"A Human Right" Discussion POIs by MANUEL LORENZO M. ALDEGUERIV https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd By clusters, write down 3-5 guide questions or points of interest (POI) on "A Human Right" by Rosario Cruz-Lucero. We will vote on which items we will devote time for during our class discussion. en-us 2025-07-22 08:34:34 UTC 2025-07-29 04:42:36 UTC hello@padlet.com Guide Question 1 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528697575 How does the importance of a significant place like Intramurous which holds many important events give context to the story?

]]> 2025-07-25 11:05:56 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528697575 Guide question 2 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528698016 How does the story give understanding to human right here in the Philippines?

]]> 2025-07-25 11:07:05 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528698016 Guide question 3 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528698201 How does trauma affect the openness and choice of words people use based on the text?

]]> 2025-07-25 11:07:41 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528698201 Guide question 4 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528698419 What role does other factors in the story contribute to Isabell’s actions?

]]> 2025-07-25 11:08:22 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3528698419 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529290246 (POI) Isabel who reports on the injustices and human right violations of targeted killings has partaken in targetted killings herself.

]]> 2025-07-26 23:34:12 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529290246 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529290384 Does isabel’s family being responsible for the loss of bagabo land make the dad’s  death justifiable/deserved? Is education and resources provided by those in power enough reason to be thankful and to forgive the loss of autonomy?

]]> 2025-07-26 23:35:06 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529290384 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529290506 Are the people who are in similar positions to Elias set up to be criminals/discriminated against from the very beggining?  How does this compare to people like isabel with her own privledge shown throught the story? how does her privledge affect her relationship with the city and people of intramuros?

]]> 2025-07-26 23:36:50 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529290506 Kaneshiro Ong https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815421 How does the story explore the theme of revenge?

]]> 2025-07-28 04:17:39 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815421 Sebastian Lim https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815459 Is Elias to be blamed or is society the problem?

]]> 2025-07-28 04:17:42 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815459 Alfred Crespo https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815724 What does the story say about justice? Is revenge justice?

]]> 2025-07-28 04:18:08 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815724 What do the small actions in the story represent in real society? jbggarcia27 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815728 2025-07-28 04:18:09 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815728 Seth Koa https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815765

  • What is the significance of the Casa Manila in painting the backdrop of the story. is it an allegory for something in the Philippines?

    • ]]>     2025-07-28 04:18:13 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815765     Bryan Ng https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815854 How does Gender or Power correlate to the abuse of human rights in the story?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:18:25 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815854     Anton Quito https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815900 How does the name "A Human Right" match with the story? (themes and events)

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:18:30 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529815900     Ethan Nolasco https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816177 In the end, how justified are Isabel's actions?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:18:58 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816177     What did the ending make you realize about human rights today? https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816178 2025-07-28 04:18:58 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816178 Giuliano Ng https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816430 To what extent can injustices be fought with violence, seeing as how Isabel brought a gun to kill Elias?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:19:26 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816430     Santiago Ramirez https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816498 Why was Isabel still friends with Elias (her dads killer)?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:19:36 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816498     https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816554 How does Isabel's role as a human rights researcher shape the narrative we receive?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:19:45 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816554     What is ironic about the title in relation to the story? jbggarcia27 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816597 2025-07-28 04:19:46 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816597 https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816616 How does the story show the line between justice and revenge, considering Isabel's decision to bring a gun and confront Elias?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:19:49 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816616     Yousef Cua https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816744 What does Elias past tell us about how society treats indigenous people?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:20:05 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816744     How does racism and social status play an important role in the story? https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816960 2025-07-28 04:20:33 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529816960 . https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529817314 How is the story accurate when it came to portraying crime in the Philippines?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:21:03 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529817314     How does Elias's identity as an indigenous Bagobo affect the choices he makes? https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529817468 2025-07-28 04:21:21 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529817468 Rafael See https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529817614 Is Elias a Victim portrayed as a villain or a villain trying to make him see like he is the victim.

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:21:35 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529817614     Joaquin Say https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529818022 If Isabel didn't steal the money, would Elias still have joined the DDS?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:22:10 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529818022     https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529819254 Could social injustice be explored as a theme in this short story?

    ]]>     2025-07-28 04:24:06 UTC https://padlet.com/manuelmaldegueriv/igqxcw2ubk47tfsd/wish/3529819254