Remake of Module 3, Lesson 30 Socratic Seminar by Finn da Bin

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Elisa Carbone descibes Richard's experience in Jamestown tough because of conflict with the Powhatans. "'Did the Indians try to kill you?"' (Carbone 114). The Native Americans don't like the settlers, resulting in them trying to get rid of them. However Sally Walker explains Richard's experience as short lived since he died in a quick span of being in Jamestown. "...he had only recently arrived from England when he died" (Walker 42).

Addison, Liam, Annie, Nick

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Maddie, Emily,Jaden,Max,Tucker :)

In Blood on the River Richards experiences more friendship with Samuel. "Richard is much better now, I am releived, I decide to take a step towords to becoming his friend"(Carbone 79).

Walker describes Richard experience in Written in bone painful. "Once the infection had spread, JR1225B would have been in severe pain probably worse than before"(40).

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Sally Walker described Richard's time in Jamestown short-lived and maybe even a little wasteful she mentioned ,"that he had recently arrived from England when he died,"(Walker 42). However, Elisa Carbone describes his time fully mentioning all sorts of stuff he's done there. Also, instead of dying in Jamestown Elisa Carbone has Richard return back to England. "Richard... you will accompany me in England," (Carbone 194).(┛✧Д✧)┛彡┻━┻

Gabriel Brooke Brayden Madison R.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Walker says that Richard was in pain from his jaw infection. "The most serious problem by far, however, was a raging, ongoing infection in the boys lower jaw... the injury would have caused intense pain" (Walker 39). On the other hand, Carbone shows him living a regular life for people in Jamestown, not that he was in any pain like Walker says.

Carter, Finn, Charlotte, and Nina

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

In Blood on the River, Elisa Carbone makes Richard leave Jamestown with Captain Smith. "They turn for one last look at the Virginia shoreline and our fort and the group of us waving to them"(Carbone 204). In contrast, The archaeologists find Richard in a grave at James Fort. "His disappearance from the historical record suggests he may have died in 1607"(Walker 43). Elisa Carbone has Richard living past 1607 and traveling back to England with Captain Smith, Sally Walker writes that Richard died in about 1607 and that they found his grave.

Vivaan, Aiden, Kayleigh, Luisa

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

From the book Blood on the River, Elisa Carbone writes that Richard goes with Captain Smith to venture back to England. "Captain Smith and Richard ride the longboat to the ship" showing that the two of them and some others have safely gone thought the hardships of the New World and are heading back home (Carbone 204).

On the other hand, Richard is shown to have lived a painful life and died as an act of violence around when they first arrived at the New World back in 1607. From the book Written in Bone, Sally Walker states that, "His disappearance from the historical record suggests he may have died in 1607" which further proves that Richard didn't live that long in Virginia (Walker 43).

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Maddie.W, Emily, Max,Jaden,Tucker

Carbone introduces Richard in chapter 2 as Samuel punches Richard this proves "they are enemies"(Carbone 20) in the beginning of the book. Then they are put together as the two boys to go to Jamestown."Richard was to serve Reverand Hunt and I was to serve Captain John Smith"(Carbone 7).

In the begining of the book Walker introduces Richard as "a fitting canidate of JR1225B"(Walker 43)

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Elisa Carbone introduced Richard as a boy who builds his relationship with Samuel and does not die in the book. "It seeems as if I have finally learned to be a friend, to open my heart and care" (Carbone 196). This evidence shows how Samuel viewed Richard as a friend, and that Richard did not die in Blood on the River. In Written in Bone, however, Richard is shown as "a fitting candidate for [a Jamestown skeleton]" (Walker 43). Sally walker includes the fact that Richard is the identity of a skeleton found in Jamestown. So, in Written in Bone, Richard is instead the one who dies, so Richard surviving in Blood on the River is fictional.

Adidson, Nick, Annie, Liam

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

In Blood on the River by Elisa Carbone Richard is introduced as a orphan boy who ,"younger than [Samuel] by a year and a bit shorter and broader, with dark serious eyes," (Carbone 12). In contrast Written in Bone by Sally M. Walker introduces Richard as a mysterious skeleton labeled JR1225B. "Hudgins dug farther until a flash of tan caught his eye as he wiped away the soil, he saw bone. The Jamestown discovery project was about to meet JR1225B,"(Walker 21).

(┛✧Д✧)┛彡┻━┻ Gabriel Brayden Brooke Madison R.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Carbone introduces Richard as Reverend Hunt's servant. We also here about Samuel and Richard's fight. We also get a description of Richard on page 100, "He is a couple inches shorter than I am, and somewhat wider"(Carbone 100). Also on page 8 she explains him as younger than Samuel, and he has dark, serious eyes. Walker describes Richard in a different way. "They determined the teenager's height was about 5'8""(Walker 38).

~Kayleigh,Luisa,Aiden,Vivaan

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Richard is introduced by Elisa Carbone when Samuel says, "we are the two boys Reverend Hunt decided to bring with him on his journey to the New World ( Carbone 7 )." This shows how Richard was going to be an important part in Samuel's life in Jamestown. In Written In Bone, Richard is introduced as JR1225B, the skeleton Carter Hudgins dug up and studied. "The Jamestown rediscovery project was about to meet JR1225B( Walker 21)." This shows how they found Richard a studied his skeleton.

