Cluster 1 (coal-centric regions transitioning) by

Cluster 1 (coal-centric regions transitioning) by https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1 T+ 2nd Integration Workshop (1/4) BoG1 en-us 2021-04-26 14:00:58 UTC 2021-05-03 06:56:18 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet-uploads.storage.googleapis.com/1157448439/56af27d0159b00b17d21cfd2c7270884/image_T_.webp Synergies between CS (reporter) GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1459959364 - V. good to depict the changes in real use of coal with events and narrative changes, e.g. Germany example.
- Explore role of EU influencing the transition pathways - But also it can have double-meaning, e.g. but saying 'the responsibility is from somebody else'.
- So the main transition is not about changing the 'energy basis' but about changing the RELATIONSHIPS and self-perception of the regional actors in relationships to their own development, from 'waiting the change to come from outside to being the change'.
- It would be interesting to explore how 'the narrative of inevitability' -both negative or positive' evolve over time.
Temporal dimension in the change of narratives

E.g. narratives - heritage from the past for the narratives: Post-war growth and reconstruction thanks to coal, but started to change in the 60ss - e.g., no competitive, 'efficient coal' to Green Capital. 'End of coal policy' 2005 and end of subsides as trigger.

Changes in industrial identities (e.g., Greek and Italian CS)
History of energy dependence from coal
Formal, functional, and perceptual boundaries do not necessary define the same boundaries
Narration of inevitability from SH with power (e.g., both in Italy and Germany)
Divergent narrative from the locals (e.g., both in Italy and Germany)
Closure of coal mining - Role of EU can be dueal too by saying that it is ' a responsibility of someone else' -
Necessity to map the position of actors along the carbon lock-in -decarbonization continuum and their rationale]]> 2021-04-26 15:06:13 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1459959364 Bosnia and Herzegovina GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460874940 Mainstream narrative:
-
-
Whose narrative? (stakeholders, institutions)
-
-
-

Selected component(s) (Technology, Stakeholders, Institutions, Ideologies, Policies):
-
-
-

]]> 2021-04-26 17:50:32 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460874940 Italy GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460876598 Mainstream narrative:
- ^{'South, marginal perception' and coal dependency, closing the mines-> socio-demographic crisis, and negative chain effects on other industries
-High unemployment, migration, lack of tourism, lack of infrastructure including digital ones.
-Three element of the narratitive -colonial, peripheral and culture peculiar -> the transition is a opportunity for exploiting existing resources -solar/wind power.
LOCALS OFTEN SEEN AS PASSIVE ACTORS WAITING FOR SOMETHING TO HAPPEN FROM OUTSIDE -lack of agency - an alternative vision is now emerging. The transition is about changing the power RELATIONSHIPS, not only the energy sources.}
Whose narrative? (stakeholders, institutions)
- ENEL, ENI,
-
Selected component(s) (Technology, Stakeholders, Institutions, Ideologies, Policies):
-
-
-

]]> 2021-04-26 17:50:49 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460876598 Greece GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460876980 Mainstream narrative:
^{- Lignite plants to address 70s oil crisis, but now decisions to close them down -not viable economically.
- Changes in regional of power and identities balances}
-
Whose narrative? (stakeholders, institutions)
- Public Power Corporation
-
-

Selected component(s) (Technology, Stakeholders, Institutions, Ideologies, Policies):
- Institutions
- Policies

]]> 2021-04-26 17:50:53 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460876980 Germany GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460877352 Mainstream narrative:
- ^{Post-war growth and reconstruction thanks to coal, but started to change i the 60ss -e.g.,no competitive, 'efficient coal' to Green Capital. 'End of coal policy' 2005 and end of subsides as trigger.}
Whose narrative? (stakeholders, institutions)
- Industry players
- Political parties
- Different level of government
- Unions

Selected component(s) (Technology, Stakeholders, Institutions, Ideologies, Policies):
- Stakeholders
- Policies

]]> 2021-04-26 17:50:57 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460877352 Questions raised GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460881949 - Passivity of affected population, sense of fatalism
- Importance of power relation
- Transition of energy basis vs transition of people and their relations
-Concept of megalopolis
Transition not only based on the transition of energy, rather on how we see the transition of people
Re-framing the relationship of power
How to challenge the mainstream narrative?

]]> 2021-04-26 17:51:48 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1460881949 Poland GCF_TIPPINGplus https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1464244516 Mainstream narrative:
- Less efficient
- EU accession,
-
Whose narrative? (stakeholders, institutions)
- See slide -with regional policy stakeholders, national policy makers -new narrative of clean policy pathways. Even of right-wing parties, two axis.
-
-

Selected component(s) (Technology, Stakeholders, Institutions, Ideologies, Policies):
-
-
-

]]> 2021-04-27 13:29:54 UTC https://padlet.com/GCF_TIPPINGplus/Cluster1/wish/1464244516