P6: Christopher Columbus - Hero or Villain? by Kerry Hurst https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap Write 4-6 sentences in which you explain whether you think Columbus was a hero or villain and why. Use evidence from the readings to support your opinion. en-us 2020-10-12 17:56:24 UTC 2020-10-30 18:10:02 UTC hello@padlet.com Christopher Columbus was most definitely a villain. Although a lot of the mistakes made by Columbus are natural things that would have happened anyways he did ruin a lot for the natives. According to the article in "the truth about Christopher Columbus" written by Christopher Minster the text states, ¨He was a slave trader who heartlessly took men and women away from their families in order to lesson his failure to find a new trade route"(Minster 16). In the end Columbus demonstrated many factors that leads us to believe he is in fact a villian. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/838029946 2020-10-17 22:15:28 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/838029946 https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839001401 I believe that Christopher Columbus was both a hero and a villain. He had many flaws, but he also changed the world. The articles prove that he was greedy and inexcusably terrible to the Native Americans who lived on the Caribbean islands that he settled, but he also changed the world’s view of our planet forever and discovered the beginning of something amazing--two new continents. While he ruthlessly killed and enslaved the native people, it was a very common and cruel practice at the time. While it is absolutely wrong by today’s standards, and I am disgusted by it, that was life back then. Finally, there is no way he could have known about or stopped the spread of diseases to the American peoples, because no one knew the expedition was bringing these illnesses to America--least of all Columbus.]]> 2020-10-18 16:54:25 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839001401 I believe Christopher Columbus was both a hero and a villain. He was a hero because he took a chance at the unknown and sailed westward. In his time, most people only took known sea routes when travelling by boats. But, he is also a villain. His motives weren't for exploration, he wanted to become rich and would do anything for it. When his first journey seemed like a failure he took Tainos from their families to prove there was some worth in his expedition. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839300283 Estefania Ramizez]]> 2020-10-18 22:33:48 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839300283 https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839319483 I believe that Christopher Columbus was both a hero and a villain. He was a hero because he sailed the big ocean and found some new land. He had no route to follow and just made decisions on his own about which direction to go. He also knew that there was a chance he could die but did it anyway. He is also a villain because once he found land me treated the natives badly. Because of this other sailors also treated them badly, because of what Christopher Columbus told about them. Overall he was both a hero and a villain. Haley Herbert]]> 2020-10-18 22:53:19 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839319483 I think Columbus was both a hero and a villain. He was a hero to the Europeans, because he found new land, and new resources. As well as opening up a whole continent to them. He was a villain because he treated the native people horribly, and disrespected them in many ways. He enslaved the native peoples, and killed them without remorse. He also brought many diseases that the native peoples had not yet encountered, killing millions. He was unable to find a route to Asia he stole from the natives without compassion, or any thought of morals. He was a hero and a villain, because he opened up a whole new continent to the knowledge of the world, but treated the natives horribly. He was more villain then hero but still has both in him, nonetheless. Quartz Landaker https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839326428 2020-10-18 23:01:32 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839326428 I believe that Christopher Columbus was both a hero and a villain. He was a hero to some by sailing around the sea and conquering land for America. He was also one of many of the firsts to do many things. Besides those few goods he had done, he is also a villain. Columbus had killed thousands of Native Americans, lead diseases to the Natives, wanted money only for himself, etc. I believe that he was more of a villain than a hero. Audrey Duran https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839339894 2020-10-18 23:17:32 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839339894 Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839446655 I think Christopher Columbus was evil to all but Europeans.He was a hero to Europeans because he discovered new land and lots of new resources for Europe. He also opened travel to an entirely new continent to Europe. Christopher Columbus was a hero to Europeans. On the other hand he killed and enslaved many Natives to accomplish everything he did. Columbus had no mercy to the Native people, he also brought many diseases and sicknesses to the Natives causing more casualties You can view Columbus in two point of views because he did good for one side and did bad for another. -Keenan ]]> 2020-10-19 00:48:43 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839446655 Depending on where you lived during Christopher Columbus's expeditions, he was either a Hero or a Villain, but for certain a man who drastically changed history without any doubt. He obviously had power, greed, and ego problems which led him to kill many Taino Native Americans. However, this certainly was acceptable during the time period, even though he believed in Christianity, which contradicts his actions. But, he also discovered the America's, and without him finding this place first, we quite honestly might not be here today. Thus, if you are or were a Christian, or Native American, at the time, Columbus was the Devil, but if you were a scientist, shipman, or a modern day person (whether you like it or not) Columbus is a Protagonist. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839562354 Jack Glover]]> 2020-10-19 02:05:46 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839562354 Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839606968 In my personal opinion, background knowledge, and new facts from the articles, I think Christopher Columbus was an evil son of a dog. He thought by discovering new lands, he had the right to rape and pillage innocent Native lives. I can support my evidence by referencing to the article "The Truth About Christopher Columbus", if you look back to myth #3, he captured natives and made them slaves on their land. He was uneducated and couldn't find his way around a map, and "winged it." When he didn't get his way with the Native's he brutally killed them all, which like it or not is wrong for a man who aspires to be a "christian." Christopher did not discover the Americas, Amerigo Vespucci did, so in turn I don't think he should be celebrated for something he didn't do and how he "did it." To some back in that time and now, he may seem like a hero for finding land, when in reality he stole land and oppressed its people, claimed to think he was somewhere he was not, and was really an egotistical idiot. ( sorry that was a little intense ) Tannyn Johnson ]]> 2020-10-19 02:36:42 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839606968 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839644798 I think that Columbus was both a hero and a villain for many reasons. He captured other natives to use as slaves as stated in myth #3.  However, slavery was very lucrative at that time in Europe and not seen as 'bad'. Also, when he returned to Spain, he brought a lot of information about discovering the new world as stated in myth #4. Europeans didn't know anything about the New World, and he told King and Queen of Spain lots about it. He was then rewarded with seeing and discovering more of the New World four times. However, for something to be discovered, it must be first lost, and the native people in the Americas, weren't considered lost. In conclusion, Christopher Columbus was both a villain and a hero.
