ENGV111 😉 by MOLATELO FELICIA https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw Made with an open mind en-us 2021-03-31 05:58:04 UTC 2025-11-24 15:09:25 UTC hello@padlet.com molatelo2016_2 https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1427884644 2021-04-17 08:06:09 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1427884644 molatelo2016_2 https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428017886 The title of our analyzed short story is Who is Irish ]]> 2021-04-17 10:16:15 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428017886 Mokwena Tumelo Donna Student no 37978802 donnatumelo557 https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428216392 2021-04-17 13:35:45 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428216392 Mokwena Tumelo Donna Student no 37978802 donnatumelo557 https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428534966
Names: Tumelo Donna
Surname: Mokwena
Student Number: 37978802
Group 7 

Who ῾s  Irish
Theme
Accepting  Cultural  Difference

It is one of the main theme of the story , Gish Jen  realized  and was familiarized  with  the  differences  that  are in their home ,China and America  traditions and customs even the beliefs and values played a vital   role towards the beginning  of the story .

When Gish  Jen   described her traditions  and values  in  China at the beginning of  the  story , and she explained how she was raised according to this   traditions and customs  and how she also tried to influence her  granddaughter to also live according to the  same   traditions and  have the same values  .

Importance of Companionship

At the end of the story  Gish Jen  met a  woman named Bess, and  decides to move  in with  her  . She  then realizes  how much she has improved  when she moved in with Bess , how she felt having a true friend  like her in her life . This  showed  how the author ῾s character  improved at the end of the story .


]]> 2021-04-17 17:38:05 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428534966 banzakhumza https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428645490 2021-04-17 18:50:49 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428645490 analyzing character msizimncube321 https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428677068 Msizi Mncube
student number: 34941940
group 7
Who’s Irish character analyzation 

 

THE GRANDMOTHER (narrator): 

*the characters on this story are described implicit.

* on this short story the grandmother is the protagonist. *she is a 68-year-old Chinese immigrant.

* she is the mother of Natalie who will be later discussed.

* the grandmother looks after her granddaughter. 

*the grandmother is determined that her granddaughter should be raised on proper Chinese morals or ways.  

* during the story we found out that Natalie doesn't approve on  the ways her mother(narrator) is trying to raise Sophie (Natalie’s daughter) , so they end conflicting. 

*We also find out that the grandmother struggles to speak English

NATALIE (narrator's daughter): Natalie is a 28-year-old Chinese women who is married to an Irish. 

*she has a daughter called Sophie. Natalie has a parenting style that is more opposite than that of her mother's. 

*she believes that a child should be spoken to rather than being spanked. 

* this character is being displayed as a person that has no morals and disrespectful towards her mother(narrator) thus we see that when she calls her mother "crazy". 

 * she ends up chasing her mother out the house, this also shows us that Natalie has a negative personality

SOPHIE (narrators’ granddaughter): Sophie is a 3-year-old mixed-race girl. 

*she is the daughter of Natalie and John; she is also the granddaughter of the narrator.

 *Sophie is a very stubborn and wild child that does not listen when she is being warned.

 * We also find out that Sophie hates her grandmother and she ends up giving her the nickname "Meanie".

JOHN (narrators’ sin in law): 

* john is Natalie's husband and a father to Sophie.

 * john appears to be an understanding person and has a good personality he also appears to be the only one who is not against the grandmother.

 *john is found out to be a person who is always depressed. 

*his character also appears as a person who struggles to find a job

]]> 2021-04-17 19:17:09 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428677068 lethokuhled5 https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428692089 2021-04-17 19:29:59 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428692089 molatelo2016_2 https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428773219 Maphala Felicia molatelo
36608246 
Who is Irish 
Group 7
The plot 
1.exposion 
At the beginning of the story Gish Jen narrates that in her culture China mixed children are supposed to be smart, she believes her granddaughter sophie is smart but she says the problem is that she is wild unlike her mother Natalie or her grandmother. Also it was revealed that Gish Jen's husband was afraid of her even the busboys and cooks were scared of her because she was too fierce. She narrates that since her daughter is married to the Shea family the Irish as she regards them, she believes that Chinese people beat the Irish when it comes to hard work on the rail road. Natalie didn't like it when her mother used the Irish word

RISING ACTION
GIsh Jen mentioned that John is unemployed and ironically four brothers in the family and not even one is working and that is an interesting fact and they stay with their mother who got sick while working and had to retire. Gish Jen compares her daughter's in laws with her progress with her husband as Chinese in America. She does not understand her son in law mainly because he has no job and cannot take care of Natalie and Sophie. She refers to him as plain boiled thinking even his name is plain boiled using sarcasm. Gish Jen believed Sophie's Chinese side is being swallowed by her wild Shea side because they one had went to a park together when Sophie took off all her clothes in public and threw them in the fountain and laughed like a crazy person and Natalie seemed to have no problem with her doing that and her grandmother suggested spanking her and Natalie refused because she believed you can talk with a child not spank them. 

CLIMAX
Gish Jen would deny Sophie snack, lunch, no park if she took off her clothes and as stubborn she was she would go six hours without eating anything and when her mother comes back she would cry about being hungry all the time. Sophie continued taking off her clothes until one day her grandmother spanked her not too hard but she cried and cried. One day she eventually stopped taking off her clothes and they went to the park and she behaved like a nice Chinese girl. One day bigger trouble came when Sophie hid in the foxhole with a shovel full of sand and threw it at her grandmother on her clean nice clothes, when she was called out to apologize she refused and stayed in the fox hole and literally yelled "I hate you meanie" it got late and her grandmother left her alone at the park because she refused to come out of the foxhole, she used a stick to chase her out once or twice n hit her but she did not come out, she left her granddaughter there. 

FALLING ACTION 
it was during dinner time when she was worried and went back to the park, she called out her name and still there was no answer, she poked and poked with a stick and when she poked harder Natalie and John appeared. Natalie called her mom crazy yet John seemed to be calm and not asking questions like Natalie he actually had answers, Sophie was found to have fell asleep in the deep hole and she started crying and crying and seemed scared according to John and she had bruises all over her brown skin. Gish Jen was called crazy and kicked out of the house because she used a stick instead of words. 

RESOLUTION
Ness who is Natalie's mother in law made Gish Jen an offer to move in with her family and she agreed because she had nowhere to go or she could do with some company. When Natalie visits she no longer bring Sophie with her. John lost his job again and he was referred to as a depressed husband. Although they could not afford a nanny rather  than asking for the grandmother's help they hire a younger baby sitter who can run around with Sophie. At this point she no longer uses the word Irish because she has become a honorary Irish herself and Bess likes to tease her and calls her Irish and she responds by saying who is Irish? ]]> 2021-04-17 20:52:03 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428773219 banzakhumza https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428832448 2021-04-17 21:57:31 UTC https://padlet.com/molatelo2016_2/if6031zgtgpt4tvw/wish/1428832448