HeLa Case Study by Cynthia Brito https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion Post your response here. Reply to at least another student's post (minimum of two sentences per response). en-us 2023-10-23 14:47:11 UTC 2023-10-25 01:24:08 UTC hello@padlet.com HeLa cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761466076 I think you should decide how your cells are used. Because you are entitled to the way your body is being used.

People can profit from a patients cell as long as the patient receives a profit too.

HeLa cells led to the growth of the human cell line.

Social issues have influenced the case because people who aren’t as fortunate have a harder time with affording the care.

Henrietta’s family should be given compensation for the use of her cells. Because I believe that’s what she would have wanted. -Taylor Brown


]]> 2023-10-24 17:31:01 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761466076 HeLA cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761467185 Who should decide how your cells are used? Why? In my opinion i would say your family members or your husband.


Should someone be able to profit from a patient's cells? Why or why not? Again in my opinion i would say yes because if its going to help other people then yes.


What good came out of the research on HeLa cells? They discovered how the HPV can lead to different types of cervical cancer.


How might have social issues (e.g., poverty, education, religion) influenced the case? It can influence educational ideas.


Should Henrietta's family be given compensation for the use of her cells? Why or why not?

Yes they should've been given compensation because maybe her family would've allowed it to happen .

-Josy

]]> 2023-10-24 17:31:44 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761467185 HeLa Cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761471699 I believe that the choice of whether or not your cells can be used for research is not entirely your decision. Unless you are put in physical and mental pain, however, they should not be used for commercial use and should stay for medical improvement only. HeLa cells have helped tremendously throughout the history of medicine from when they were first discovered. As most if not all modern-day medicine was made with the help of these cells most recently, they were used for the COVID vaccine. For something like this, this is kinda of the building block of medicine, I do believe people should be compensated including her family (At least free health care). But I wouldn't agree to give credit to everyone who donated a little bit of cells as you should do it for the betterment of society and not your personal wealth. I believe that there was some case of racial discrimination as while yes the text states that regulations weren't as strict I feel like if she was a white lady there would be stricter. And I feel at the time this happened that if it did happen to someone that was white there right of compensation would've been fought harder for.

-Abdrabo Alwahishi

]]> 2023-10-24 17:34:52 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761471699 HeLa cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761474384 I should decide how my cells are used because they are mine. The patient or their family should be the ones to profit off the cells because they are related. The goodness from the research of HeLa cells is the growth of the human cell line. The social issues caused the colored patients to be in a separate hospital which probably wasn't as good. Henriettas fam should be given compensation for the use of her cells because they are related. -Brielle

]]> 2023-10-24 17:36:44 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761474384 HeLa Cells- Andrew Hartman https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761474844 I think that the people whose cells are being used should be able to choose what happens with their own cells, since if they don't want a piece of their body to be gone, no one should be able to take it away. I think someone should be able to profit from a patient's cells as long as it's good for everyone, but if they exploit it by making it super expensive, that shouldn't be allowed as then not everyone would be able to access it. Lots of good vaccines that have prevented vicious diseases have come from the research of HeLa cells, like the prevention of Polio. I think social influences like poverty have influenced the case because these big time doctors gained lots of money, and were borderline unethical with how they went about collecting the cells, and some people that don't have as much money aren't able to afford the proper medicines, some that were made from these HeLa cells. I think that Henrietta's family should receive some compensation as many big companies made billions of dollars and can afford to give this family some money in exchange for the amazing cell that has saved many lives.

]]> 2023-10-24 17:37:03 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761474844 HeLa cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761476670 I think I should be the one who decides what's done with the rest of my cells becuase it is basically the prefecture to my being and profits of my cells should be split partially to my family or something like that.i believe that the research put into discovering a breakthrough in anything should give credit to both the scientist and the patient.I think the fact that Henrietta was black and the fact that racism was more abundant in 1900, morality towards African American people was treated negatively and definitely effect how doctors treated her.

]]> 2023-10-24 17:38:16 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761476670 HeLa Cella char4935 https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761477056

I think that everybody should be able to decide how their cells are used. Its their cells so let them choose how they can be used.

I think people should be able to profit off of a patients cells but only of the patient receives some profit.

One thing good that came from HeLa cells is that they found out that it can lead to cervical cancer.

Some people might not be able to afford the care that they need

I think they should be given compensation because its their own family members cell that they used and they discovered a lot of new things from it.

]]> 2023-10-24 17:38:32 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761477056 noemi 🐤 https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761479463 · You should be the person to decide what your cells are used for.

· Unless a doctor got proper consent from their patient, there should be no reason for them to profit off of them.

