Guilty or Innocent? 1B by Sanders, Jamie - POWDHS Teacher https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y The Scarlet Ibis en-us 2020-09-29 11:53:02 UTC 2020-10-02 12:51:14 UTC hello@padlet.com JeanMarie https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797347711  "i stopped and waited for doodle"(hurst 441) Meaning that he wasn't planning on doodle dying it just happened. After he wanted he went back for doodle and we he had seen him dead he "...began to weep and tear blurred vision before me looked very familiar". (Hurst 441) showing that it wasn't meant for him to die he even stated that he was in a childish  mood when he ran i got this from the quote "... the flood of childish spite evanesced as well" (hurst 441). this all shows that he loved his brother so much and would never want this it's shown many times over and over again in the story. ]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:03 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797347711 robbie lockhart https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797347899 bother is somewhat guilty. " I stopped and waited for Doodle" (Hurst 441) . bother stop waited for Doodle. " I'd run... careen him around corner on two wheels. Something I accidentally turned him over..."(Hurst 431).]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:09 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797347899 Leandra lawson https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797347908 I think his is guilty because he mistreated him and made him feel less as a person. He also was embarrassed I know this because in the text it states " I was embarrassed at having a brother of that age that can't walk, so i set out to teach him" ( Hurst 432). Just because you are embarrassed you shouldn't try to make him feel different or even try to change who he is. He also threatened him to leave him alone knowing how scared he gets when his alone. I know this because in the text it states "" Then I'll leave you here by yourself. " I threatened" ( Hurst 432).  ]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:09 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797347908 Dajuan Wardell https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348104 I think Brother is guilty and here why. In the text is said, "...so I began to make plans to smoother him with a pillow" (Hurst, page 430). So even when his brother couldn't even talk/ at birth, he wanted to kill Doodle cause he was a invalid brother. Say in the text, "I ran as fast as I could, leaving him far behind with a wall of rain dividing us"( Hurst, page 441). So it didn't even cross brother mind the Doodle can mine death, leaving his 6 year old brother ,that just started run, in a bad storm.]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:13 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348104 Shermya Thomas https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348144 Brother is guilty because he had an chance to go back and safe Doodle but he kept running. According to the text"I ran as fast as I could,leaving him far behind with a wall of rain dividing us" I feel like he's guilty for doing that and he should take all the blame for it because he was there it was his fault. He should of never leaved his brother like knowing he had problems and that he couldn't most things.]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:14 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348144 bailey https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348252 2020-10-02 12:29:18 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348252 Ethan Miller https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348575 Brother is guilty of killing Doodle. In the text he tries to help his brother get better at doing things he should have never have never been able to. The text says,"]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:26 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348575 walker https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348611 bother is guilty in the scarlet ibis because he treats his bother bad and knida hates him. In the text is says "...so i began to makes plans to kill him by smothering him with a pillow" I feel like this is showing that he didnt want him as a bother form the start. It also states "then ill leave you here by yourself,"I threatened, and made  as if i were going down" he scared Doodle in to touching his own cask what kinda o bother dose that and also threatened to leave him up there with it. ]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:27 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797348611 kharyn https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797349134 Brother is guilty because he left doodle in the rain and Doodle told brother before not to live him by himself and Brother didn't listen and also Brother was being mean to Doodle every since he was born.In the book it say " I ran as fast as I could leaving him far behind with a wall of rain dividing us" Hurst page 441. Also he was making plans to kill him while he was sleep in the book is says " .....so I began to make plans to smother him with a pillow.]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:42 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797349134 Isaiah dunlap https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797349680 He is somewhat guilty because he did leave his brother behind but he waited for him to catch up. In the Texts it states " So I made plans to kill him(431). This means that he did want to kill him but he did teach him how to walk]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:57 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797349680 Grant Davis https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797349758 I Think brother is guilty because of how he treated him from when he was born to when he died. "...so I began to make plans to kill him by
smothering him with a pillow" (Hurst 430). He wanted to kill him by smothering him with a pillow because he hated him so much and he really wanted him to die in the first place. Another point i have for this argument is when he taught him something it was out selfishness so he could feel better about having a disabled brother. "I'm going to teach you how to walk...Why...So i won't have to haul you around" (Hurst 432). This statement made by brother only proves he thought he was a burden to him and his family.