Adam Peisajovich]]> 2020-10-19 03:05:06 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839644798 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839671751 I believe christopher colombus was both a hero and a villian. A few reasons why He was vonsidered  hero is he brought in christianity and brought new riches. He also introduced new foods such as; Tomatoes, cocoa and corn to Europe. A few reasons as to why he is a villian is because he inslaved countless amounts of native americans. He introduced a tax system where if they couldnt pay up they were inslaved. 
Nevaeh Erni]]> 2020-10-19 03:25:41 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839671751 https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839672874 I believe Christopher Columbus was a villain. Because he has many flaws, such as claiming land that wasn’t his, he was was slaughtering native Americans and claimed they were Indians. He has demonstrated many factors especially when he was slaughtering and eating all of the native Americans food, and taking and raping their daughters. They took their men and made them “slaves”  and he has claimed many things that weren’t true as his own. That is why I believe he is a villain. - nick fuentes]]> 2020-10-19 03:26:36 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839672874 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839684882 I think that Chrisopher Columbus is both a hero and a villain. It was very brave of him to set sail and to discover new land, but the things that he did while he was there, not so great. He brought religion to a place where it is now known for religious freedom. This means that he brought Christianity stating “No one should fear to undertake any task in the name of our Saviour, if it is just and if the intention is purely for His holy service.” This allows us to be in the America that we are in now rather than ruled by a single religion. At the same time, he also enslaved natives and used them for profit. In my opinion, he has helped more than hurt, but he has also definitely done some wrong. Ayden Abeyta]]> 2020-10-19 03:35:48 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839684882 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839762472 I think Christopher Columbus was a hero. If it were not for him, all of America could be speaking Spanish, French, or even Dutch. Not only was he the first person to cross the Atlantic Ocean, but he also was the first man prove Aristotle's recent theory that the Earth was round. Thanks to Columbus, other countries were able to reach the new lands, opening up new trading routes and a whole new world of trading goods. The man also looked dashing in tights. 
Luke Lamb  ]]> 2020-10-19 04:29:31 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839762472 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839809147 I think Christopher Columbus was both a hero and a villain. He was the first person to cross that Atlantic Ocean, discovering new land. With his 4 voyages across the oceans he was very successful. He brought lots of riches to Spain and brought lots of new foods to both Spain and the Americas. Christopher also did some wrong. He enslaved many native Americans and but a tax on them. Columbus did not care for the native American lives. He claimed lots of land that was not his and took from the native Americans. Overall I think he was a Hero and a Villain depending on witch side you are on. - Samuel Smith]]> 2020-10-19 04:57:33 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/839809147 I believe that Christopher Columbus was both a hero and a villain. Through his travels to find Asia and discovering the Americas instead; he opened up a new door for trade and allowed a spread for new ideas, opening of a country with freedom of religion, and a spread of goods. Without Columbus' voyage, we may not be where we are in our lives right now. Columbus is a villain though for his vile acts against Native Americans everywhere he went. He and his settlers slaughtered Native Americans, enslaved them for profit, and forced them to pay taxes. "The Natives were soon forced into slavery, and punished with the loss of a limb or death" (Article 1). The unfair treatment of the Taino by Columbus and his troops further allowed the inhumane abuse of Native Americans by other European Settlers. Columbus did some great things to get America off to a start, but he was an awful man that killed many. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/840684191 Kayla Davis]]> 2020-10-19 12:20:52 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/840684191 Christopher Columbus was most definitely a villain. Although a lot of the mistakes made by Columbus are natural things that would have happened anyways he did ruin a lot for the natives. According to the article in "the truth about Christopher Columbus" written by Christopher Minster the text states, ¨He was a slave trader who heartlessly took men and women away from their families in order to lesson his failure to find a new trade route"(Minster 16). In the end Columbus demonstrated many factors that leads us to believe he is in fact a villian. Kaylee Flook https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/841245789 2020-10-19 14:35:33 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/841245789 https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/841601695 I think columbus was both a hero and a villan. I would say he was a hero beacuse he was the one who discovered america by sailing and was able to bring lots of people from europe to america and as stated in (myth #3) the europeans were much more adavnce and they brought those advancements with them which the natives were very intrested in, and i also would say he is the villan because he treated the nattives who were already there very bad and with no respect for the land that they were already living on by keeping them as slaves, and i agree with what is stated in (christopher columbus:hero or villan)¨He was not a monster nor a saint.¨
