Reservoir Simulator by Bonavian Hasiholan https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5 With your own opinion, compare between Eclipse and tNavigator en-us 2018-04-07 00:43:04 UTC 2025-10-03 23:55:56 UTC hello@padlet.com Bonavian bondpeace99 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249385616 Dear students,

Please make comments on the above question (Not more than 30 words): 1. Click on the 'add' icon on the bottom right corner to post your answer. Write your name in the title.
2. Place the post anywhere you like.
3. Please answer latest by Monday, 9 April 2018, 12.00 pm. Thank you]]> 2018-04-07 00:53:43 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249385616 Gregorius Eldwin Pradipta (1001438989 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249396106 - tNav give better visual in 2D and 3D
- coding in tNav is not as precise as eclipse which is sometimes there is error in eclipse but not in tNav
-tNav is user friendly]]> 2018-04-07 05:22:11 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249396106 Mavist Cruz (1001333961) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249397333 tNavigator has a better GUI than Eclipse. It provides real time results viewing and supports live discussion which Eclipse cannot do. It also saves simulation time compared to Eclipse.

]]> 2018-04-07 06:03:22 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249397333 Errick Arveen 1001334273 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249401628 Tnav is better than Eclipse in the sense of interface and settings. Eclipse however has better accuracy and simplicity in input data and codings. 

]]> 2018-04-07 07:23:15 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249401628 Joseph 1001335902 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249410914 Tnav GUI is better, and for large simulation data its faster because you can use the model as it processes. but eclipse feels more reliable and accurate.]]> 2018-04-07 09:53:34 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249410914 Ghozany alfarisyi 1001230909 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249411685 For eclipse, we need to acquire high knowledge and training as it is quite complex. Contrary, tnavigator dont need necessary training as long as we have basic simulation background.]]> 2018-04-07 10:04:46 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249411685 Zeyad (1001335846) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249413602 Tnav is much more better than eclipse. It provides better visual and clear instructions. Also , History matching in Tnav is clear and easer than that in eclipse. Tnav is faster compared with eclipse .However, eclipse is more accurate. ]]> 2018-04-07 10:35:32 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249413602 Mohammed Jamal(1001436747) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249414961 tNavigator is more easier and comfortable than eclipse in which tNavigator have only one window to work on but, eclipse you have to open more than two windows.]]> 2018-04-07 10:56:04 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249414961 Osamah Nabol(1001436472) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249415560 In Eclipse we have to run the data first then show the model in petrel so we have two software, while tNavigator is more simple; all work can be run in one software.]]> 2018-04-07 11:06:58 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249415560 Juan Liemantoro Sanjaya (1001437956) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249419099 in my opinion, both tnav and eclipse are important in oil and gas industries, both are good software to give reservoir engineer description of the model. tnav has better interface, and easier to use compare to eclipse, it's because tnav has tried to introduce new way of working to reservoir engineer, compare to eclipse as mother of reservoir simulation simulation that i think still applied old-school mode. in the end both will be used as reference, the more the reference the better the result.  ]]> 2018-04-07 12:01:57 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249419099 Soo Tzan Yaw (1001540944) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249464191 tNavigator has a simpler user interface and lower learning curve than Eclipse. However, Eclipse has better tools and apps due to its long-standing history as the standard in the industry.]]> 2018-04-07 20:44:04 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249464191 Avinnaash Suresh (1001438213) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249490103  
Advantages (difference) of tNavigator over ECLIPSE are;
·         Running of different input syntaxes from different simulators (ECLIPSE (SCHLUMBERGER), IMEX (CMG), & TEMPEST (ROXAR)) 
·         Supports 3D monitoring and user’s interactivity at runtime 
]]> 2018-04-08 05:35:08 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249490103 Khairunnisyah 1001438914 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249497065 tNavigator is much more handy and has easy access to all of its features compared to Eclipse though Eclipse is more widely used in the industry for its long term exposure, when it comes to tNavigator, the user should be able to understand it easily with few training lessons and the manual. Tnav could definitely optimize the project duration and its contemporary features helps to solidify the resulting models in a faster and optimized way.]]> 2018-04-08 07:30:00 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249497065 Elizabeth Adau Arop Nyok (1001437895) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249527575 -tnavigator, unlike eclipse takes a shorter time to run.
- tNavigator can run on any workstation ,that is it can run on even an i pad.
-the two are unique in their own ways]]> 2018-04-08 13:07:52 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249527575 Majd Ibrahim (1001335089) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249528021 T-NAV can show reservoir characteristic,  reverse in time showing previous data easier in drilling horizontal wells and can show a lot of graphs option with no need for petrel. 

