"The Cardboard Box" By: Arthur Conan Doyle by Jenny Burke https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35 By: Justice Mudd, Jillian Ordway, Lillian Marler and Jenny Burke en-us 2022-01-27 13:58:57 UTC 2022-02-14 13:59:55 UTC hello@padlet.com https://padlet.net/icons/png/1f4e6.png jenny_burke1 https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2015949217 2022-01-27 14:21:21 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2015949217 Reenactment jenny_burke1 https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2015977901 2022-01-27 14:33:04 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2015977901 Our Summary jenny_burke1 https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021392285 Miss Susan Cushing received a cardboard box in the mail, that contained freshly severed human ears inside. The local detective asked Sherlock Holmes if he would like to help with the case, and he agreed. After some investigation on Holmes' part, it was determined that the ears were not a pair and that the box was meant for Sarah Cushing, Miss Susan Cushing's sister who had lived with her until quite recently. Mary, the youngest sister of Miss Susan Cushing, had a husband named Jim Browner, who worked on a ship and had a drinking problem. Before Sarah lived with Susan, she had lived with Mary and Jim for a while. Soon Sarah began to come onto Jim, and when he rejected her, she became very angry with him and set to sabotage his relationship with Mary. Before long Sarah had seeded doubts in Mary's head and made her not trust Jim anymore, and the couple began to grow apart. Soon Mary began to fall for Alec FairBairn, a friend of Sarah's. Once Jim realized what was happening, he was extremely angry at Mary, Sarah, and Alec, and he told Sarah that if Alec ever stepped foot in his house again, that he would send Sarah one of his ears as a "keepsake". After that Sarah left and moved in with Susan. Then Jim found out the Mary was still seeing Alec behind his back and when he confronted them, he threatened to kill her if she ever saw him again, and Alec ran. After some time had passed and things had cooled down, Jim was set to go to sea on the boat he worked on, the May Day, but due to some technical difficulties the departure had been delayed so he decided to go surprise his wife, only to find her with Alec FairBairn. He followed them to a train station and then to a place where they hired a boat to go onto the water in. Jim followed them onto the water, caught up to them about a mile from shore, and proceeded to bash Alec's head in with his walking cane. He then beat Mary to death with his stick after she cried out for Alec and clung to his body. After they had both died, Jim used his knife to cut off an ear from both of them, and then sunk their boat with them in it. He paddled back to shore, cleaned himself up, packaged the ears, and got back onto the May Day. Where the next day, while stopped at a port, he sent the gruesome package to Sarah Cushing at Miss Susan Cushing's residence, due to him not knowing that Sarah no longer lived there with her sister. Which is how Susan received the package instead of Sarah. After some instruction from Holmes the local detective, G. Lestrade, arrested Jim Browner after he returned to port the following day for the murder of his wife and of Alec FairBairn. Once in police custody Jim Browner gave a full confession to the police, and explained that he hadn't been able to sleep since the murders because he kept seeing their horrified faces every time he closed his eyes. ]]> 2022-01-31 14:38:55 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021392285 Susan jenny_burke1 https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021408201
  • Oldest, quiet, large blue eyes.
  •  Lives alone, works on embroidery. 
  • Had to kick out some medical students a few years back due to noisy and irregular habits. 
  • Was sent the package of the severed ears. 

    • ]]>     2022-01-31 14:45:05 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021408201     Sarah jenny_burke1 https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021410386
  • Middle sister. 
  • Has a temper and is “hard to please”. 
  • Close with her sister Mary and moved near her. 
  • Had a falling out when she tried to make a move on Mary’s husband. 
  • Sarah moved in with Susan. 
  • Mary’s husband rejected Sarah so she started talking bad about him to make Mary hate him. 

    • ]]>     2022-01-31 14:45:59 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021410386     Mary jenny_burke1 https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021413283
  • Youngest. 
  • Married. 
  • Starts having an affair with Alec Fairbairn after Sarah starts talking bad about her husband Jim.