grey smith

]]> 2020-10-19 15:51:44 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/841601695 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842146675 Columbus was both a hero and a villain, he came and set a voyage to better his county. as doing so he found land, found new goods and conquered land for his country to spread the reign of the Spanish empire. In doing so he did some very unforgiving things to the natives and there culture. with this said i believe that he was both a hero and a villain 
- Julian S. Hugg  ]]> 2020-10-19 17:44:52 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842146675 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842275961 I believe that Columbus is a villain and a hero. While he did go about things the wrong way, he delivered the people of America to our home, even though he didn’t know it at the time. He mistreated the natives horribly, but they would have most likely been conquered by someone else, like “one of the most ferocious people in recorded history, the Caribs,”(Crowder 2), or people like the Aztec, who “carried out ritual human sacrifice on a scale far exceeding any recorded of any other people in the history of the world,”(Crowder 2). That being said, Columbus was a brave explorer, trusting his instincts. He was “a very talented sailor, navigator and sea captain,” (Minster 3). 
Danni Johnson]]> 2020-10-19 18:13:09 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842275961 Columbus was a hero in terms of discovering new lands and civilizing them. He “brought civilization to the American lands” (Crowder). He did things wrong such as treat native americans poorly but in terms of discovery he was a hero. People might have had ideas that the earth was flat but Columbus was the first to actually prove it. This helped revolutionize astrology and science around the world. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842279188 By Mac ]]> 2020-10-19 18:13:51 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842279188 I believe that Christopher Columbus was a little bit of both hero and villain. While he may have done things wrong by mistreating the natives, trading slaves and more. But if it was not him it would have most likely been another exploration. But overall the general outcome was positive. He was the first man to cross the Atlantic ocean. And many firsts, He had good intentions but followed through with bad outcomes which makes him both a hero and a villain. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842311200 -Anthony Trillanes

]]> 2020-10-19 18:21:31 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842311200 Columbus was a villain and a hero to me because he ruined a lot for the natives but also did a lot for trade and allowed a spread for new ideas. If not for Columbus a lot of other countries would not know how to reach other lands. Columbus discovered new lands and civilized them.In a way Columbus was also a villain because he slaughtered native Americans, enslaved them for profit, lead diseases to the Native Americans, etc. So he was a hero by discovering and civilizing new land and opening America etc... But he was a villain also because he slaughtered Native Americans and what he did to them was wrong. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842348780 - Cedarius Yates]]> 2020-10-19 18:30:25 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842348780 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842715081 Columbus was both a hero and  a villain/ Columbus was a talented sailor, navigator, and ship captain. He then went west without a map, and trusting his instincts with his calculations. However, during his fourth voyage, he and his men were stranded on Jamaica for about a year when his ships rotted. But he was also a cheapstake. Althought, he then refused to to pay up after promising to reward to whoever spotted land first on his 1492 voyage. Columbus refused to pay up to sailor Rodgrigo de Triana after the sailor spotted land first. Then Columbus gave himself the reward instead because he had seen a "glow" the night before. 
-Catalina Estrada

]]> 2020-10-19 20:19:20 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/842715081 Christopher Columbus. https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/843585023 Christopher Columbus, i believe, was a villain. I say this because he enslaved people, and natives. he was arrested, and had some mistakes. Although he had mistakes, him as a villain did some great things as well. Like constructed a deal with the Spanish, and voyaged the world. I would say he is both but if i say he is a villain this paragraph
 will most likely be read and the audience will have a bias opinion.]]> 2020-10-20 04:55:53 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/843585023 Christopher Columbus https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/877295566 To me i think Christopher Columbus is a villain. The reason i say this is because he did three things that were really bad. The first thing he did that was bad is that when he came to the new world he pretty much said this is all mine and took almost everything from them. The second thing was that when he came to this new place he killed a lot of the people there if they didn't do as he said so. The final thing is that him and his crew brought over so many diseases that killed alsmost their enter tribe whtch also spreaded to north america and killed more of the native americans there too. 
By Jake Wood]]> 2020-10-30 17:33:14 UTC https://padlet.com/kerryhurst/j9ir5acud85zqiap/wish/877295566