· There were a lot of good things that came from HeLa cell research. Scientists learned more about genetics and different kinds of diseases.

· I think if Lacks wasnt disadvantaged, she wouldve gotten asked for some sort of consent if not compensation for her cells and the discoveries that were made because of them.

· Henriettas family definitely deserves compensation, especially because their mothers cells has helped so many people. There is no excuse to not give them anything.

]]> 2023-10-24 17:40:03 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761479463 mariela 🤓 https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761480151 you should be the one who chooses how your cells are used since they’re YOUR cells, but i do think your family could also have a say if you’re dead or something.

i think as long as the patient is also profiting off of their cells then it would be okay for that someone to profit off of their cells.

because of hela cells, we have been able to test vaccines, learn about genetics, developing drugs, etc.

social issues played a part of the case because lacks was a black woman who suffered poverty and didn’t have (her family) a say or had gotten profit from her own cells.

lacks family definitely should’ve gotten compensation for the use of her cells since she’s the reason why many vaccine/test worked out in the first place.

]]> 2023-10-24 17:40:31 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761480151 HeLa cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761480544 1.i think if the actual good it will do is worth more than i think the reserchers its really mockville but they should

2.no i dont think you should be able to profit off cells honestly i think all healthcare should be free

3thier is so much that has come out of this like cancer prevention and aids and helped us learn about both of those

4.porvety and racism both affected this issue cause they where poor but the compaines profited majorly off the cells and at the time they where treated like lower class citzen

  1. they should be loaded they shouldn't just be compensated they should absolutely rich like millions of dollars

]]> 2023-10-24 17:40:46 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761480544 Summer Vaughn https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761481876

• Who should decide how your cells are used? Why? - You should be the only one to decide how your cells are used. You know yourself better than anybody, and whether or not the cells would be going towards “good or bad cause” doesn’t matter. it should be your right to choose what happens to YOUR body and therefore YOUR cells.

• Should someone be able to profit from a patient's cells? Why or why not? - Yes. I think that as long as the patient gets a fair percentage of the profit then the scientist who had the skills and patience to create whatever they did with the cells also deserves some of it.

• What good came out of the research on HeLa cells? Many vaccines and medicines were created, lots of research on different diseases was conducted because of HeLa cells.

• How might have social issues (e.g., poverty, education, religion) influenced the case? - During the time that Henrietta was alive, people of color were definitely not respected and treated the same as they are today. Even if they did have Henrietta’s personal consent at the time, I doubt much compensation would’ve been given. Along with the fact that she was uneducated and living in poverty, scientists had an easier time disregarding her rights and identity and were able to get away with lots more.

• Should Henrietta's family be given compensation for the use of her cells? Why or why not? - Definitely. Henrietta and her family deserved to know what she contributed to American healthcare. Henrietta most likely would have wanted her family to be included in the compensation as well.


]]> 2023-10-24 17:41:38 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761481876 HeLa Cell https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761483067

  • In the context of medical research, informed consent from the patient or their legal representative should be the primary factor in deciding how a patient's cells are used. This is essential to respect an individual's autonomy and ethical considerations.

  • Profiting from a patient's cells can be ethically complex. While research and medical advancements are crucial, it's important to ensure that patients or their families receive fair compensation or benefits if their cells contribute significantly to commercial research or profit. Ethical guidelines and legal frameworks should be in place to strike a balance.

  • The research on HeLa cells has been immensely beneficial. HeLa cells have played a pivotal role in advancing medical science, contributing to the development of vaccines, genetics research, cancer and AIDS studies, and drug development. They have been invaluable in understanding and treating various diseases.

  • Social issues like poverty and limited access to education likely influenced Henrietta Lacks' situation. She, being a poor and uneducated black woman, may not have had the resources or knowledge to advocate for her rights, such as informed consent. Social disparities can affect how individuals are treated in the medical system.

  • There is a compelling argument for compensating Henrietta's family, considering the significant profits generated from HeLa cells. While it's challenging to retroactively address this, it highlights the importance of ethical considerations and informed consent in medical research. Ideally, fair compensation or support should be provided to the families of cell donors when their contributions lead to significant commercial gains.

    • -Joshua Aguilar.



    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:42:24 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761483067     HeLa Cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761483703 You should be able to decide what your cells are used for unless you let a scientist or doctor decide. This is because there may be a specific disease/ illness that you or someone you know may have experienced, and you want to contribute to its extinction. If you donate cells to science, you should be paid based on how successful they have proven to be. For example, if the cells you contributed worsen a type of illness, compensation should be out of the question.