    • ]]>     2022-01-31 14:47:12 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2021413283     Setting jenny_burke1 https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2025350008 2022-02-02 13:36:39 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2025350008 Suspects and their M.O.M justicemudd https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035490690 Three Medical Students
    M - The medical students might have had a grudge with the victim because she had hopes of getting rid of their noisy and irregular habits.       
    O - Lived at the victim’s “apartments”     
    M - They knew where the victim lived.

    Ruled out because of how the ears were packed with salt (A medical student wouldn’t do this). They also wouldn’t have done it because the ears were removed with a “blunt instrument”.

    Jim Browner                    
    M - Mary had an affair with Alec, built up anger towards Sarah, Mary, and Alec. Jim had anger issues and was conflicted by the fact that Mary didn’t love him anymore.   
    O - Alec and Mary were alone in the middle of a lake        
    M - Knew both victims and knew their routines/where they lived. ]]>     2022-02-08 13:49:56 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035490690     Possible Red Herrings justicemudd https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035493494 One possible red herring was the medical students. It wasn’t really a “red herring”, just wrong suspects. They rented out an apartment from Susan. She had to kick them out a few years prior due to their “noisy and irregular habits”. ]]> 2022-02-08 13:51:11 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035493494 Clues justicemudd https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035497644
  • Miss Cushing had two sisters, her sister Mary had a husband (Jim Browner) who Miss Cushing (susan) was not fond of. 
  • “but if Fairbairn shows his face here again I’ll send you one of his ears for a keepsake.” - Browner 
  •  Sarah moved in with Susan.  
  • Jim said that Sarah was the devil. 
  • Jim resulted in drinking and had threatened Mary multiple times.
  • Blames Sarah for everything.
  • “It gave me a kind of savage joy when I thought how Sarah would feel when she had such signs as these of what her meddling had brought about.”

    • ]]>     2022-02-08 13:53:01 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035497644     Jim Browner justicemudd https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035508448
  • Was married to Mary.
  • Recovering alcoholic that fell back into addiction
  • Loyal
  • Rejected Sarah’s advances

    • ]]>     2022-02-08 13:57:36 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035508448     Our final reflections justicemudd https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035513572 Jenny - This story was definitely very interesting, I wasn't sure what to expect in the beginning except for another boring old story. However, I enjoyed this story and found it weird that someone would have sent a pair of severed ears to someone. I like how detailed the story was. I disliked that Jim resulted to Murdering them instead of just getting a divorce.

    Justice - I like how odd the story was. I've watched a lot of Forensic Files and it reminded me a lot of something you would see on one of the episodes. Something I disliked was how Sarah came onto Mary’s husband. I know there had to be a story, but that’s your sister. It was stupid and gross. I could NEVER see myself doing that. But I also agree with Jenny. I never understood why people killed their spouse after finding out they are cheating or something similar instead of just getting a divorce. 

    Lillian - The story has an incredible way of keeping the reader on the edge of their seat. Everything I’ve read from this story keeps me intrigued. It’s hit after hit with something new and more interesting with the case. In a way, the beginning of Jim’s story makes you feel a bit bad for him, but that quickly went downhill as soon as he mentioned murder, and when he became abusive. I didn’t like the way Sarah kind of started to treat Jim in a weird way. AS A SISTER IN LAW. Kind of weird. Also, If Jim knew there was something wrong with Mary, or he noticed that she didn’t have an interest in him anymore, it would have been easier to get a divorce.

    Jillian - I really liked how detailed the story was and how the fact that it was told from Watson's point of view kept the reader from understanding everything and on the edge of their seats until the very end. I think it was an interesting perspective for it to be told from and that it really added to the story. I did not like however, the way that as the story went on Jim kept on becoming more angry and abusive, until he got to the point where he threatened murder. I also did not like how as he gave the police his statement he was completely unapologetic for murdering his wife and another man. He says that he cannot be punished more than he has already punished himself, but that's not remorse for his actions, he's only regretting the guilt he feels and the nightmares he's gotten from his horrific crime. 
    ]]>     2022-02-08 13:59:41 UTC https://padlet.com/jenny_burke1/kfnrtl6hqqsw2c35/wish/2035513572