]]> 2018-04-08 13:12:42 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249528021 Vasantha kumar (1001438411) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249545930 T navigator easy to lean compared to eclipse. Eclipse is not very user friendly. T navigator has a better advanced feature like geology model design, PVT and etc in one simple system. The most importantly the simulation speed is very high compared to eclipse.


]]> 2018-04-08 15:51:24 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249545930 Ng Ming Quan (1001437002) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249555108 Eclipse can run a lot of tools such as Office and Petrel at the same time, while tNavigator is simpler to use and can show the well activities more detailed compared to Petrel.]]> 2018-04-08 17:08:09 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249555108 Ameer Fayyadh 1001231227 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249601812 tNavigator supports black oil, compositional and thermal compositional simulations for workstations and High-Performance Computing clusters.

ECLIPSE 100 solves the black oil equations (a fluid model) on corner-point grids. ECLIPSE 300 solves the reservoir flow equations for compositional hydrocarbon descriptions and thermal simulation.

]]> 2018-04-09 00:11:23 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249601812 Aldo Febrien (1001439139) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249630183 Tnavigator support more input data format(eclipse 100/300,IMEX) compare to eclipse and tnavigator is a single executable program which allow to run variety module in one program (black oil/compositional)]]> 2018-04-09 03:39:59 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249630183 Said K 1001539740 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249630824 Tnavigator has a better GUI( compared to eclipse, it has an unlimited core processor which leads to higher speeds, it is faster/quicker compared to eclipse.
Tnavigator unlike Eclipse, has no need for preprocessor]]> 2018-04-09 03:45:24 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249630824 Ramyar Rizgar https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249632612 1001437765 

* TNav is more convenient to use. 
* Both Eclipse and TNav precise and accurate in calculation. 

*TNav is more easier and simpler to use and Faster
* Eclipse more complicated. 

*TNav new compared to Eclipse thats why not been accepted that much
*While Eclipse been used for longer time easier for the existing experts, since they got used to it]]> 2018-04-09 03:58:31 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249632612 Ali Abid Mahoon https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638199 1001439257 