    HeLa cells have provided useful insight into many diseases and their treatments, such as HPV, and how it leads to cervical cancer. Social issues may have had an impact on the case because many would consider it to be ethically immoral to use somebody's cells without consent. This can greatly reduce the amount of research conducted on the HeLa cells. Lastly, Henrietta's family should definitely be compensated. Not only were her cells used without knowledge, but they have also contributed a very generous amount to the treatment and prevention of various illnesses and diseases.


    -Alex Hinson

    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:42:48 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761483703     HeLa https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761484114 I believe that one’s self should always be the one to decide any medical decisions about their own person, I believe this because nobody knows your best interest apart from yourself whether good or bad. I don’t think it is a bad thing that scientists are profiting from a patients cells, without the researchers composing their experiments there would be no profit made in the first place. The good thing that came out of this study would be all the people HeLa has saved and helped. Henrietta was a poor, black women from an uneducated family, as quoted in the passage, I do believe this had a factor in the result of her not getting any compensation for her cells or even be given the decency to know that the doctor had taken and sent cells from her body. If she was wealthy and she was a fit for the social que I do believe things would’ve turned out differently. I certainly believe that Lacks family should be getting compensation from the profit being made off of her cells, absolutely. Without her cells most discoveries and the advancements we see today in the medical field would’ve have been discovered or possible.- Brooke

    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:43:04 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761484114     HeLa Cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761485395 Personally, I think the one whose cells they were. If they wanted my cells, I would want to be the one to say they can or can't use them. If in an event similar to this however, I'd say it's up to the family. I also think that the profit from those cells, or at least some of it, should go to the owner of the cells, as technically, it's a part of them that's just growing somewhere else, and so it's the same as if they wanted to use the person as a test dummy. And yes, while I do think that more things could have been done before the use of these HeLa cells, I will admit, they've done a lot for us as a species, from boosting our cellular research, to helping us fight new illnesses that we've discovered over the years, like Covid. Now, the whole consent thing and figuring what would happen with the cells, what the family gets out of it, all of that was figured out, although a lot later, and while in theory they could have said, those aren't your cells, and the other side saying the same back and forth forever, there's more to it than that. The family's financial situations could have affected their thoughts on if they should be paid for the what the cells have done, being related to them, or maybe they view the whole idea of science is something they refuse to believe due to religious thinking, all of those could have affected how the family, or even certain judges could have seen this, and how that case went. On the topic of how the family views if they should be rewarded or not, I personally think that they shouldn't. While yes, it is technically their family, it's not them, it's not any of their cells, and so they didn't actually do anything. Then again neither did the scientists, and that's where we're going to end it, because this is already longer than I wanted, and is way less coherent.

    Colby Hayes

    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:43:56 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761485395     HeLa Cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761486682 Your relatives should decide how your cells are used because it is your body. If it is useful for studies then the scientist should ask for permsiion first and noticfy how they will use it.

    I think you shouldn't make a profit because its unfair to the one that provided the cells and those who are also being tested on. If it helps with making cures or making vacinens to help reduce the chances of many viruses and sickness.

    What good came out of HeLa Cells is benifical because it led to the growth of human cell line.

    Social issues might influener the case because those who don't have medicai or any sort of program to help them afford would influence the case.

    The Henrietta's family should be given compensation for the cell of her cells because thats probably what she would of wanted.

    -xochitl

    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:44:48 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761486682     HeLa cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761487337 The person that should have power to decide how your cells should be used is by your family members. my reason is that your family members are the some of the only people which you could trust that would do the right thing when it is about the death of a family member.


    A person should not be able to profit from a patient's cell and that is becuase i had said earlier that the person that had passed by should not be used as an object and more less that even if there is profit from the persons cells that other people other than their family members since it is the only right reason to why i think this should not be allowed.


    The only good that came of HeLa Cells is that her cells helped many doctors have a better method to realize their research based on illnesses,how they affect the human body, and how to help cure it.


    Based on how the family was poor and colored many people took advantage of that and it badly affected Henrietta's health,her family's health and their economical disadvantages.


    Yes, based on how the profit came from a

    passed away relative since the power of what is done to HeLas cells they should have been given the profit of the selling of her cells.


    -Anthony Ramirez



    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:45:13 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761487337     HeLA Cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761487738 Ultimately, what happens with the cells of a person are up to them. If their cells can be used in any form of scientific research, that choice should be made by the owner of the cells. Also, the person should be entitled to some form of compensation if their cells result in any form of scientific breakthroughs or advancements.