]]> 2020-10-02 12:29:59 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797349758 Mckenzie wade https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350203 brother knew the reason he did that was based off of pride and he knew what he did was wrong when he left doodle in a raging storm after he crying out not to leave him.

]]> 2020-10-02 12:30:09 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350203 tyler https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350518 I think he is somewhat innocent because he waited and when he didn't show he went back to were he was to find him dead and he cried and he helped him run and swim   ]]> 2020-10-02 12:30:19 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350518 sara https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350781 i think that he is innocent because he was just a 12 year old boy who might not have completely known what was wrong with doodle and he never planned to have doodle die and he truly loved his brother. even though brother did abandon him and run away, he was just trying to help him walk nit kill him. "i stopped and waited fo doodle" (hurst411) meaning that he was going to go back for doodle and that his intentions were to never kill his brother. "i began to weep, and the tear blurred vision before me looked very familiar," (hust 411) if you read this you can clearly tell that he loved his brother, just might have been a little hash, but what do you do with your siblings, i know we aren't angels to them all the time. i get embarrased by my family a lot just like brother did with doodle.]]> 2020-10-02 12:30:25 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350781 Bethany Wilson https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350971 I think brother is fully 100% guilty. I could see where someone would be coming from if they think he is either innocent or somewhat innocent because there is enough evidence to back it up either way, but still, since he is at that age to where you should know right from wrong I think he is guilty.]]> 2020-10-02 12:30:31 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797350971 Anthony Hampton https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797352122 2020-10-02 12:30:55 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797352122 Anthony Jensen https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797352794 In the short story Scarlet Ibis, Brother is somewhat guilty because in the beginning he said "...so i began to make plans to kill him by smothering him with a pillow." This directly shows he wants Doodle dead, but later in the story a statement by the narrator contradicts the other statement. "I stopped and waited for Doodle." Brother didn't have to wait for doodle he could've left him for good. That is why with those statements I feel Brother is somewhat guilty.]]> 2020-10-02 12:31:09 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797352794 aubree tate https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797353977 i think hes guilty because the way he treated his brother because he wanted to kill him

]]> 2020-10-02 12:31:41 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797353977 Justin Barbare https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797359922 I believe that he is guilty because he said "...so I began to make a plan to smother him with a pillow" and he would foce his bothe to stand up hundreds of times and when it was raining really hard he his brother yelled "Brother Brother Don't Leave me! Don't Leave Me" and he still left him. (Hrust)]]> 2020-10-02 12:34:07 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797359922 Bryson berning https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797359945 i think that he is guilty because he was trying to smother dooldel with a pillow (heurst 432) i will leave you by your self (hurst 432) he was a bad brother because he was trying to kill his on brother who dose that. threes a fuf evidence that he is very guilty.]]> 2020-10-02 12:34:08 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797359945 karen camacho https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797367341 i feel that he is somewhat near innocent. '' doodle was my brother and he was going to cling to me forever''. he has love for his brother but there is also something's he has done that i don't agree with]]> 2020-10-02 12:37:04 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797367341 Travis Cain - Innocent until proven guilty https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797370413 He is kind f guilt because we might not have seen what he is actually like we watch mostly about doodle and not enough of brother, he could really care about doodle but maybe he was scared in the heat of the moment he ran, if he hated doodle i think he wouldn't of come back for him because he knew he wouldn't survive the storm because he knows how weak doodles body was, or maybe not because he was able to help doodle defy everyone and the doctor, but it was all for himself, I think brother got jealous because doodle was getting all the love for learning how to walk. That might be why he was crying, because it was all because of him that doodle could walk but the only love we see brother getting is from doodle so i think that doodle and brother have a strong bond]]> 2020-10-02 12:38:15 UTC https://padlet.com/sandersj39/k75584isp37i235y/wish/797370413