1-tnav is the first parallel simulator supporting 3d monitoring and user interactivity at runtime. ]]> 2018-04-09 04:05:10 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638199 Enas AlJamal https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638255 2018-04-09 04:05:15 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638255 Enas AlJamal https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638277 Tnavigater
Is way eas]]> 2018-04-09 04:05:28 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638277 Enas AlJamal https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638296 Tnavigater
Is way easier to used than Eclips and petrel and it doesn’t ]]> 2018-04-09 04:05:45 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638296 Enas AlJamal https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638302 Tnavigater
Is way easier to be used than Eclips and petrel and it doesn’t suddenly stuck.
It has everything in one.
However eclipse 
Is old but  we got used to it during the semester.
To make it shorter Tnav is new and a better simulation software to be used in universities.]]> 2018-04-09 04:05:47 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249638302 Ritaj https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249639312 For tiNav; it’s user friendly. Easier to work with. All the platforms at one place(no need to open graphs from office, model from petrel, etc) therefore it’s more convenient to the user. On the other hand, ECLIPSE is easier to write the code with it. However, it’s more complicated compared to tiNav to work with]]> 2018-04-09 04:13:51 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249639312 Abdulrahman M. 1001334231 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249641627 T navigator is easier to use and simulate black oil models than eclipse as it is more simple and got all the functions in a single software which can consume less time compare it with eclipse 100 ]]> 2018-04-09 04:30:21 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249641627 Wong Shao Hang 1001335237 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249641823 In my Opinion TNav is much easier than eclipse. It fasten the dynamic reservoir stimulation on laptop compare to others. What mostly important i think is the interface of the Tnav is much more simple and easy to read. ]]> 2018-04-09 04:32:22 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249641823 fajar jati pitutur (1001438009) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249642162 Tnav offer easier use of simulation than eclipse, although some of the codes in eclipse could not be read by tnav. Also, Tnav could not read errors in the codes, so when there is an error, Tnav will automatically skip i and continue with the modelling. ]]> 2018-04-09 04:34:54 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249642162 Odongo Rose 1001437831 trudster26 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249642679 tNavigator is very user friendly and does not require any other software to view the model since it is integrated with geology, model and network designers. Eclipse requires other softwares like Petrel in order to be able to view the model]]> 2018-04-09 04:38:31 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249642679 Deanna Bt Khairon https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249644612 TNav is more easier to operate with conpare to eclipse. ]]> 2018-04-09 04:51:02 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249644612 Tin https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249646177 2018-04-09 05:04:48 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249646177 Loo Zheng Hao (1001437342) mushi6789 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249646260 For the tnavigator, its easier to operate than the Eclipse. It is because we can monitor every step of the reservoir simulation at runtime, but also, we can directly interrupt and change the simulation’s configurations with just a mouse click]]> 2018-04-09 05:05:46 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249646260 For tanvi can give clear view than eclipes and also it one window software compare to eclipes you need run the files in different simulation softwar https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249646316 2018-04-09 05:06:18 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249646316 Haseeb Ashraf 1001232597 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249647552 Tnav doesn't require preprocesser unlike eclipse.
Tnav has a simpler user interface compared to eclipse though eclipse is more common due to its long existance in the oil industry,
Tnav is usually faster than eclipse ]]> 2018-04-09 05:17:14 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249647552 Aakhaash Neatha (1001438110) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249651018 TNavigator is more easy to use than eclipse because of its tendency to have vast options in one window, and whereas eclipse and petrel in the other hand are slow in their simulation but i prefer using eclipse as it is more convenient.]]> 2018-04-09 05:47:31 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249651018 Mohammed aboluhom( 1001437595) https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249710605 In my opinion tnavigator is way better than eclipse because it has got many features that are not available in eclipse such as that you can see the results while processing for example while the tnavigator is still processing for the next 10 years and has done five years you can see the graphs and results for the processed years. ]]> 2018-04-09 10:01:05 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249710605 Aban Nobel Bonan https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249710818 T navigator does not require the usage of a pre processor such as petrel , however unlike eclipse Tnav can run regardless of error with the data file . 
 ]]> 2018-04-09 10:02:03 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249710818 Cheng lina 1001232802 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249719910 I think tNavigator is  easier to use. it simpler and more convenient than Eclipse, because it doesn't need other software to help it, and it also runs faster.

]]> 2018-04-09 10:42:19 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249719910 Dheneshwari 1001437564 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249730958 The Navigator gives more of a raw workspace view of the resource structure, while the navigator shows more of a logical view provided by contributions from various projects to show logical structure. ]]> 2018-04-09 11:31:12 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249730958 Azha 1001130439 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249734919 Tnavigator provide reservoir simulation services using only one software . Where as eclipse has more than one software they include prepossecor and modelers . Tnavigator is more user friendly than eclipse  ]]> 2018-04-09 11:46:05 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249734919 Ng Wei Kent 1001436947 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249805260 T nav is better as it is more advance compared to Eclipse. Every function found from eclipse, office and petrel can be found on the screen of Tnav and it is user friendly. 

]]> 2018-04-09 13:58:55 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/249805260 Akash 1001231631 akashm2124 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/250084842 Tnavigator  requires dealing with only a single interface as compared to dealing with more than one that is seen in Eclipse simulator. In addition, complicated geological structure cannot proceed without the use of pre-processor in Eclipse.]]> 2018-04-10 01:21:15 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/250084842 Sivarajan Esvaran 1001437921 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/250253052 In my perspective, Tnav is far more better in many aspects compared to eclipse. For instance, eclipse needs petrel which is a pre processor to run a model. Whereas, Tnav does not required any kind of pre processor and will help to save many time.]]> 2018-04-10 13:23:02 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/250253052 Kirubhakaran 1001335252 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/250275011 tnavigator is much simpler to understand the behavior of the reservoir than eclipse.Because tnavigator has run time where we can analyse the process and tnavigator does not require any pre processor.]]> 2018-04-10 13:59:18 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/250275011 https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/329753433 2019-02-11 08:12:41 UTC https://padlet.com/bondpeace99/iq3bm9ui3cz5/wish/329753433