    Hela's cells allowed for many different breakthroughs in the medical field, such as being able to test vaccines and medicines as well as researching genetics.


    When it comes to the case of Henrietta, her social class should have had little to do with how knowledge about her cells was spread. However it was likely that her being from a poor family caused doctors, who are of a higher social status, to not consider giving her the credit she deserved. Still, using her cells and not notifying her or her family about the actions is immoral, even for the sake of research.


    Henrietta's family should very well be given compensation for the use of her cells. Henrietta herself should have been compensated immediately after the discoveries were made after the use of her cells. Even more so her family because they are Henrietta's kin and suffered the most from the loss. Using Henrietta's cells for research, and eventually profit, without even notifying her family is unjust and unfair.

    Consider the following. You gave blood at a donation center. Without your consent, that blood was tested and part of it contained the necessary genetic makeup to cure a disease. However, in the midst of this cure being created and sent out, you both never knew of the use of your blood and were never compensated for the use of your blood without your permission. How would you feel?

    -Caleb Taft

    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:45:28 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761487738     HeLa Cells jriv4676 https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761490589 I believe we should be able to decide how our cells get used, seeing as it's still our body. We should have the choice to decide whether to donate or not, regardless of the circumstances. I do not believe that a doctor/researcher should be able to profit from a patient's cells after having a scientific breakthrough. It is their cells that have contributed so they should have some kind of monetary gain. The good that came out was a stable human cell line, that was grown itself. As well as helping test vaccines, learn more about genetics, research cancers, and AIDS, and develop drugs. The social issues of her situation definitely affected how the doctors/researchers went about things, as well as how important it was that they should've gotten a payment of sorts. Yes, they should be given compensation, because Henrietta is dead, which leaves the family members the only way to make the wrongs right. After all, it was their family member that helped these corporations make millions. - Janeily :0

    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:47:10 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761490589     HeLa Cells - Padraig Farrell https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761491313 I believe that you should be able to decide if your cells are used for something. I also believe that someone should be able to profit off of your cells as long as you are being compensating. The good that came from the research on HeLa Cells was the testing on vaccines, research into cancer, and helping developing drugs. Social Issues such as race and education might have influenced this case because if Henrietta did not give consent, I believe that the doctors may still have used her cells because of her education or even because she was in a segregated hospital. I do believe that Henrietta’s family should be compensated because HeLa cells have been used in the development of so many drugs and because they were unaware of the use of her cells.

    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:47:36 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761491313     HeLa Cells - Liz https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761494222 I believe you should be able to decide the fate of your family after you die. Though you can have the final say, something could happen after you die and your specific cells may be needed, and in that case, your family will need to decide for you due to the change in situation.

    People should be able to profit from your cells, but a portion of the profits should be given to the family of the deceased, as the family should benefit from the contribution of their family members to health science.

    People have used HeLa cells to further a lot of research that has saved many lives.

    Social issues such as education have influenced the case due to the research conducted due to the cells.

    Henrietta's family should have been given compensation for the use of her cells, as they had not consented and they have to pay for things her cells have probably created.


    ]]>     2023-10-24 17:49:23 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761494222     HeLa https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761498516

  • I believe the person who gave the cells should choose what should be done with them. if you can't cognitively think for yourself then family members should make the decision.

  • yes because that's their cells and genes they were part of the contribution. if they did have those cells then they would have any profit in the first place

  • a lot of good things came out of it such as new vaccines and medicine to help fight diseases . it is also the reason why we have the vaccines that we do today

  • it influences the case because it shows that if the Lacks family had gotten money from their family members then they would of not have been in the situation that they are in now. based on the reading it sounds like the situation that the lack family is in is a pretty rough situation

  • Henrietta's family should get compensation because she was never asked for her cell to be used that way. also if the cell we never gave the whole medical landscape would have changed big time.

    • ]]>     2023-10-24 17:51:55 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761498516     HeLa cells https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761512271 The family of the individual or the individual himself should be the one to consent if they want their cells being used. I feel this way b/c a lot of families can feel that their loved one is being violated by being used for sciences and not everyone believes in science.


    I believe the family should benefit from donating their family cells. B/c it would provide great benefit for the family.


    HeLa cells provide a great research base for a lot of scientist. It can survival outta the human body and can be used for tests.


    Those factors can negatively affect the family b/c they can be forced to donate the family member and be played outta money.


    Yes Henriette family should be given something, even if it was years ago. The mistake happened but can be fixed.


    Luna Colon


    ]]>     2023-10-24 18:00:54 UTC https://padlet.com/cynthiabrito3/cancerdiscussion/wish/2761512271