The Hero's Journey Stages by Tyara Morales

The stages of the Hero's Journey

kkim124 — 2025-02-04 20:12:54 UTC

Winkler's stages include less advanced vocabulary while Volger's stages use a higher vocabulary level. Winkler's stages are also less perilous and tense compared to Volger's stages. Winkler's stages also goes straight to the point while Volger's doesn't.

Why does Winkler's stages not have the refusal of the call?

Why does Volger's stages not have "Status Quo upgraded?"

Why is Volger's departure stage more perilous?

Kaitlyn

knguyen2_80_1 — 2025-02-04 20:13:53 UTC

Notice:

Many of the stages are very similar like the status quo and the ordinary world, if not the same like the call to adventure.

The hero's journeys mean the same things and follow a very similar structure.
One is more in depth and the other is more straightforward/is more "beginner friendly"

Wonder:

Why does Winkler's hero's journey not have a refusal of the call?
Why does Vogler not have an updated status quo/ new life type of event in his hero's journey?
What about the result was not important enough to be in Vogler's hero's journey?

Matthew

mkalish4_1 — 2025-02-04 20:19:36 UTC

Notice: Some of them are the same but not all of them.

Notice: Some of the ones are in different orders than others. Call to Adventure is at 1 and then at 2.

Notice: In some of the groups, there are more parts of the journey than others.

Wonders: Why are there different parts of the journey

Wonders: What are the different parts of the journeys

Wonders: If the parts of the journey are in different places then does that mean the book is just in a different order then others?

Rish

rismendi — 2025-02-04 20:19:40 UTC

notice:

Many of the stages are the same thing except stated differently.
They are mostly the same
The parts that aren't in the other are only in stories sometimes
wonder:
1. is one of them more standard or common
2. What does new life mean
3. Are crossing the threshold and departure the same thing

Kareem Badwan

kbadwan — 2025-02-04 20:19:48 UTC

One of them is more specific than the other and has more stages but the other one has a combination. Winkler stages have more advanced vocabulary. I wonder why Vogler's stages have more Archetypes in his stages. Wikler stages are very basic vocabulary while Voglers has much more advanced vocabulary. Winkler repeats some words throughout his stages.

rihuck — 2025-02-04 20:21:13 UTC

Notice:

1) There are 12 stages in both types of the hero's journey.

2) In Wrinkler's stages the number of stages varies in numbers.

3) Volgers have an even amount of stages in each section.

Wonder:

1) Why do there have to be two different types of the Hero's Journey?

2) Why don't the different Hero's Journey? have the same amount of stages in each section?

3) Why are there more types of archetypes in the Wrinklers?

Peter Evan Pollack

ppollack1 — 2025-02-04 20:22:43 UTC

Notice: Three things I notice are that Winkler's and Vogler's writing styles are very different. In phase 3, the return, Winkler only has Status Quo Upgraded, but Vogler doesn't. Winkler's writing in the hero's journey is shorter than Vogler's.

3 things I wonder: Do Vogler and Winkler know each other? Do they have similar writing styles? I wonder what Winkler and Vogler write about.

Avi

achandarana21 — 2025-02-04 20:24:25 UTC

I notice that one of the differences is that one goes right to the point and one elaborates a little.

I notice Winkler has phases and stages in the phases

I notice Winkler phases have more specific details.

I wonder which one more people use

I wonder if Vogler copied Winkler.

I wonder why there are different parts of the journey.

Marcel

mwencel — 2025-02-04 20:26:43 UTC

I noticed that some of them have a lot of detail but then some others do not have as much detail as the others. I noticed that some of them have a very good vocabulary and some do not have as much vocabulary as others. I noticed that Most of these stages are similar and they are all not different. I wondered why they have so many different parts of the hero's journey and why does it have to have that much. I wondered why doesn't all of them use really good vocabulary. I wondered why some do not refuse to call.

Kate

kgustafson15_1 — 2025-02-04 20:28:57 UTC

Notice:

Some of the stages on both of the hero's journeys are the same but in different words.

there are all 12 stages in the hero's journey.

the voguers have less advanced vocabulary.

wonder:

why are there 2 hero journey

why does 1 have advanced vocabulary?

why does one have a different words.