Carter, Finn, Charlotte, and Nina

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Around the start of the book Blood on the River, Richard is shown to be one of "the two boys Reverend Hunt decided to bring with him on this journey to the New World" (Carbone 7). This evidence hints to the fact that Richard might be quite important further in the book as he was also chosen for a reason to go on the journey.

From the book Written in Bone Richard is first introduced when Hudgins was digging "Until a flash of tan caught his eye... The Jamestown Rediscovery Project was about to meet JR1225B" (Walker 21). The way that Richards skeleton was introduced to the reader brought to them in a way that tells the reader that JR1225B was going to be a huge turning point in the chapter.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Elisa Carbone first introduces Richard as a "doomed" orphan boy that is going to the New World with Samuel. "The orphanage is not a bad place...Richard's tooth only fell out because it was already loose when I punched him,"(Carbone 7). She shows this in a kind of funny way by first mentioning his name as someone Samuel has punched before.

Sally Walker introduces Richard as an excavated Jamestown skeleton with the code name JR1225B. "To hear Carter Hudgins talk about finding bones is to understand what makes moments like this so extraordinary,"(Walker 22). Walker additionally describes the find as "extraordinary" as seen in the evidence above. The discovery of these bones was an important moment to those present in the informational text that are in the field of forensic anthropology, science, and history.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Other colonies besides Jamestown may have grown bigger than Jamestown. As well as that, the population of Jamestown may have died out due to Native American attacks, starvation, or infection as suspected happened to Richard Mutton.

Liam, Nick, Annie, Addison.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Emily,Maddie,Ticker,Max,Jaden.

"In 1698, after a fire destroyed an important government building in Jamestown, the capital was moved to the city of Williamsburg"(Walker 53).

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

This occurred because there was a war with the Natives and the colony got destroyed.

Carter, Finn, Charlotte, and Nina

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Jamestown was once the capitol of the colony, but isn't anymore. This happened because the English evoled from the original settlement to bigger cities. The Native Americans got sick from Europe on disease giving the English more room.

(┛✧Д✧)┛彡┻━┻ Gabriel Brooke Brayden Madison R.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Maddie.W, Emily, Tucker,Jaden,Max

In Blood on the River, "Richard is younger than I am by a year and a bit shorter and broder with dark serious eyes"(Crabone 12).

Walker describes Richard as a 14 year old boy who dies in 1607. He was also "about 5ft 8in (1.7m) unusually tall for a boy his age"(Walker 38).

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Elisa Carbone described Richard as a kid that's ,"a bit shorter and broader," than Samuel (Carbone 12). In contrary Walker says he was ,"5 feet 8 inches, unusually tall for the sixteenth century,"(Walker 38) showing the difference in heights between books. (┛✧Д✧)┛彡┻━┻

Brayden, Gabriel Brooke Madison R.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Elisa Carbone described Richard as "younger than [Samuel] by a year, and a bit shorter and broader, with dark serious serious eyes"(Carbone,12). Sally walker explains that Richard had to endure a "ongoing infection in [his] lower jaw"(Walker,42).

Addsion, Annie, Liam, Nick

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Carbone describes Richard as "a bit shorter and broader, with dark, serious eyes ( Carbone 12 )." This shows the descriptiveness of Richard in Blood on the River. Walker describes Richard as someone who is older but died recently after he came to Jamestown. "Richard Mutton, certainly seems like a fitting candidate for JR1225B ( Walker 43 )." This shows how scientists think that Richard Mutton is JR1225B.

Carter, Finn, Charlotte, and Nina

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

In Blood on the River, Elisa Carbone describes Richard's character as "younger than [Samuel] by a year, and a bit shorter and broader, with dark, serious eyes"(Carbone 12). In contrast, Sally Walker says in Written in Bone that Richard was about 14, and that he was about 5 feet and 8 inches tall. This shows how each book describes Richard differently.

Vivaan, Kayleigh, Aiden, Luisa

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Using multiple texts to build knowledge on the same topic can provide more information and even help you find biased and untruthful words. In Blood on the River, Richard lives to at least the Summer of 1609, meanwhile, in Written in Bone, Richard dies in 1607 according to historical records and stable isotope analysis.

Liam, Nick, Annie, Addison.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Maddie, Emily,Tucker,Jaden, Max

Using multiple texts allows more opinions and ides which can enhance the readers knowledge of the topic even more.

Two texts can differ but also be similar.

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Multiple text give different view point and that Richard survived in Blood on the River but not in real life.(┛✧Д✧)┛彡┻━┻ Brayden Gabriel Madison R. Brooke

finnguth — 2025-05-05 13:19:07 UTC

Using multiple texts to gain knowledge helps readers to explore multiple viewpoints on a single topic/character. This will lead to them having an open mind when it comes to taking in even more opinions about something.