was wrong but she still stole a calculator. She should be punished.

Augustine khoo

2019-04-21 14:20:59 UTC

Yes.As she had already committed a crime by stealing the calculator from the bookstore.Even though,she is still young ,she should still be punished. Hopefully, learning from her mistake and turning over over a new leaf.

Samuel Wong

retiredlt24_email — 2019-04-28 14:03:47 UTC

Yes. She decided to take something that did not belong to her.

Whose here in 2020???

2020-04-02 14:59:27 UTC

Me( AL)